Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
G-623 Handley 12-18-2023
Current Planning Public Comments and Testimony °�EOQ� Please fill out the form, below,to submit written comments on a pending land use application or an appeal of a tree removal request.All written comments and materials are due by the deadline listed on the Notice. Written submittals received by the deadline will be entered into the public record of file and will be considered by the decision body. Contact the staff coordinator listed on the Notice if you have questions. Case Number* Please see Notice for correct LU or tree appeal number. LU 23-0002/AP 23-04:A request for an RP District(wetland) Unavoidable Crossing to Install a Sewer Line and Serial Lot Line Adjustments. If you do not see your case here the comment period is not open. Please check back later. Case Number- LU 23-0002/AP 23-04:A request for an RP District(wetland) Unavoidable Crossing Verification* to Install a Sewer Line and Serial Lot Line Adjustments. Please re-select your case number to ensure it routes to the appropriate case. First Name* Scott Last Name* Handley Address Street Address 18360 Delenka Lane Address Line 2 City State/Province/Region Lake Oswego OR Postal/Zip Code 97034 Email* scott@loveloparks.org Stance:* r Support Cr Opposition r Neither for nor against Please type your comments below,or you may upload a PDF of your comments. If you have other media types, please contact planning@lakeoswego.city to coordinate its addition to the public record. Comments This upload form is now restricting submissions to only 25 MB. I will be submitting multiple files to complete LoveLOParks full supplemental testimony. It is disturbing this restriction was put into place in between Nov 20,2023 and today without warning.The supplemental testimony is 95 pages with 23 exhibits. File Upload LU 23-0002_Supplemental-Statement-in- Oppostion_LoveLOParks-Steering-Committee-Part- 218.51KB 1-Pages-1-9.pdf PDF format only SUPPLEMENTARY STATEMENT IN OPPOSITION The LoveLOParks Steering Committee ("LoveLOParks SC") is submitting this additional new testimony in light of the City's release of the missing pages in "F-012 Staff Memo LU 20-0027" and "F-017 Chapter X Analysis Memo 12-15-2023". The development application LU 23-0002 sewer conditions are invalid and unlawful by Chapter X and the application as conditioned must be denied. 1. City Charter Preempts City Code A. Under a home rule charter, the voters have the ultimate, legal governing authority over their city parks and sewer system: Under Article XI, section 2, of the Oregon Constitution: "The legal voters of every city and town are hereby granted power to enact and amend their municipal charter, subject to the Constitution and criminal laws of the state of Oregon[.]" Under Article IV, Section 1(5), of the Oregon Constitution: "The initiative and referendum powers reserved to the people by subsections (2)and (3) of this section are further reserved to the qualified voters of each municipality and district as to all local, special and municipal legislation of every character in or for their municipality or district." B. The voters exercised that authority and limited park development in natural areas, including expressly limiting development of sewer facilities within those areas to those which benefit the users and visitors to the parks; the private sewer facility, in this case, does not meet the requirement of being for benefit of the park users and visitors, and is therefore, excluded from development: Lake Oswego voters exercised their Oregon Constitutional right to amend the City Charter to "insure all development within a Nature Preserve is consistent with the preservation of a Nature Preserve as a natural area"with citizen initiative petition 20201N-1 and the resulting citizens' Measure 3-568 ratified on November 2, 2021, with a 62% majority vote. As mentioned before, ratification of Measure 3-568 reset the LO voters' intent for Chapter X. Each Chapter X provision was precisely chosen to ensure the maximum protection and preservation of LO natural areas. The first provision is intentional to be maximally restrictive to development consistent with the preservation as natural areas. Our intent was broadly communicated, as all our exhibits have shown, to the LO voter population via the Lake Oswego Review Cities View and Opinion pieces, recognized consistently by the Lake Oswego review staff writers, and all our initiative and campaign materials shared via our website, social media, email subscription lists, and not once, but multiple times to nearly every voter household. The voters' intent is clear that the voters' mean to keep LO natural habitats in their most basic natural state undisturbed by development. Lake Oswego City Code is preempted by the powers and limitations granted by voters' in the City Charter; therefore, the voters' provisions in Chapter X- Park Development Limitation take ultimate precedence and the Community Development Code is preempted. The City staff and Deputy City Attorney's unsubstantiated opinions that Chapter X is not land use "standards and criteria" has no legal standing, and they do not have the authority to overrule the voters' charter amendment. Furthermore, the City directed the applicant to execute an invalid covenant after Measure 3-568 was ratified on November 2, 2021. The City was mandated by voters'to revised the sewer route directive to other available options on the passage of Measure 3-568 and failed to advise the applicant otherwise.Additionally, the applicant failed to execute the covenant before November 2, 2021, and didn't execute it until over 3 months later on February 23. 2022 (Exhibit 20). Additionally, the City Council on November 2, 2021, was informed the sewer would be installed by drilling (Exhibit 15). Drilling may or may not be authorized by Chapter X depending on the impacts to the natural habitat. But, sometime between the January 11, 2023 (Exhibit 21, Page 8) and June 22, 2023 (Exhibit 22, Page 8)the method changed from drilling to trenching. See Exhibit 23 for full timeline of events. C. Such an exercise of voter authority is also consistent with and carries out the delegation of the state land use laws to implement Goal 5 preservation to prevent loss of natural resources for the benefit of current and future generations. There is nothing temporary about cutting 14 trees and clearing a 17'x 525' section of natural habitat in Waluga Park- West for heavy construction vehicles to trench and install a sewer line for a private property owner. The ecological impacts and deterioration of the aesthetic qualities contradict everything the voters' intended by amending the City Charter to retain and preserve their Nature Preserves. Replanting vegetation and trees is not preservation. The scar will be real for decades. D. The Mayor, City Council, the City Attorney, the City Manager, City staff, and the DRC serve the City's owners, the voters', and do not have the authority to overturn the voters'decision to amend the City Charter to preserve Nature Preserves as natural areas by allowing Waluga Park-West's wetland destruction and loss of natural habitat for anyone. E. The Development Review Commission is commissioned by City Council, not City staff, and is bound by all Federal, State, and local statutes, laws, regulations, provisions and ordinances. Voters' hold the ultimate owner of authority and have not given their voter approval to the City for the development proposed in Waluga Park-West. The City's press release on November 2, 2021, on the passage of Measure 3-568 confirms and acknowledges that"Any future property-specific changes will include voter approval." 2. Supplemental Willful Blindness Since the ratification of Measure 3-568, the City has willfully failed to faithfully fulfill their obligation mandated by voters'to enact and operationalize the development restrictions imposed by Chapter X. On November 17, 2021, Ivan Anderholm Director of Parks and Recreation presented an impact report where by he stated: "So we've had, since the election, I've sat in on at least a half a dozen meetings with our city attorneys, both of our city attorneys, the city manager, the mayor, a couple of different counselors, to just talk about this. And then, Nancy Gronowski, who's here sent a, a questionnaire kind of a a thing that evokes some, some conversation that we had. So the city stance on implementation of of this charter amendment. So everybody understands where we're going with this. Unlike, charter amendment, that dictates we do something. This charter amendment really restricts what we can do on a specific list of properties. We talked about and discussed about looking at implementation ordinances, and, you know, how are we gonna manage this? And at the end of the day, the decision was made in the city manager and city attorney's office, with input from parks, that, we're probably we're not gonna do you're not gonna see an ordinance that's an implementation ordinance of, of measure 10 or chapter 10. What we have come up with in the city attorney's office and parks are in the process of drafting it right now. Is a, procedural document that talks about, development in any of these properties that are identified and it'll be, you know, and the initial will be the concept of what the public has asked for or what the parks board or the parks department wants to initiate in those properties." Audio: https://www.ci.oswego.or.us/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=1902052&dbid=0&repo=CityOfLakeOswego Minutes: https://www.ci.oswego.or.us/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=1942482&dbid=0&repo=CityOfLakeOswego 3. Supplemental Legislative Record Artifacts Unlike a referendum placed on the ballot by a governing body, like City Council's Measure 3-575 that only required the approval of 4 out of 7 council members, a local citizen initiative begins with a petitioning period that requires a minimum 15% of registered voters to sign the citizen initiative petition in order to qualify for the ballot. LoveLOParks volunteers logged thousands of hours over 18 months: - informing our community going door-to-door(pre-Covid), sending 40,000+ mailings to -15,250 households (-30,000 voters), and through our website, email, and social media - collecting over 4,800+voter signatures to qualify Measure 3-568 - obtaining prominent environment and conservation organization endorsements from Oregon Wild and Sierra Club Citizen initiatives aren't easy. They require tremendous patience, persistence, and perseverance—then, add a global pandemic, wildfires and ice storms. Nonetheless, the volunteers forged ahead ensuring our community could choose to enact proven, sensible legal safeguards protecting these natural treasures. LoveLOParks intentions for the citizen initiative petition 20201N-1, and thereby voters'intentions on ratifying Measure 3-568,prohibiting development that was inconsistent with maintaining Nature Preserves as natural areas and that a voter of the people is required before future prohibited development is considered was well communicated over our 2 year effort in all LoveLOParks petition and measure literature, shared on our website, social media, direct mail, and email subscription lists, as well as in the Lake Oswego Review by staff writers and LO citizens and the City of Lake Oswego. The electorate was well informed and educated. Even Sierra Club's testimony, G-589 Motz-Storey 12-09-2023, confirms the voters'intent is clearly expressed in Section 43's first provision. A. 2020IN-1: Citizen Initiative Petition-Supplemental Exhibit 1 We Must Protect Our Scott Handley • We have a strong interest in protecting these elements that Jan 9, 2020 Natural Areas contribute to the natural, cultural and aesthetic health of our community • It strengthens limitations on development that is incompatible and inconsistent with their natural conditions. • The community should be guaranteed these pockets of nature are left to remain in their natural condition. The community preserved Springbrook Park; we must now preserve these 15 natural parks. Exhibit 2 Our community Rosemary • "Citizens now want to protect these natural places through Jan 16, 2020 should decide Dicandilo the Lake Oswego City Charter so their use can only be changed by your vote." • "...yes, we DO WANT an initiative on the May ballot that "limits development"in our natural parks that is inconsistent and incompatible with preserving their natural conditions. " • "You never know what those "City improvements" might be." Exhibit 3 Save LO Parks Betsy Wosko • I encourage you to sign the petition to protect LO Parks, a Feb 6, 2020 Initiative: Remember citizen initiative for a city charter amendment which would Tom McCall provide some baseline of protection against commercial development for trees in 14 small parks, tracking the same protections Springbrook Park currently enjoys Exhibit 4 Don't take LO natural Claire Puchy • "There is a citizen's initiative that is worthy of our support to Oct 7, 2020 areas for granted ensure these are protected from inconsistent uses and development. " B. Measure 3-568 - Supplemental Exhibit 5 Love LO Parks Clara Howell • "...a measure on the November 2021 ballot that would July 7, 2021 measure will appear (Staff Writer) protect 15 parks from future development." on the ballot • "Lake Oswego community members have made their stance quite clear on leaving certain parks throughout the city as natural as possible..." • "...prevent 15 parks from any future development..." • "The Love LO Parks initiative would expand those limitations to 14 additional parks and natural areas— ... Waluga Park- West ...—and development would be limited to only what is necessary for the enjoyment of the natural spaces." Exhibit 6 Evaluating options Theresa • "The only park that is presently charter protected is July 14, 2021 on Springbrook park Kohlhoff Springbrook. It has been and remained so since 1978 despite measures attempts by the city to fudge." Exhibit 7 Council refers Clara Howell • "Love LO Parks claims its measure protects the parks in Aug 11, 2021 preservation (Staff Writer) their most natural element." measure to ballot • "Love LO Parks is a grassroots movement led by Lake Oswego community members to prevent 15 parks from any future development." • "The Love LO Parks initiative would expand those limitations to 14 additional parks and natural areas— ... Waluga Park- West ...—and development would be limited to only what is necessary for the enjoyment of the natural spaces." • "The concern is that with the various city councils, they don't look at the city parks as a unique asset. They're willing to exploit the parks for other purposes," lake Oswego resident Mike Louaillier told Pamplin Media Group, "The city politicians should not look at the parks as an asset to exploit. They need to be left alone." Exhibit 8 City Referendum is Theresa • "The citizen's initative merely brings the remaining Sept 22, 2021 attack on citizen Kohlhoff undeveloped parks into this protected status. The city's initiative referendum did not spring up spontaneously. It was a calculated attack against a true citizen's initiative to limit development" Exhibit 9 Vote to truly protect Michael • "Initiative 3-568 better protects our natural area parks... Oct 7, 2021 parks Kohlhoff places the current natural park areas into the Charter." • "Understandably, the large dollar donations to the Referendum's PAC [Measure 3-575] are by development, real estate and business individuals." • "The Sierra Club and Oregon Wild compared the two measures and strongly endorsed the Initiative [Measure 3-568] as better protecting our natural parks." • "Initiative 3-568 continues full protection." Citizens' measure Tom Finnerty • "3-568 (citizens measure)was written with the full and clear would fully protect intent to protect our parks without the influence of parks corporate development..." • "3-575 (City Council initiative)was written...coming from insiders' interest that allow expansion of development...and other items that don't protect our natural parks." Exhibit 10 The Devil's in the Ann Savage • "I've learned much about LoveLOPark's Measure 3-568 over Oct 13, 2021 details the last 18 months from their outreach efforts. They sent the full text of their proposed Charter amendment and quick reference—a simple read in plain English." • "I found a helpful resource with both measures'text and comparisons...You might find it useful too: loveloparks.org/ compare" Measure 3-568 has Ann Milkulka • "Residents have been working hard for the last 18 months... integrity to get Citizen's Measure 3-568 on the ballot. The driving force has been the shared belief that the Lake Oswego natural parks urgently need protection from development." • "...the entire area of each park will be protected under Chapter X." Don't be fooled Brad Home • "We can't trust the City of LO to protect our natural parks." • "3-568 is...focused on leaving our natural parks alone." • "Our natural parks should be protected and stay free from exploitation and development... Look to Woodmont Bill Jaurusch • "Woodmont Natural Park would be in a more natural state as when considering life-long resident Donald Meyer had intended under citizen- measures initiated Measure 3-568." • "There's no question Citizens' measure 30568 will improve protection of natural resource with endorsements from Sierra Club and Oregon Wild." Measure couldn't be Stephanie & • "Measure 3-568, led and funded by neighbors for 18+ more different John Detjens months, seeks to enshrine sensible legal definitions into our City's Charter for our natural parks, their acreage and boundaries, and development limitations. If ratified, these parks and protections can only be amended by voters. Springbrook Park's Charter Chapter X established by citizens in 1978 is proof positive that strong charter protections work." • "...our community has one opportunity to enact lasting legal protections for our natural parks. Sierra Club and Oregon Wild endorse 3-568; you should, too! No accident Kirsten • "Oregon Wild and the Sierra Club's Oregon Chapter chose to Sommer endorse Citizens' Measure 3-568. Let that sink in. These organizations are recognized leaders in environmental and conservation efforts. Their endorsements were neither accidental nor a token handout, but were achieved only after scrutiny of both the citizens' measure and the city council referendum. Both organizations have recognized that Measure 3-568's development limitations protect our natural parks best." Save your right to Anne Carter • "Save your right to vote on future similar development of vote our natural parks." Don't be fooled by Jeffrey • "If you want to restrict the development of our parks you city measure Bowman must vote yes on 3-568..." Exhibit 11 Citizens taking Scott Handley • "For decades, the City has failed to adopt strong protections; Oct 20, 2021 initiative therefore, citizens have taken the initiative. Over the last 24 months, hundreds of LO volunteers dedicated thousands of hours...to...craft a Charter amendment with precise, deliberate and intentional development limitations to protect 16 natural parks." • "...we forged ahead ensuring our community could choose to enact proven, sensible legal safeguards protecting these natural treasures." Exhibit 12 park measure debt is LO Review • "Crucially, the LoveLOParks measure also states that Oct 27, 2021 a matter of trust editorial projects outside of these limitations would need to be board , approved by voters in a May or November election. " LoveLOParks: Vote LoveLOParks • "Measure 3-568 started from a genuine concern to protect our yes on Citizens' Steering natural parks from city development ambitions." Measure 3-568 Committee • "The charter can only be altered by voters...This legal safeguard has protected Springbrook Park for 40+years." • "...development limitations to keep our natural parks safe, accessible, healthy, and vibrant natural habitats " • "We have no vested interest except protecting our natural parks for our community's continued enjoyment of their forests, meadows, and abundant wildlife and preserving our way of life." • "Over the last 24 months, we've mailed Measure 3-568's Charter text to -90% of voting households." • "Voters should read both full texts and not rely solely on the limited information within the Voters' Pamphlet....loveloparks.org/compare." Don't let politicians Michael • "We need to protect and preserve these natural areas exploit parks, natural Louaillier from development. Of the two competing ballot measures, areas only the citizens' initiated Measure 3-568 will pro-vide our natural parks with the strong legal protections needed." Voters deserve the Nancy • "I believe all LO citizens should have a voice if our natural facts Flemming park lands are to be developed." • "Only Measure 3-368 is endorsed by both the Sierra Club and Oregon Wild, and is the only one of these two disparate initiatives that empowers voters to decide any future development in our public natural parks." Not confused on Kirsty Reilly • "The Citizens' Measure 3-568 explanatory statement is measures concise and focused on protections limiting development; the arguments come from citizens with history about past City exploits and a genuine passion to protect nature." • "I'm with citizens who worked diligently bringing us Measure 3-568 to protect nature from development." Measure 3-568 is gift Mark • "The most"conservative" action toward our natural places is for the future Chambers to do nothing ... to leave it and allow just a bit of wild to remain. " • "...please give the wild places protection, and vote YES on Measure 3-568" • "Improvements mean desecration of unique and all too rare places." Don't miss chance to Anthony • "I enthusiastically support ballot measure 3-568 because it protect parks Tesoriero places sensible limits on the development of our natural parks" • "Protections provided by Measure 3-568 can only be removed by the voters" • "Oregon Chapter of the Sierra Club and Oregon Wild support Mea- sure 3-568, • "...preserve the few natural spaces we have left for current and future generations to enjoy. " Facts and the future Pierre • "...it's really about the planet you guys are leaving me..." Zubrinsky • "...the Sierra Club and Oregon Wild endorsed the citizen sponsored measure..." • "I'm not willing to give them [city] the key. That's why I'm voting yes on Measure 3-568" Let's keep our Mike and • "In 1975, the Emery Family granted the 42-acre Cook's Butte promises Debbie portion of their property to the people of Lake Oswego. The Wilkins city received this grant under the stipulation that it"be preserved in as close to a natural state as possible." • "What does it take to protect our natural parks from each new version of City Council? " What would Marjorie Jan i • "Please join those of us who have fought the City for almost do? Holibaugh 30 years to safeguard Cooks Butte, and now other wilderness parks. " Exhibit 13 Press Release: City of Lake • "Any future property-specific changes will include voter Nov 2, 2021 Citizen's Initiative Oswego approval." 3-568 Passes • "Love LO Parks elevated the issue of natural area protections for a broad set of acreage within the city" • "The City will share more information about the charter amendment process in the coming weeks. " Exhibit 14 Press Release: LoveLOParks • "...strong protections to conserve our cherished natural Nov 2, 2021 Citizen-initiated Steering areas..." Measure 3-568 Committee • "...development limitations to keep our natural parks Passes! natural..." • "Any future natural park changes that would involve development otherwise restricted by Chapter X will require voter approval " • "...conserving these natural habitats for future generations..." Exhibit 16 Love LO Parks Clara Howell • "Measure 3-568 put forth by Love LO Parks—a grassroots Nov 10, 2021 measure passes (Staff Writer) movement led by Lake Oswego community members to over competing city prevent 15 parks from any future development" measure • "We're proud our community recognizes the value of strong protections to conserve our cherished natural areas " • "Love LO Parks claims its measure protects the parks in their most natural element" • "The Love LO Parks initiative expands those limitations to 14 additional parks and natural areas— ... Waluga Park-West ...—and development will be limited to only what is necessary for the enjoyment of the natural spaces." • "The Love LO Parks measure also includes a requirement of voter approval for park projects that are outside the parameters laid out in the amended charter. " • "The city will eventually share more information on the charter amendment process. " Vote for parks is Scott Handley • "...voters have chosen to leave an everlasting legacy of historic moment wilderness to future generations. " • "They have chosen a legacy that conserves our natural habitats for the abundant wildlife that call them home and for future residents to enjoy all their splendor. " Exhibit 17 Unintended Corey • "...charter amendment designed to prevent development at Jan 12, 2022 Consequences Buchanan 15 parks and natural areas. " (Staff Writer) • "Love LO Parks claimed its measure would protect the parks in their most natural element..." • "...ensures that development is limited only to what is necessary for the enjoyment of natural spaces on 235 acres worth of land at...Waluga Park-West" • `...any projects outside of the ground rules set forth would need to be approved by citizens via a vote." Exhibit 18 Condemning LoveLOParks • "Measure 3-568 was ratified by 8,267 Lake Oswego voters, or Jan 20, 2022 council's words to Steering 62%, thereby enacting legal safeguards limiting voters Committee development in 15 Lake Oswego natural parks keeping them safe, accessible, healthy and vibrant natural habitats. " City recognizes will Mayor Buck • Protecting our natural area parks and the overall of voters enhancement of the ecosystem is a top priority for our City— as evidenced by our Climate Action Plan, the number of residents engaged in community-based environmental advocacy groups, our City investments in the enhancement and preservation of natural areas and by the passage of Measure 3-568 itself. Council should Matthias • "...prevent development at 15 parks and natural areas." respect will of voters Beckmann Respect the vote and Rosemary • "Voters were well-informed on Measure 3-568, a well- attend to more DiCandilo researched and strongly supported two-year effort by Lake pressing issues Oswego residents" Council, citizens Kathy Hanava • "I am dismayed by the LO City Council's comments that need to work togethe voters were "duped" and stupid to vote for Measure 3-568 which won by a large measure and required years of citizen effort to bring to a vote a measure to keep our parks as natural as possible. " To the members Pierre • "I didn't vote yes on the citizen sponsored initiative that of our City Council Zubrinsky protects our nature parks so that you, the city council could "tweak" it. " Exhibit 19 Voters weren't Virginia • "...I understand completely why the Love LO Parks was Jan 26, 2022 `duped' on Boden forced to do what they did by getting a vote of the people. parks measure The City has completely ignored the residents concerns L of safety and keeping the area natural. " Exhibit 1 We must protect our natural areas I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/17/23,11:38 PM https://PamplinMedia.com/lor/447644-363758 We must protect our natural areas Scott Handley Jan 9,2020 Lake Oswego is known as the"village in a park,"a place of physical beauty and respite from the expanding urbanized regions surrounding it.Our extensive tree canopy is a result of investment by the community in its natural parks, open spaces and environmental stewardship groups.We have a strong interest in protecting these elements that contribute to the natural,cultural and aesthetic health of our community. Recent events reminded us that stewardship is not enough.We've learned that Lake Oswego code allows for "conditional uses"in natural habitats that are inconsistent with preserving them as natural areas—a reactive process requiring enormous community involvement,time,effort and expense to appeal.We've also learned certain natural areas protected by deeds are insufficient and place these natural areas at risk for development.For decades, our City's adopted park plans have outlined steps to codify protections for these natural areas(e.g.heritage sites) with little substance to guarantee protection.Until we have a legal instrument that codifies the community's intent to preserve these natural areas,some will see opportunity to develop them. • .x LAKE,' OSWEGO r . 4' RAIN Spark .# G A L LER Y 44 - STAR1 411 HUNTING ;. HERE • - _ • In 1978,a community-led ballot initiative to"preserve Springbrook Park as a natural area"passed overwhelmingly,3- 1.This initiative enacted"Chapter X-Park Development Limitation"in the Lake Oswego Charter.This initiative prevented developing Springbrook Park into a major athletic facility.Recently,Chapter X protected Springbrook when the City considered expanding the Tennis Center into this natural area.Springbrook is the ONLY natural park with Charter protections. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/we-must-protect-our-natural-areas/article_f11fc808-81f9-58b9-a389-2b414d10a824.html Page 1 of 2 We must protect our natural areas I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/17/23,11:38 PM Now,we have an opportunity to codify protections for 15 additional City-designated natural parks in nine neighborhoods.Our community-led initiative,2020IN-1,takes a proactive approach by amending Chapter X to include these natural areas.It strengthens limitations on development that is incompatible and inconsistent with their natural conditions.It allows improvements to maintain safe and healthy ecosystems for wildlife,flora and fauna to thrive in their natural habitat and for residents to enjoy.It prohibits commercial logging.It expands the methods for including more natural parks in the future.It costs taxpayers NOTHING. These 15 natural parks are small and intertwined into the fabric of our neighborhoods and community.Their ecosystems are host to abundant wildlife and give many in the community refuge from the increasingly developed world.Several of these natural areas were gifts to our community by families who saw our innate human desire to develop these lands,and they wished them to remain forever wild.The community should be guaranteed these pockets of nature are left to remain in their natural condition.The community preserved Springbrook Park;we must now preserve these 15 natural parks. x Emergency Veterinary CLINIC OF TUALATIN Open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Even Holidays! i4.114 More Information The initiative process is our democratic mechanism that allows the community to participate in legislating rules governing our community.While the City-assigned ballot title to this initiative is imperfect-"Restricts improvements on certain Lake Oswego park properties,"our Charter text is crystal clear.It protects 15 Lake Oswego natural parks as nature preserves limiting development that is inconsistent and incompatible with their natural conditions. We need you!We need 4,365 Lake Oswego registered voter signatures to place our natural park preservation initiative on the ballot and allow our community to vote.Download the petition,print,sign,and send: https://www.loveloparks.orglpetition Scott Handley is a Lake Oswego resident. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/we-must-protect-our-natural-areas/article_f11fc808-81f9-58b9-a389-2b414d10a824.html Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 2 Readers' letters I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/18/23, 8:52 AM https://PamplinMedia.com/lor/448250-364764 Readers' letters The Review Jan 16,2020 School district needs to be fiscally responsible When the voters approved the Lake Oswego School District's capital improvements Bond Measure 3-8 in 2000,they were responding to a Lake Oswego School Board request that included funds for needed improvements for various elementary and secondary schools.Instead,after spending twice as much for Lakeridge High School as it had asked the voters for(an extra$8 million plus$8 million more for"surprises"),the school board delayed indefinitely most improvements to the elementary and secondary schools. When the voters approved the Lake Oswego School District's capital improvements bond measure in 2018,they were responding to a Lake Oswego School Board request that included a$7 million dollar swimming pool line item. For many decades the existing swimming pool has served both students and residents of the school district. x Adisacr Thai DINE-IN,DELIVERYAND TAKEOUTAVAILABLE YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD THAI RESTAURANT 1235 MCVEY AVE.SUITE A Now,we are told that the school board has asked the city to use parks and recreation funds approved by the voters to help build a new,much larger,much more expensive pool or pools at or near Lakeridge High School. Is it unreasonable for Lake Oswego voters to expect that the Lake Oswego School Board would actually carry out its commitments when it asks for money? Dennis O'Neil Lake Oswego Our community should decide You may believe our gorgeous Lake Oswego natural parks are protected from development.Our natural parks improve our quality of life and property values.They exemplify the sylvan character of our city.They provide solace to our souls and our beloved pets too.They even provide biological banks,of a sort,for an uncertain future. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/readers-letters/article_f6c54cc8-4103-59f3-8ab2-1202746adddb.html Page 1 of 2 Readers' letters I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/18/23,8:52 AM However,these areas are not fully protected.Even donated land that is supposed to be protected in perpetuity.When the third attempt in as many decades was made to develop Cooks Butte Park with a huge communications tower, citizens started investigating:exploring the nuances of the City Charter,parks plans and land use codes.As a result, they found our natural parks are not fully protected.Citizens now want to protect these natural places through the Lake Oswego City Charter so their use can only be changed by your vote.Lawyer-speak can turn something good into something bad,or vice versa,so let's be clear.First,please join your neighbors and sign the petition before Jan. 31,2020 to get our community initiative on the May ballot,despite the somewhat misleading title,"restricts improvements in certain City park properties,"that was assigned.Because,yes,we DO WANT an initiative on the May ballot that"limits development"in our natural parks that is inconsistent and incompatible x Emergency Veterinary CLINIC OF TUALATIN Open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Even Holidays! More Information with preserving their natural conditions.Visit Love LO Parks for a petition. Second,in the May election vote"yes"on our community's measure to preserve Lake Oswego's natural parks for residents,visitors and future generations and limit development in natural areas that are intertwined into the very fabric of our neighborhoods.You never know what those"City improvements"might be. Rosemary DiCandilo Lake Oswego https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/readers-letters/article_f6c54cc8-4103-59f3-8ab2-1202746adddb.html Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 3 Save LO Parks initiative:Remember McCall I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/17/23,11:55 PM https://PamplinMedia.com/lor/450904-366371 Save LO Parks initiative: Remember McCall Betsy Wosko Feb 6,2020 Tom McCall was Oregon's governor from 1967 through 1975.An environmental maverick,he passed the nation's first bottle bill and made great efforts at cleaning up the Willamette River.In 1973,with Senate Bill 100,he ushered in the Comprehensive Plan("CP"),which did three things:(1)created a set of 19 statewide goals,most of which dealt with preserving and protecting our environment;(2)required local governments to pass their own CPs,tailored to their areas;and(3)created the Land Conservation and Development Commission,a state agency responsible for ensuring compliance of local governments with respect to their own CPs. 4 Emergency Veterinary J CLINIC OF TUALATIN Open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Even Holidays! More Information Goal#1 of the CP was"citizen involvement."Now,why,for a bill which purpose was to protect and preserve the environment,would goal#1 be citizen involvement?What Gov.McCall presciently and wisely foresaw was that development interests,because of profit motive and because developers often serve on planning commissions and city boards and councils,would have an outsized influence on policy and practice which could adversely affect our natural environment.Citizen involvement,then,was designed to be a check against the potential for self-serving, short-sighted and environmentally irresponsible development. Today we face an existential environmental crisis,with climate change and mass extinctions,including insects and birds.Thousands of mature trees in our City—the foundation of our ecosystem—have been removed in just the past several years because of development. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/save-lo-parks-initiative-remember-mccall/article_1a4ea2ad-491e-59d4-aeb3-25c790e8db81.html Page 1 of 2 Save LO Parks initiative:Remember McCall I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/17/23,11:55 PM This is why I encourage you to sign the petition to protect LO Parks,a citizen initiative for a city charter amendment which would provide some baseline of protection against commercial development for trees in 14 small parks, tracking the same protections Springbrook Park currently enjoys.We need to do a lot more;but this is a good start. Development interests already have too cozy a relationship with the City,as evidenced by the thousands of old trees felled,and especially because the City has refused to consider and weigh the CP in deciding to allow so many old trees to be felled.We need to get back to basics,recognize the CP as the environmental and land use Constitution that it is,and heed Gov.McCall's implicit warning.Please go to www.LoveLOParks.orglpetition and add your voice to this good cause. Betsy Wosko is a Lake Oswego resident. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/save-lo-parks-initiative-remember-mccall/article_1a4ea2ad-491e-59d4-aeb3-25c790e8db81.html Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 4 Don't take LO natural areas for granted I Opinion I lakeoswegoreview.com 12/18/23, 8:55 AM https://PamplinMedia.com/lor/483226-389518 Don't take LO natural areas for granted Claire Puchy Oct 7,2020 The recent wildfires are a reminder of how precious our environment is to humans,as well as to wildlife.Natural areas—even small ones in urban areas—contribute to our physical and mental health,to air and water quality,and to mitigating some of the effects of climate change(think how wonderful it is to walk through a wooded area on a hot day).Here in Lake Oswego,we are very fortunate to have a network of natural areas,and we should never take them for granted.It took the efforts of citizens,public employees and government leaders to set them aside for us and generations to come.There is a citizen's initiative that is worthy of our support to ensure these are protected from inconsistent uses and development.This is Petition 2020IN-1.Signing the petition is not a vote for or against the initiative;but it's an important step towards qualifying it for a vote.You can learn more about this initiative,and download,sign and mail the petition by going to https://www.loveloparks.orglpetition. x Adieaa Thai DINE-IN,DELIVERY AND TAKEOUT AVAILABLE YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD THAI RESTAURANT 1235 MCVEY AVE.SUITE A Claire Puchy is a retired wildlife biologist whose career included positions as Executive Director of the Audubon Society of Portland and the Columbia River Gorge Commission.She was also an ecologist with the City of Portland, and Wildlife Diversity Coordinator for the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife. https://www.lakeoswegoreview.com/opinion/dont-take-lo-natural-areas-for-granted/article_ee318ddd-8a59-5f0c-bfb1-90d06b7bec02.html Page 1 of 1 Exhibit 5 No action Busy _ `?, '' Harmony i!IPL from summer for - / , j' Academy _ ' _=___ Salem on pavement y I gets timely = - h .. _ c- - wakesports projects $ IT: grant See Page A8 See Page A7 See Page B1 - Owner&Neighbor - \ — Dr.Robert B.Pamplin,Jr. L k 0 R • Pamplin MedlaGroup Wednesday,July 1, 2021 • Vol 100, Issue 41 • Building a stronger Lake Oswego through great local journalism • lakeoswegoreview.com • $1.00 NEWS IS CHANGING RAPIDLY I For breaking stories, COVID-19 news and the latest headlines, visit pamplinmedia.com S 0 gitArD S OF "5. Chlorine , , shortage no longer „ „ . 7 a worry .. / . , .........._ i Cemical shipped to LO; residents ,, i' `�� ` - - II, still urged to use water prudently _ 1 �, _ ' /, , ' i .—, By CLARA HOWELL ----_ ,G \ �-_ \\a " " 'Tv 1 : "Iti r^a�. " Pamplin Media Group �I • � r 1 � . � � �•, �, ,„> _ , , ' 1��[ � -• Lake Oswego received a chlorine delivery June o11 e N' ''' 28,which put the city at ease in terms of voluntary _ �H 'alb a , 1 w 7 . -it I y r \ l water reductions. ,,, l * , ' - ' ,` s ` tfitie' I!' 'lilt i `�+<"1_ After a critical electrical failure at Westlake Chemical � _ j, � c � _��1 � '�!,-• �• r , � 11 : —a chlorine manufacturing facility in Longview,Wash- -� ;'r ( -f ' in ton which supplies much of the region—about three Ll .�4 t' to �,� '- 9� � � � weeks ago,Lake Oswego and surrounding areas were d ; • �,9,_ �' �� P �'`I t '` asked to voluntarily reduce water usage despite being r J r �, era"= — h in a recent heat wave where temperatures skyrocketed ¢ into the triple digits. The failure has since been fixed �►> f ""' �t and the chlorine supply has been reestablished in Lake i '� , :. ., I' ,� Oswego. E1 ' //: ), / I v After the failure at Westlake Chemical,the city sent Ale .. z �i /t out a news release June 17 encouraging residents in t-! _/ v • Lake Oswego and Tigard(the two cities share their wa- ?�z `� �. �,. ;4T, 1 (•,`fr ; t "` i ter supply)to reduce their indoor and outdoor water us- ' „„„ ; g.At '" :; a <;6 l age due to the shortage. ii r While the tap water remained safe to drink,the city �'�" ' '\ t: . -, encouraged people to take shorter showers,not leave ,� "� 18P. — the water running and postpone new plantings,among �• r (. "' �' other actions to conserve water. "This hasn't happened before—not that I know of PMG PHOTOS:JONATHAN VILLAGOMEZlik anyway—for our chlorine supply,"said Lake Oswego's A The concert series will take place every weekend through August at the Lakewood Center for Citizen Information Specialist Katy Kerklaan. "We're the Arts parking lot. ► Local pianist and composer Michael Allen Harrison performed at the �, \- I very grateful to our community for stepping up and do- first Summer Sounds concert Saturday,July 3. ing our part to reduce water usage." Kerklaan said the city is still reminding people that it is more important than ever"to be mindful of our water Lakewood Center By CLARA HOWELL were no op ��so.f .• use.Water is a precious resource." Pamplin Media Group portunities \1, ', , Kerklaan added that the city is thankful for its part- for the Arts kicks off ' for people to .�s. nership with Tigard.The city used Tigard's aquifer stor- ' andemic life is slowly actually join li,, -' *, . = age and recovery wells to help extend the water supply weekly performances ; inching back to"nor- together to �i' \ mal." see music or r ` ' ,•_ ' See CHLORINE/Page A3 With that in mind,the theater or "It's in response to ' Lakewood Center for the Arts is dance or any because we I trying to give community mem- type of perform- COVID, I errs more joy local opportunities to gath-ns ing arts," said Fate of online knew that there were ; er and enjoy local musicians Lakewood's Ex id opportunities for and theater in a safe manner. tive Director Andrew no 0 pp , The new Summer Sounds Edwards. "In our pre- people to actually join I concert series kicked off Satur- planning we wanted to have LOSDtogether to see musicprogram day, July 3, with local pianist something available during the and composer Michael Allen summer months." There is currently limited or theater or dance ; Harrison. Edwards said he thought seating,though the performanc- or any type of I The concert series will take Summer Sounds would be a es will take place outdoors.Ma still unclear performing arts." ' place every weekend through great opportunity for people to ny of the shows,Edwards said, p g : August under the pavilion tent familiarize themselves with are already halfway sold out so —Andrew Edwards, , in Lakewood's parking lot, 368 gathering at Lakewood again he encourages people to pur- Lakewood Center for the Arts I S.State Street. before the center's first perfor- District awaiting state guidance executive director I "It's in response to COVID, mance back on the main stage because we knew that there Sept.23. See SUMMER/Page A3 about offering remote classes in fall By ASIA ALVAREZ ZELLER Pamplin Media Group IIS,T€ I_J1I Ii)211hlS measure %\71 Students in Lake Oswego School District have had the option to access fully remote instruction since the start of the school year.When the district phased in its hybrid model,some opted to remain in online instruction referred to as LO Online. appear on Novemhi ba110 Families were surveyed this spring about a potential online program for fall 2021,when schools are expected to be reopened for full-time,in-person learning. Of the 3,800 students surveyed,only 2%wanted an on- Petition amends city charter ceived enough signatures on an initia- line option. 196.5' SAVE tive petition to place a measure that Additionally,LOSD's policy has the teacher-student to protect 15 parks, natural would amend the city's charter on the ratio target at 1 to 28 on average.In the survey,roughly A COOKS11: ,► November 2021 ballot. eight students per grade on average districtwide ex- ,�+� ;- areasfrom developmentTo initiate a municipal ballot mea- pressed an interest in an online option — creating a BUTTE + sure,a person must collect signaturesmuch smaller ratio than the target. IBR6ENiMEEiINC ^ ' "' By CLARA HOWELL from at least 15%of registered voters in Guidance from the Oregon Department of Education �* /� • Pamplin Media Group the city.In Lake Oswego,there are just currently includes four "assurances," including a re WEO,SEPT18@0:30PM •�• ti r �,i over 30,100 registered voters, so more quirement that 50%of instruction be synchronous,if a LRNFRIOGFHIGHSCHOOL, s 7 r c4 . ��. Lake Oswego community mem- than 4,300 signatures are required to district were to choose to have an online program next errs have made their stances quite place the initiative on the November fall. Wm GREEN FOR G000 s . 1 clear on leaving certain parks ballot.Petitioners qualified 4,433 signa- ODE expects to have updated guidance in late July,at 1 TOWER 0 i did throughout the city as natural as tures in June. which point LOSD will know whether an online program sauecoo•sbuHe.coot . fir. possible—more than 4,400 people to This news followed a heated debate is required or not. ,- . '�= jw- ` f be exact. that began in 2019 over the future of LOSD Executive Director of Elementary Programs PMG FILE PHOTO Love LO Parks, a grassroots move- Cooks Butte City Park.The city of Lake Frank Luzaich and Executive Director of Secondary Love L0 Parks received enough signatures on an initiative ment led by passionate Lake Oswego Oswego and Clackamas 800 Radio Programs Lou Bailey brought a recommendation to the petition to place a measure on the November 2021 ballot community members to prevent 15 that would protect 15 parks from future development. parks from any future development,re- See PARKS/Page A3 See ONLINE/Page A3 INSIDE Police Log B5 Merkley introduces , Editorial/Opinion A6 Obituaries 131 ' Affordable Home Act Neighbors B1 Sports B10 ; `� � See Page A4 i!/ 7 12506 00102 2 - .. We're sailing again this summer from Seattle to the unspoiled wilderness of Alaska aboard the revolutionized Celebrity Millennium®—the perfect luxurious complement to the rugged beauty of Pe, ', , The Last Frontier.And,as on every Celebrity vacation,drinks,Wi-Fi,and tips are Always IncludedSM IS HERE / • tT * '' Beginning July 23,embark on 7-night round-trip journeys to captivating places,including Kefchikan, Juneau,Skagway,the breathtaking Inside Passage,and the impressive Endicott Arm&Dawes Glacier. ALASKA SAILINGS FROM SEATTLE • - - STARTING THIS SUMMER I �' `• CALL 1-888-283-6879 I CELEBRITY.COM I CONTACT YOUR TRAVEL ADVISOR *Visit celebrity.com for terms and conditions.Always Included pricing includes Classic Beverage Packages,unlimited Surf intemet packages,and tips included for all guests. CelebrityXCrui Health and safety protocols,guest conduct rules,and regional travel restrictions vary by ship and destination,and are subject to change without notice.Due to evolving health ;, 1. protocols,imagery and messaging may not accurately ref act onboard and destination experiences,offerings,features,or itineraries.These may not be available during your SAIL BEYOND -'-j - _- voyage,may vary by ship and destination,and may be subject to change without notice.02021 Celebrity Cruises Inc.Ships'registry:Malta and Ecuador. Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,July 7,2021/Thursday,July 8,2021 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman A3 Chlorine Summer + • I. • - ; .0 . ' . Online ..� E • .46 • From Page Al • From Page Al �� " _ • From Page Al throughout the shortage. chase tickets for$20 online. • . '� 4': �-0 • • •'410 . Lake Oswego School Board at "During periods of high wa People are not required to 6.: f., .' . .. ,• • the Monday,June 21,meeting. •ter demand, Tigard supple- wear face coverings, though • 8 I Should ODE require an on- ments its supply with water Edwards encourages folks •• .S. a~ line option or if the district from two city-owned aquifer who haven't been vaccinated ' • t_ j ' ' •• chooses to offer one, Luzaich storage and recovery (ASR) to continue wearing face cov- 0 .. recommended the board adopt wells,and a native groundwa- erings. People are invited to • 4 � r Stride Learning Solutions as its ter well," the city of Tigard's bring their own lawn chairs , ' • third party online provider. website read. "The ASR wells and for the first couple •, 4. 1>I 1 , . - LO Online,which was creat- are filled with water from Lake shows, Edwards encourages *�� , r �� ed in response to the pandemic, Oswego Tigard Water Treat- folks to bring their own bey- •- was a district-run online pro- ment Plant in the winter when erages and snacks. With the .� '� 1/4' gram. •people aren't using as much recently lifted COVID-19 re- =�< Luzaich said that a contract water, then used as an addi- strictions, Edwards said �-� - with Stride won't be signed un- tional source in the summer there will likely be an oppor- I I til the company assures it can when demand increases." tunity for concessions and 1 - '\it, meet what both ODE and the Kerklaan said the city made increased capacity at a laterNa district require of an online operational changes to extend date. a learning provider. the chlorine supply. Harrison is a well-known > It's unclear yet whether "Both cities made changes to musician who has performed PMG PHOTOS:JONATHAN VILLAGOMEZ Stride will be able to meet the our irrigation throughout the many times in Lake Oswego. Michael Allen Harrison is a well-known musician who has played many concerts in Lake Oswego. guidelines of ODE or those of cities and operation in public "Trained at the Portland LOSD.Stride does not current- works to reduce our water State University School Of ly offer synchronous instruc- use,"Kerklaan said."Reaching Music,Michael began his ca- upbeat sound with his band, July 10,by the musical group than a year. tion. out to our community and ask- reer as a classical composer, his work with inspiring vocal- 3 Leg Torso. For a complete "For the artists, it's really Luzaich said variables that ing them voluntarily to help later incorporating other ist Julianne Johnson, his list of performances and de- amazing.They are waiting for still need to be worked out in- conserve, that extended our styles and genres such as pop, skills producing and creating tails about the performers, the audience,"said Edwards, dude quality, cost, class size chlorine supply. So, by doing jazz, new age, musical the- music for ballet, theater and visit Lakewood's website. adding that he's heard similar and the student experience. their part, we also did our ater,rock,folk,and world mu- film,his love for teaching and Edwards said he's heard sentiments from audience Despite the unknowns, the part." sic," read Harrison's bio on for his giving spirit." from musicians and musical members as well. "They just board approved adoption of Kerklaan said the city will be Lakewood's website. "As an Other performances will be theater performers that want to be out and doing Stride as its online learning conducting a debriefing to dis- iconic artist,he is known for a mix of musicians, comedi- they've had very few oppor- things and that's what Lake- provider,with the caveats that cuss how to mitigate this issue his magical piano solo perfor- ans and musical theater.The tunities to perform in front wood is all about: providing Stride is able to meet the state in the future. mances and recordings, his next show will be Saturday, of live audiences for more that opportunity." and district requirements. Parl�s "aspirational"goal to have the would expand those limitations measure, which will undergo ea in an urban area and just protect them as natural areas, petition placed on the May 2020 to 14 additional parks and natu- public outreach before return- leave it alone; it needs to be not just have natural areas that ballot,then shifted their aim to ral areas — Bryant Woods ing to the council for approval taken care of,"Wagner said. people assume take care of qualify for the November 2020 Park,Canal Acres,Cooks Butte, Aug.3. Wagner said a group of citi- themselves,"Wagner said. • From Page Al ballot before the pandemic hit. Glenmorrie Greenway,Cornell According to the city's June zens were involved when the Lake Oswego City Manager "I actually put a pause on our Natural Area,Hallinan Woods, 15 staff report, the Love LO petition first formed in 2019, Martha Bennett said one con- in-person circulation efforts to Iron Mountain Park,Kerr Open Parks measure could affect res- and a handful in that group who cern with the Love LO Parks Group—a conglomerate of 18 kind of assess what was going Space,Lamont Springs Natural toration activities, renovation worked on restoration efforts measure is that if the city wants different public safety agencies on,"Handley said. Area, River Run, Southshore and replacement of existing fa- in the natural areas saw prob- to update the master plan for a like police and fire departments He added they had two years Natural Area, Springbrook cilities—like water storage or lems with the wording of the park or natural area in the fu- in Clackamas County — said to obtain qualifying signatures, Park,Stevens Meadows,Walu- utility infrastructure—in the measure that might hinder ture,"the Love LO Parks mea- the park provided the best loca- so they hit the ground running ga Park-West and Woodmont listed areas. what could be accomplished in sure would send us to the bal- tion to erect a communications again last October and wrapped Nature Park — and develop- It also could affect the city's those spaces in the future. lot,"Bennett said. "Everytime tower to improve communica- up collection in June 2021. ment would be limited to only ability to provide ADA access "We started working and we we want to update a master tions for police, fire and life The initiative would repeal what is necessary for the enjoy- and address parking needs for thought,probably a good solu- plan we'd have to go to the vot- safety personnel. and replace Chapter 10 in Lake ment of the natural spaces. visitors as well as"the ability to tion would be to actually work ers." A number of residents want- Oswego's City Charter that was The initiative also would al- develop,revise, adopt and im- with the city and have the coun- This, Bennett added, would ed to preserve the park as natu- created in 1978 to preserve low room for the addition of plement master plans for each cil put something on the ballot be very expensive. ral space and created the group Springbrook Park or other other natural spaces to be in- of these natural areas." that addresses some of the The measure drafted by city Save Cooks Butte. parks"acquired by a bond issue eluded in the charter as they Stephanie Wagner, a mem- wording,"Wagner said."I think staff will address those con- Ultimately the city and C800 after the effective date of this appear. ber of the Oswego Lake Water- the sentiment in it(the Love LO cerns while working toward the opted to move away from Chapter if(and only if)the vot- "It really shows me how shed Council,said that the way Parks measure)is good,it could same goal presented in the Cooks Butte as a potential site ers specifically designate such much people care about their the Love LO Parks measure is just be so much better." Love LO Parks measure. for the tower, but some con- other park as subject to this city here.That's one of the most written could present problems Wagner added that the corn- During the June 15 City cerned residents felt their work Chapter." gratifying things," said Hand- with restoration activities — peting measure wouldn't take Council meeting, Councilor wasn't done and began working The charter language said an ley of the process of gathering like removing unhealthy trees, away from the Love LO Parks Aaron Rapf said the Love LO on the ballot measure. athletic facility, parking lot, signatures."For me,it's been a replanting and supporting the measure.Rather,it would make Parks group shed light on Lake Oswego resident and road or trail for motorized ve- very enriching experience.I'm urban forest—and access.She it more clear and address some something they may not have Love LO Parks leader Scott hides could be developed at almost at a loss of words." said it focuses on hands-off of the accessibility and restora- looked at otherwise. Handley said this is the same any of the parks covered by During a June 15 City Coun- preservation,but urban forests tion aspects. "It allows us to improve up- initiative that the group start- that chapter. cil meeting, councilors direct- need more than that. "It really does look at how we on it,"he said during the meet- ed in late 2019. They had an The Love LO Parks initiative ed staff to draft a competing "You can't have a natural ar- take care of these parks and ing. ellit 1- : *:: r 17 * 4 r - at Pr' /` 1 HAPROPERTIE S S1-1 Justin Harnish Kristi Harnish Errol Bradley Anna West Tim McNamara Cori Jo Gamburd Bruce Winkler Barbara Carbone Tricia Jenkins Principal Broker/ Principal Broker) Broker) Broker Broker Broker Broker/Listing Broker Licensed Office Fanner Partner Customer Coordinator Coordinator Rela ons Local Real Estate Expertise _..-NL LEVERAGE rni h r i m GLOBAL PARTNERS h a s p open es co on a Global Scale NEW LISTING ON OSWEGO LAKE NEW LISTING - WESTOVER TERRACES *,7** .,d-. „ ,o,,e, <I --- • .41 r �p ��. ; : • wt r + t tr r a AY-'.. y ,... i 11 ■ ��111 Nun nun 6.. nr --'}v 1,: a- ' . 1 1- 3 a . .:4 9I Il -� r IIu'. .'�,� 4yf4�4t1f '- - -� eV5' -ac .1' 7 ":n`; f .! .,r;_,..--: *4 ii : =y -'. te a SUMMIT COURT $5,498,000 NW SHENANDOAH TERRACE $2,695,000 The total package on Oswego Lake's north shore with 180+ degree views. Hard A pristine home rich in history,one of the first two sites built in the early 1900's, to find wide footprint this family compound on an oversized lot is the house you with every amenity including: gourmet kitchen, formal dining room & living wish you grew up in.This home has it all;dedicated office&bonus/rec room,sun room with private terraces, large owner's suite, generously sized guest rooms, filled chef's gourmet kitchen,great room,"man cave';flat turf yard,new oversized vaulted/beamed bonus room with wet bar, climate controlled wine cellar, room double boat house with roof top deck for sun&fun,and so much more! for a gym,and views of Mt.Hood,St.Helens&the city. 7,180 SQFT 14 Bedrooms 13.2 Bathrooms 6,719 SQFT 15 Bedrooms 14.1 Bathrooms NEW LISTING - LAKE OSWEGO NEW LISTING - LAKE OSWEGO * I, ,_ • l'--="--N--------- — '-,:',-',,i-TiV'''''''1-..,-,,,44,. { _ a+ i ' _ - F is WEST ROAD $1,595,000 WOODHURST PLACE $1,198,000 I's vary rare to have zero steps,wide hallways,tall ceilings and that"Palm Springs" A lot of house for the money! Sitting atop the Marylhurst neighborhood in Lake lifestyle here in the pacific NW. A very open concept with both family room & Oswego with commanding views of Mt.Hood,&backing to a private greenspace; great room off of the gourmet kitchen, den/office with built-ins, formal dining this traditional has a flexible floorplan with a great room floor plan,living room, room, owner's suite wing & 2 guest suites on the opposite end of the home for grand master suite,large guest rooms,3 car garage&private back yard. Further maximum separation of space,oversized 3 car garage and loads of storage. separation of spaces include an optional in-law suite on the lower level. 3,926 SQFT 13 Bathrooms 13.1 Bedrooms 5,669 SQFT 16 Bedrooms 14.1 Bathrooms HARNISH PROPERTIES Pacific Residential Mortgage, LLC 201 B Avenue, Suite 101, Lake Oswego N Blake Rice NMLS-135765 harnish@harnishproperties.com 1503.699.8483 Sr. Mortgage Advisor www.harnishproperties.com PACIFIC 4949 Meadows Road Suite 150 RESIDENTIAL Lake Oswego, OR 97035 AA, MORTGAGE f O (503)699-5626 Office • (503) 260-9564 Cell Licensed in the State of Oregon NMLS-1477EQUALHOUSINGLENDER Exhibit 6 Opinion Pam diaGplin Meroup A6 • Wednesday,July 14, 2021 /Thursday,July 15, 2021 Support who push for cleaner energy f As the world's energy con- There are droughts and wildfires in Financially,fossil fuels,and the renewable source. jobs right here in the U.S. sumption grows larger ev some parts of the world and floods risks associated with them,should At first glance,that may seem By setting the example,we could ery day,we face a huge and hurricanes in others,destroy- be a thing of the past. like a daunting number,but let's show the world that climate change challenge of adapting to ing food and freshwater supplies Despite what some of renewables' put that into perspective—the is a battle we can win. the needs of a modern world. along with habit- fiercest critics United States already spends as There is no real reason to avoid In the past 20 years alone,our en- able land. may say,it's not much as 10%GDP on energy annu- the change to renewable energy. ergy consumption has grown by As a devel- going to cost ally,and switching to 100%renew- We're running out of fossil fuels more than 40%and is continuing to oped country $100 trillion to ables would cost the United States anyway. MIEWgrow exponentially.The world add- with decent in- '„ convert to 100% about$500 billion per year for the It's been proven that the environ- ed 179 gigawatt(GW)of renewable frastructure,the Jack Zoucha renewable ener- next 20 years—less than 1%of the mental,social and economic risks of generating capacity in 2018 and 176 physical risks to gy.One study GDP. not going green far outweigh the fi- GW in 2019.However renewables Americans are by energy re- Renewable energy would drasti- nancial burden we would face dur- still account for just 34.7%of all minimal—but search firm, cally lower our energy spending, ing the transition.The real problem global generating capacity. the financial risks are extremely Wood Mackenzie, make electricity up to 90%cheaper, is not the cost,it's our country's We do have the current capacity alarming,yet mostly unspoken. put the total cost at$4.5 trillion by reduce our dependance on foreign leadership refusing to change. to create enough energy,however The National Resource Defense 2040,while another by the Ameri- oil and erase our vulnerability in For our future,for our kids'fu- known oil deposits could run out in Council estimates that hurricanes, can Action Forum put the price tag global oil markets. ture,and for the planet's future— just over 53 years,gas reserves in droughts,real estate losses and en- closer to$10 trillion in costs by 2050. Switching to renewable energy get out and vote for candidates that just 52,and known coal deposits ergy costs could cost the United Both studies are very rough esti- could save almost$300 billion per support renewable energy policies could be gone in 150 years. States.An additional$1.9 trillion mates,based on completely replac- year on agriculture and manufac- and agendas. The consequences of fossil fuels per year by 2100,and that amount ing energy currently produced by turing costs and an additional$1.9 can be seen all over the world,eco- almost doubles when wildfire dam- fossil fuels,and additional transmis- trillion per year in environmental Jack Zoucha of Wilsonville is the Oregon nomically,socially and politically. age and health costs are added in. sion lines to cover the variability of damages,while creating millions of Institute of Technology's student president. Don't change RECORD NEAT.. r ror liilitiorirOic-'7-.. g I!kg''''jitaiiitiiit)gorc ,.;. - r• ruieson inmate DROUGHT.. rok , ,,o, votingnghts .. ,. W ,..; .. .his last,painful session of the Oregon Legis-T L lature was difficult for many reasons. III,. iiii* —= The building was rsutterly and off mas to e OAS ` ` ev- eryone but legislators and their staff,mean- t ing there was no ability to"lobby"legislators or staff, YINF4k1: and the actual hearings were remote,meaning there �. was none of the usual interchange,conversation and *opt ; • �`• ,. 111114 01111,"1 k \ itrioitek rarely even any questions. The result has been some awful legislation in the \ area of criminal justice,what is now often called"so- OREGON .. ,. " �rT• cial justice."The voices of victims,cops and prosecu- � -r ' ,,- ,,,- tors have been ignored,and violent criminals have RANO1ER the full sympathy of the Democratic Party Ihave ac �� '' `' ' k tively served my whole adult life. But the icing on the cake was a !„ � ,� ')!Iiinpiii{ .."'l�11°I(11�i�, ^IYnII'f'"f.�- V June 22 Portland Tribune opinion I I I piece,"Don't disenfranchise people 1 ���'� �', , I�i 'I!' I '', 414 who want to vote," by two current �� r7.j.1 state legislators,Tawna Sanchez and r': Andrea Salinas.They were joined by 'a a national advocate for convicted y criminals,the head of The Sentencing Project. MYVIEW They are miffed because although ©MIKE Kt 7/�2/�I they passed many laws that will se Joshua verely hamper fair and effective law Marquis enforcement,their efforts are aimed at allowing the absolute worst,cur- rent felony inmates to vote. READERSIETTERS To be clear,Oregon has been in the forefront of ex- tending the franchise—the right to vote—to former felons,even those convicted of murder or rape.The only disqualifier is for the roughly 12,000 men and Crown Plaza hotel saves the land Area Canine Therapy Teams,a pro- leave things as they are.If you do,the women serving time for a felony inside an actual pris- day dun ng heat wave gram associated with Dove Lewis Veteri- referendum wins and Springbrook loses. on.People in any county are eligible,as is anyone nary Hospital. If you want Springbrook to continue its with any criminal record,so long as they are not cur- e don't have air condition- We saw at least eight other dogs in the charter protections,then you need to rently doing felony time in a state facility. ing. hotel,but none quite as friendly and well- vote for the initiative. To give an idea of how tiny this number is,it repre- At first,we thought we behaved as ours(but then we are biased). Theresa Kohlhoff sents roughly one half of 1%of the population. could endure the Oregon So,we are extremely grateful to the Lake Oswego Let's be clear,this very proposal had not one,but heat wave with our fans and a cool base- Crown Plaza hotel for their generous two bills in the 2021 session,neither ever even got ment.But when the weather forecasters change in policy that spared us,our dogs, Schrader's climate bill voted on.At testimony on the Senate side,almost 100 started talking about temperatures over and other dogs from suffering through an people submitted written testimony and roughly half 110,and our two labs Nixon and Lena unprecedented sizzling heat wave. is too little, too late opposed the bill.According to their opinion piece,the were panting even when lying still,we Corinna Campbell legislation would even grant the 30-odd killers on decided we better check into a hotel...if Lake Oswego I'm writing to express my dismay at death row the right to vote on matters like the death we could find a room. Rep.Kurt Schrader's misplaced priorities penalty or criminal sentencing. After learning that our first choice Evaluating regarding our precious and irreplaceable uatin The authors'poster boy for this proposal,which is nearby was completely booked,we called g options on planet. far beyond what each state(except Vermont and the Crown Plaza Portland-Lake Oswego Springbrook park measures Again and again,he seems to prefer in- Maine)provide,is a man named Anthony Williams. on Kruse Way and asked if they had any dustry needs over what worries his con- He is serving a life term without parole for a particu- "pet-friendly rooms." The city is considering a referendum stituents(like me). larly brutal murder several years ago.He committed They responded by saying that ordi- against a citizen's initiative,Love LO I am deeply frustrated with Schrader's the crime when he was 17,so to receive a life without narily they did not allow pets,but under Parks. weak-tea compromise on what is increas- parole sentence is extremely unusual. the circumstance of incredible heat,they The only park that is presently charter ingly urgently needed:STRONG environ- Williams speaks about the"150-person riot"he were making an exception and accepting protected is Springbrook.It has been and mental protection as an investment for took part in at the Oregon State Correctional Insti- pets in all their rooms...at no extra remained so since 1978 despite attempts the future—for us,our children and tute after he had been allowed to spend several years charge! by the city to fudge. THEIR children. in the Oregon Youth Authority.He wasn't in the So,we reserved a room,and we were The draft referendum would do an end One would think after the horrifying adult prison until he was 25. thrilled.But just sitting in our room got run around the charter,our city's consti- heat wave we just struggled through— Authors of this bill,and their opinion piece,really, to be a little boring,so we spent quite a tution.By removing the charter protec- 119-degrees outside my home—that we really want people like Williams to decide who your bit of the time in the lobby near the tion,Springbrook will be demoted and could put protecting our ecosystem first. school board should be,whether the drunk-driving check-in desks.The presence of our dogs "managed"—tree removal for parking Your bill does not require major reduc- laws should be made more lenient,or even if Measure brought smiles to the faces of many and impervious surfaces for paths.This tion in emissions for another 20 years! 11 should remain law. guests,and some asked to pet them, is the kind of"improvement"Spring- That is WAY too little,and MUCH too It would be comic,if it were not so unjust,to sug- which,of course we encouraged. brook has resisted. late.Please!Prioritize Our Planet— gest the very worst in our community should be giv- While they were petting our dogs,we Further if both measures go onto the NOW! en the right to decide others'lives.Once released, chatted and told them about how our ballot,the one with the higher number of Mary Lyon those rights automatically return to them. dogs did service work for PACTT,Port- votes will win.You cannot just vote to Lake Oswego Oregon already wipes away all legal barriers once a person leaves prison.There is no reason to reward the 0.3%of the population who are in prison with the vote. Pamplin Media Group opinion policy ter 200,general letter 300,Citizen's View 550. When slavery was abolished,an intentional clause Please be aware that since we've combined newspapers, allowed deprivation of liberty upon lawful conviction Pamplin Media Group welcomes the chance to hear from we do not have enough room to run every submission the of a serious crime. citizens,either as letters to the editor or guest opinions. week it comes in.Our individual newspaper websites will run No writer will be published on the Opinion page more than their own letters and Citizen's View pieces online each week. Joshua Marquis of Astoria was Clatsop County district attorney once every month.Deadline is noon Friday;Citizen's View Email submissions to pmalee@pamplinmedia.com or use from 1994 to 2018.He is active in the National District Attorneys pieces should be submitted earlier.Word limits:political let- the online portal. Association. ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING - Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 7 Survey finds Has Colorado T Lake -"' r _ political ��> solved digital Ni D I V I$I O 1 Oswego i, ,9,-,-_-._ „ divide on i divide ink r: enjoys a ' vaccine ii, .. .. schools? y,, : r night out sip��� ." See Page A8 , See Page B1 See Page B4 Owner&Neighbor ""' 'l •, !" Dr.Robert B.Pamplin,Jr. Lake0swegoReview Pamplin Mecimroup Wednesday, August 11, 2021 • Vol 100, Issue 52 • Building a stronger Lake Oswego through great local journalism • lakeoswegoreview.com • $1.00 NEWS IS CHANGING RAPIDLY I For breaking stories, COVID-19 news and the latest headlines, visit pamplinmedia.com m LOCity 111t111111 A Councilor ....i , ,.., Nguyen D E 1 A I D ,..,,,, , , .... _ . to resign Council president, Arts council exhibit . _ & whose term expires tofeature abandoned .i ' _,I i _ , in 2022, will be buildings, old cars �, �` �- � � s �' � i "��^ � - moving outside city By CLARA HOWELL � i , '�I�t 4 ( °� limits nl .t ti Jam'. �. Pamplin Media Group , ii ,� � Y By Pamplin Media Group i i i I.. �,.4:1, ,ll , i �0 he Arts Council of Lake Oswe- _._ , - --•_ T go's next showcase may be a r ;-.3. _ t- !-)j; '' - ,:46-4 " �' — Lake Oswego City Council bit haunting. - __ 11.111111 President Daniel Nguyen plans to The exhibition titled"Aban- resign this fall when his family doned,Images of What Remains"will "°" moves outside of city limits. have about 90 pieces of art on display The city announced Nguyen's de- from Sept.3 through Oct.29 at the new cision in a press release Monday ARTspace Gallery located in City Hall, COURTESY PHOTOS evening,Aug.9.Nguyen's resigna- 380 A Avenue,Suite A. "GasCo Building-Inspiring the Imagination"is a painting by Laura Blackwell that will be on display during the upcoming Arts tion is effective Oct.6. The opening reception,where about 45 Council of Lake Oswego exhibit.The building,which has since been demolished,was located on Highway 30 near the St.Johns "I am extremely honored and artists will talk about their processes, Bridge in the northwest industrial area of Portland. humbled to have been able to serve will be from 5:30 to 7 p.m.Friday,Sept.10. the Lake Oswego "The West Coast of America has a "I enjoyed exploring and learning different interpretations of the theme. museum and it's always really interest- community," Nguy- unique history from Indigenous Peo- their history,"Johnson said in the press One piece of art that stood out to John- ing to learn about the history of mining en said in the re- • ples,early frontier days and the Oregon release."There's something so haunt- son is a painting of a former Portland Gas especially because these mine towns and lease."Thank you to Trail,to the boom and bust industries of ingly beautiful about an empty house Company building,which has since been the mining camps and the big mines the Councilors,staff, . . logging,mining and agriculture.As re- that used to be someone's home stand- demolished. were set up in really backcountry loca- volunteers,commu- ' suit,the landscape is dotted with aban- ing alone on the landscape." "There's cool little historical tidbits tions that were really rugged and hard to nity leaders, and doned sites and structures,"read a July Johnson told Pamplin Media Group that you don't run across every day,but get to,and really hard to live near,"John- members of boards, 22 news release from the ACLO. she thinks the theme will resonate with someone took a picture of it and did a lit- son said."So you come across these man- committees, and s "Once thriving and burgeoning,these people, and that throughout the pan- tle bit more research on it,"Johnson said. made structures and giant hills of things commissions with now discarded,neglected places bear demic,she thinks more people explored Similarly,a photograph of the Board- people pulled out of the ground.It's inter- whom I have worked NGUYEN the mark of past human presence." rural areas.In many of the artist state- man Tree Farm during fall that will be on esting to think what life would have been with.I believe in the Lake Oswego's Public Art and Pro- ments and descriptions,Johnson added display is also no longer there anymore. like working there and living there." vision for Lake Oswego we have all gram Manager Stephanie Johnson said that she noticed people talking about Another photograph,which personally Work is available for sale and exhibit worked towards and look forward to the theme was inspired by her experi- the feeling of abandonment as well,es- resonates with Johnson,is of an aban- hours are 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Tuesday seeing Lake Oswego continue to ence living near ghost towns and aban- pecially during the last year-and-a-half. doned mine. through Friday. thrive." doned mines in New Mexico and Colo- Artwork will include photography, "Prior to this job,I was in Colorado Visit the ACLO's website for details: Nguyen,a small business owner, rado. paint,collage and 3D pieces,all capturing working in a mining town at a mining artscouncillo.org. was elected to the council in Novem- ber 2018.He was the first person of color to win a seat on the Lake Os- wego City Council. The council will appoint Nguyen's " sir 1: :- '/ replacement in the fall;hi:: :: / t41 ,/ / ! , 1I "Councilor Nguyen ml � ; 'r :� a I history as the first person of color �, i 1 ever elected to the LO City Council," 1 a i it , ri i iI Y / > Lake Oswego Mayor Joe Buck said ,, 11 /if ,.; a; in the release."His leadershipand j ,� ,y i 1 , 1l t voice have not only created stronger i I. ` : 1 ' ' i I City policy,but inspired a spirit of . ,; a , ,%, j, .. _ tremendous possibility through ac- K �' ;p e El �";;�, `� tionable progress that leaves a true f legacy.As a personal friend,I'll miss �� him on the dais greatly and know i the Council will continue carrying i his message forward." � ‘ I rs I Ted Rigoni's photograph,"Last Man Standing,"was taken at the Chemung Mine near Kate Ampersand's photograph,"Ghost Trees,"will be on display during the Arts the ghost town of Masonic,California. Council of Lake Oswego's next exhibit. •C ounce refers preservation measure to ballot the council voted to approve The city's proposed measurer; Charter referendum pp y p p �, ,'� � -�._ the city staff-proposed natural would amend chapter 10 of the "1" ��Y„ f is response to citizen area preservation charter ref- city charter to state that"the r . ,,` 'L _- o • erendum for the November City of Lake Oswego shall ''" C .11 '\ Y" " y ft r , • petition aimed to 2021 ballot. manage the Natural Areas to 'tt �-L. �4 �t ` Vl:-. ;y This measure,aimed to pro- preserve and enhance the bio �4- „4 t '- - protect natural spaces - .v Q p tect 21 natural spaces in Lake logical,hydrological,ecological - `�_ �°�3�• 4 41 � � � ;� , Duringthe Oswego,will join a competing and environmental functions 4..._ � x 4� t IIT ` "' Aug.3 meeting, By CLARA HOWELL initiative by the group Love LO and promote a healthy ecosys �� ��; �� vil t* the council voted Pamplin Media Group Parks on the ballot. tern. The City shall also man- �-' . `-., fP; " . % >.1 �, � to approve the Both measures have similar age Natural Areas in a way -- ' . ' - r ;di- "; 4 city staff- The Lake Oswego City intentions of protecting the that protects their scenic and _ - -- _ fit, ! proposed Council decided last week to city's parks,but Love LO Parks aesthetic qualities and pro- _ t ' _era ; f.J , 1 , natural area send a parks measure to the claims its measure protects the vides access to nature for thev preservation November ballot—some- parks in their most natural ele- public, consistent with their - - = charter thing a group of citizens ment, while the city says the environmental values and eco- - ',-- t 7 referendum for dedicated to preserving the competing measure clarifies logical function." ' ' the November city's natural spaces is not some of the verbiage in the The amended charter would 2021 ballot. particularly happy about. Love LO Parks measure that -. Duringthe Aug. 3 meeting, couldpresent future concerns. f 74 PMc PHOTO: g g See PRESERVE/Page A3 :�" s�c s 1 CLARA HOWELL INSIDE Police Log B6 ' LO Little League all- _ Editorial/Opinion A6 Obituaries B8 9 Neighbors B1 Sports B12 stars off to regionals �_ See page B12 >; i ,! .ar' 7 12506 00102 2 PamplinClassifieds r _ Re ulda ere- .. I 1. IC=` LI I I It44 _ , , = IL Work closer to home and save gas and time. Pamplin MediaGroup " a ' 7- Check out all our Help Wanted ads in this week's classifieds! Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,August 11,2021/Thursday,August 12,2021 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman A3 Preserve of other natural spaces serve constructed before guage in the original char- appointed"by the remarks pity purchases be included in the charterer tern(date initiative is ratified) ter needs to be changed if made by city leaders during as they appear. that is above ground as long it's being applied to more the council meeting.He said "The concern is that with as that facility or structure, parks than just Spring- there were attempts to Yates nnnear • From Page Al the various city councils, or parking lot,road,or trail brook. work with the city on the property they don't look at the city for motorized vehicles is "While the language for initiative petition and that Hallinan Woods parks as a unique asset. not altered in any manner Springbrook serves that the City Council did not prohibit several actions at They're willing to exploit that would further impair one park and allows us to reach out to him. Handley the parks, including con- the parks for other purpos- or be inconsistent with the address these concerns said he even worked with • 1, struction of athletic facili- es," Lake Oswego resident natural conditions of a Na- with our other natural ar- Parks and Recreation to en- A f ter negotiations wan ties, commercial logging, Mike Louaillier told Pam- ture Preserve. eas through public planning hance the text of their mea- the addition of new public plin Media Group."The city "The City of Lake Oswe- processes, applying the sure. seller city buys 2-acre streets or roads,and the in- politicians should not look go shall be allowed to imple- same conditions crafted in "The mayor basically i stallation of new telecom- at the parks as an asset to ment (or allow any person the'70s to the changing cli- slanders, made false accu- munications for $1 .65 million munications facilities. exploit.They need to be left to implement) a park mas- mate of today's environ- sations and lied about our Activities allowed by the alone." ter plan for a Nature Pre- ment(in)city natural areas efforts," Handley said. "I city's proposed charter lan- According to the city's serve that was adopted be- unwittingly creates condi- think it's a complete disser- guage include various June 15 staff report, the fore (date initiative is rati- tions that residents would vice to the citizens who By CLARA HOWELL maintenance, renovation, Love LO Parks measure fled)." find counterproductive to have been working for the Pamplin Media Group stewardship and mitigation could affect restoration ac- The problem, according our shared values and con- last 18 months to bring this efforts. tivities,renovation and re- to the city,is the future im- cerns for long-term care message to the neighbors After years of community members Love LO Parks is a grass- placement of existing facili- pact this charter amend- and access,"Buck said. and for those who signed it pushing the city to acquire the Yates prop- roots movement led by ties—like water storage or ment would have by limit- During a June 15 council (the initiative petition)." erty adjacent to Hallinan Woods and a pro- Lake Oswego community utility infrastructure — in ing maintenance work to meeting, councilors direct- Buck told Pamplin Media longed period of negotiation with the prop- members to prevent 15 the listed areas. structures built before the ed staff to draft a competing Group that as a city, they erty owners,the city of Lake Oswego has fi- parks from any future de- It also could affect the amendment was ratified. measure,which underwent have to look into the future nally locked down the property. velopment. The group re- city's ability to provide "In terms of crushed public outreach before re- and understand and clearly During the Aug.3 City Council meeting,the ceived 4,433 signatures, ADA access and address gravel being allowed under turning to the council for interpret the consequences council approved the purchase of the 2-acre more than the 4,300 needed parking needs for visitors ADA,I learned through this approval Aug.3. of the Love LO Parks mea- parcel located at 1107 Yates Ave.for$1.65 mil- to qualify, on an initiative as well as"the ability to de- process that it is only al- City Manager Martha sure. lion. petition to place a measure velop,revise,adopt and im- lowed up to a certain level Bennett said they also re- For example, Buck said, Hallinan Woods currently consists of 3.75 that would amend the city's plement master plans for of grade. So it is partially vised the definition of natu- the Love LO Parks measure acres of public wooded area directly north of charter. each of these natural ar- true but may not be up to ral areas"to make sure that would cause issues around Hallinan Elementary, and includes a stream The Love LO Parks mea- eas." ADA requirements in all the roles of natural areas in wildfire restoration work and walking trails.The public space now has sure would repeal and re- Lake Oswego resident situations," Lake Oswego helping us mitigate and pre- like fuel reduction.He said been expanded with the purchase of the adja- place the original chapter Betsy Wosko said the Love Mayor Joe Buck told Pam- pare for climate change and they might have to thin cent 2-acre piece of property located directly 10 in the charter,which was LO Parks measure would plin Media Group. to allow us to reduce the trees or make sure certain north of the main portion of the park. created in 1978 to preserve not prevent restoration "Aside from the trail,it's risk of wildfire in the corn- trees are in the right spaces The private property is separated from the Springbrook Park or other work or the city from main- the notion of providing ac- munity were clearly identi- to help combat climate public woods by a chain-link fence along its parks "acquired by a bond taining the parks. She also cess through parking for fled as the purpose of man- change. He said the Love southern and eastern perimeter,but it is mostly issue after the effective said crushed gravel for the mobility challenged and aging natural areas." LO Parks measure is a very undeveloped and visually indistinguishable date of this Chapter if(and trails or boardwalks — others when appropriate Buck said he's heard ma- hands-off approach. from the rest of the wooded area.The neighbors only if) the voters specifi- rather than paving—would given the specific,local con- ny people question why the "When we talk about fire have argued that the public and private sec- cally designate such other not limit access to people. ditions. These are prime city didn't work together mitigation and fuel remov- tions are one contiguous wooded area and park as subject to this Lake Oswego resident examples of the unintended with the Love LO Parks al,we're focused on remov- should be treated as such. Chapter." and Love LO Parks leader consequences that come group on this issue.He said ing dead trees and excess Neighbors and residents throughout Lake The charter language Scott Handley agreed and from applying blanket rules drafting a competing mea- underbrush that can lead to Oswego have been trying to convince the city said an athletic facility, said that the Love LO Parks to a wide variety of parks sure was not the city's first hazardous fire conditions," for years to purchase this property so the space parking lot,road or trail for measure wouldn't affect the and conditions." choice. Buck said."Without access can remain natural,and the effort ramped up motorized vehicles could maintenance of existing fa- Buck added the option for "I know for a fact—for those tasks are not possi- again last year with development plans taking not be developed at any of cilities,which includes ren- a paved path is not the first years members of the com- ble." shape. the parks covered by that ovation and restoration. choice,but it's important to munity attempted to work Buck also noted that it's Last month,the council approved a resolu- chapter. "The City of Lake Oswe- have it as an option—espe- with LO Parks on some- important not to forget the tion to exercise eminent domain with respect to The Love LO Parks initia- go shall be allowed to main- cially when considering thing that could be collab- genesis of Love Lo Parks: acquiring the property.During the July meet- tive would expand those tain(or allow any person to maintenance of an area. orative,that the community the argument that an emer- ing,city attorney Jason Loos said this resolu- limitations to cover 14 addi- maintain) a Nature Pre- There might be a time, he could come together on," gency communication tow- tion was the first legal step in moving toward tional parks and natural ar- serve for the purposes of said,when the city needs to said Buck, adding that he er should not be placed on using eminent domain to acquire the property. eas—Bryant Woods Park, ecological restoration that transport water wagons or had conversations with Cooks Butte City Park. It basically indicated that"the city needs the Canal Acres, Cooks Butte, provides a safe and healthy other tools for restoration Love LO Parks more than a Buck said it feels like peo- property for public use,"Loos said during the Glenmorrie Greenway,Cor- natural area that is accessi- or maintenance that would year ago and stressed that ple don't trust the city be- meeting. nell Natural Area,Hallinan ble for public enjoyment, require a paved path. having a measure without cause it tried to place a Woods, Iron Mountain provides a healthy habitat "Right now community support of the council, the communications tower at — Park, Kerr Open Space, for wildlife,eliminates inva- members are hand-water- parks department and oth- Cooks Butte. The fact is, Lamont Springs Natural sive species,restores native ing areas of Iron Mountain er experts wouldn't be suc- Buck said,residents suffer Correction Area, River Run, South- species, and mitigates fire Park due to the extremely cessful. "It just fell on deaf when there's not ample ra- shore Natural Area,Spring- hazards," the Love LO dry conditions,"Buck said. ears,unfortunately." dio coverage for first re- In a July 28 story titled,"Lake Oswe- brook Park, Stevens Mead- Parks charter amendment Wasco said the language Experts and community sponders and the tower has go Lions Club honors member with ows, Waluga Park-West read. in the Love LO Parks mea- members had concerns to be built somewhere. award,"the date of the Lake Oswego Li- and Woodmont Nature "The City of Lake Oswe- sure would afford the same with the Love LO Parks ini- "That's something that's ons Club Anniversary was incorrect. Park — and development go shall be allowed to main- protections given to Spring- tiative petition,stating that really left out of this narra- The celebration will be from 10:30 a.m. would be limited to only tain(or allow any person to brook Park in the original though the goal was good, tive,"said Buck,adding that to 1 p.m.Oct.16 at Lakewood Center for what is necessary for the maintain)any existing facil- charter—it's just extend- there were issues with the the city is trying to keep the Arts,368 South State St. enjoyment of the natural ity or existing structure,or ing the same protections to execution. people safe. "We have to The Review strives for accuracy.If spaces. any existing parking lot, other parks and enhancing "We have to listen to that come together to find solu- you see an error,email editor Patrick The initiative also would road,or trail for motorized the original charter. advice,"Buck said. tions. It's not always just Malee at pmalee@pamplinmedia.com. allow room for the addition vehicles in a Nature Pre- But the city says the Ian- Handley said he was"dis- black and white." I'llifi'- .7 ' ft HARN I SH 1 f 11$ �"- �L p� i A off ki ' I , r 1111-) - \ , . Ll :l PROPERTIES Justin Hamish Kristi Harnish Errol Bradley Anna West Tim McNamara Cori Jo Gamburd Bruce Winkler Barbara Carbone Tricia Jenkins Principal Broker/ Principal Broker/ Broker/ Broker Broker Broker Broker/Listing Broker Licensed Office Fanner Partner Customer Coordinator Coordinator Relations Local Real Estate Expertise LEVERAGE i rn h r i m GLOBAL PARTNERS h a s p open es co on a Global Scale NEW LISTING-EXTRAORDINARY MOUNTAIN VIEWS THROUGHOUT �OF gy Ppd�Qp� _ _ (Oct M iIV ---,B 1 7� C 1 � ��i'!.'',°00 l _ _ - I � ��r" J' 1111 IIII • 5r I ItO uu Y�1 .>_ T . ,. •� - . -` :,',.. '1 ai y x 'qp _ r 6� & ;.taT�a y r � f r "' a tl « • V}"a u wx- . . jd '%, •'fi' a 1�tr �,r O., .4 �u..�.1 _..� ~. TI r��" t tl I,, ,fir • .'s"� . v't .N of?I'� A31 a ,. I U i �, \ r yam_��I _ . . . �E - - p rZ II .6 '.-` ' �.-- - , ill`-i�.11r�J. ,l .-rir�+9 ,rt- �� s .,e G n 'i,4 4.* -f I iWip..� t mot, = N 4 I` ,l,' k i . . �y _ SW MYRTLE CT $9,495,000 SHANANDOAH TERRACE $2,695,000 Modern sophistication beyond its surroundings, truly one of one. Walls of glass for A pristine home rich in history. One of the first two sites built in the early 1900's. A 5 a 270-degree view of the city, river, mountains and beyond to you. This showpiece bedroom,4.1 bathroom home with every amenity.A kitchen with a breakfast bar&nook. encompasses elements not found in this marketplace.German engineered stainless steel A dining terrace,and living room with private terrace.Luxurious bath and heated Carrera front door and window package. Three bedrooms,3 bedrooms and 3.1 bathrooms with marble floors.Generously sized guest rooms,bonus room with wet bar,climate controlled main floor primary,elevator,bar,gym,game area,wine room,pool bath,sauna,lap pool wine cellar,gym,flat fenced yard,and three car garage.Views of Mt.Hood,St.Helens& and three vehicle garage. the city! 7,581 SQFT 13 Bedrooms 13.1 Bathrooms 5,957 SQFT 15 Bedrooms 14.1 Bathrooms HARNISH PROPERTIES Pacific Residential Mortgage, LLC 201 B Avenue, Suite 101, Lake Oswego N Blake Rice NMLS-135765 harnish@harnishproperties.com 1503.699.8483 Sr. Mortgage Advisor www.harnishproperties.com PACIFIC 4949 Meadows Road Suite 150 _ RESIDENTIAL Lake Oswego, OR 97035 kAi.-i fMORTGAGE CI in the State of Oregon NMIS.1477 EQUAL HOUSING LENDER (503)699-5626 Office • (503) 260-9564 Cell Exhibit 8 Opinion LGr0uP m Pamplin A6 • Wednesday, September 22, 2021 /Thursday, September 23, 2021 — Fthth• • • b i ing f •d h ii n r u is obvious that COVID-19 has �� .� put a tremendous strain on our L T N ALCOHOL&DRUG HELPLINE collective health,including our YouthLine _ 7 RESOURCES �r� Call 800-923-4357(24/7/365) mental health. �� 7 4 J' ` i �.`� pk��•� • �' ,A. SUICIDE LIFELINE Text RecoveryNow to 839863 Mondays- And while fears of a surge in sui- • .a AL Call 800-273-8255(24/7/365) Fridays,2-6 p.m. cides have not materialized,it's not = ;. 4 l `, Text 273TALK to 839863 Mondays-Fridays, The Alcohol and Drug Helpline serves exactly something to celebrate.In an f \ t' 2-6 p.m. anyone who needs information,support or average week,16 Oregonians die by 1 — ,fr ;� ,;, ' ti _ -�' YOUTHLIKE access to resources and treatment for suicide,twice as many as are killed s * Call 877 968 8491 alcohol or drug use. in auto accidents. Text teen2teen to 839863 SENIOR LONELINESS LINE And,while the rate of suicides and `t . '' ,' �` �'S �' suicide related visits to emergency w. + Chat at oregonyouthline.org Call 503-200-1633 A teen-to-teen crisis and help line.No We support seniors in our community who departments actually dropped during tvergday6a l are feelinglonelyand havingdifficulty the early COVID days of"shelter-in- �� ' cw problem is too big or too small. connectin . place,"since the start of this year, i -q - ;= MILITARY HELPLINE • ��; ;p,�,i� OREGON BEHAVIORAL HEALTH SUPPORT mental health visits by adolescents Call 888 457 4838(24/7/365) LINE have increased nationwide and,lo- / Text MIL1 to 839863 Mondays-Fridays,2-6 Call 800 923 4357(24/7/365) cally,calls to the Lines for Life crisis p• suicide hotline have spiked as the Support for service members,veterans and Emotional support,mental health triage, delta variant rips through the state. --IF their families that is independent of any drug and alcohol counseling or just a For too long,policy makers and - ! AT" 1 1 .. branch of the military or government. connection with a person who cares.Callers the press shied away from discussing don't need to be in crisis to contact this line. such trends and statistics,fearing PUG PHOTO:ZANE SPARLING that a frank discussion of suicide Volunteers and employees at YouthLine pose for a photo with U.S.Sen.Ron Wyden might lead to more suicides.But re and Multnomah County Commissioner Sharon Meieran at the Lines for Life offices on Their effort has been aided by over the past year,including the fire search shows that's a mistake,add- Friday,Feb.15. some prominent female athletes. and having a family member battling ing to the stigma around suicide and Gymnastic sensation Simone Biles, with COVID-19,led him to seek out leaving individuals struggling with Sen Ron Wyden's recent visit to ple of color.Lines for Life is respond- tennis star Naomi Osaka and soccer help for emotional health. depression feeling isolated and hope- Lines for Life and is working on a ing to this troubling trend with a phenom Christen Press have all re- "It really made a difference to me. less. story about that organization's youth public awareness campaign,Mental cently taken very public breaks from I just want to thank the professionals That's why,since 2019,most Ore- hotline.The Lake Oswego Review, Health Out Loud,highlighting the competition to focus on their mental who are there and can,in some cas- gon newsrooms,including those of meanwhile,covered a suicide aware- need for people to speak up about health. es,just be there to listen,"Cameron the Pamplin Media Group,have fo- ness event in that community and their mental health and seek support Closer to home,earlier this month said,noting that with counseling he cused attention on the topic during the Clackamas Review continued its when they need it.The local nonprof- Marion County Commissioner Kevin was able to refocus his thoughts on September,national Suicide Preven- coverage of the 2019 suicide of a it is sharing the experience of some Cameron shared his personal experi- what he could control."I just want to tion Month,and have worked to 9-year-old Oregon City boy and the Oregonians of color working on men- ence dealing with stress.The former help anybody I can knock down adopt a set of best practices when re- impact his death has had in the re- tal health issues within their own Republican state lawmaker was in those walls.It's OK to ask for help." porting on suicide throughout the gion. communities and promoting its Ra- the thick of the midnight wildfire We agree. year. One area that we plan to explore is cial Equity Support Line(503-575- evacuations from Santiam Canyon a —Pamplin Media Group The Portland Tribune covered U.S. the rising rate of suicide among peo- 3764)staffed by people of color. year ago,and said various stressors editorial board \AThich READERS'LETTERS EV is • g City referendum is attach 0 MIKE LOCHS 9/20/21 on citizen initiative � ����� , HEHE'SA PARENT WHO am disturbed by the city's referendum which I' LOST His Coot. AT would strip away Springbrook Park's char- impr �� k W NATS f1�S ter protection—and preclude this protec- , ®• ; • _ DEAL? A N EWB ERG SCHOOL for you • tion to the remaining parks—while profess- . o �.I.,,�a ing to be"protecting"natural areas.This is dou ' L`, • i BOARD MEETING. ble talk. r nterest in electric vehicles is growing.The Over the years,Springbrook has been main- tained and has had trails wide enough for emer- ing all of us aware that we need to address gency vehicles to drive through,whether for this crisis quickly and aggressively.Con wildfire suppression or extra water.As is,it has ` verting cars,trucks and busses to all electric worked even with the overused-for-the-space � - �� vehicles is emerging globally as one of the best tennis center inappropriately placed there de- I ` answers. cades ago.The ADA applies there and an accom- ? ��. Fortunately that message is getting through modation was made at the first of 2021 for a little IM _ in Lake Oswego.EV registrations in Lake Os- more parking as opposed to the excessive park- b wego increased by more than 50%last year ing the Parks and Rec had wanted.So just what and now represent almost 5%of the total num- problem does it have that the city now frantical- ri � �� ) ` �� ber of EV registrations in the state. ly wants to fix by snatching away its charter pro- ■ ���� -. ��,/ ��11 This strategy is also catch- tection? -,�m■1issi� Ark ing on globally.Currently 80 Springbrook is what has existed and been ap countries and other govern predated since 1978.If you haven't been there, Neighbors have reached out to Renaissance school gardens curriculum,protect natural re- ill , mental entities have set dead- do go.It is a wonderful place to walk through. untold times.Yet its leaders ignore the physi- sources on school grounds,develop a food waste lines to phase out the sale of The citizen's initiative merely brings the remain- cal,emotional and spiritual benefits of trees on curriculum and support the inclusion of a sus- " x fossil fuel vehicles.Virtually ing undeveloped parks into this protected status. their acquired properties.Renaissance then tainability goal in the school board's current all major automobile manu- The city's referendum did not spring up sponta- "landscapes"the tiny yards of their new homes strategic plan.All of this work is dependent on facturers such as Ford and neously.It was a calculated attack against a true with small,young trees that will take 75-100 having well-planned and functional facilities that General Motors have set simi- citizen's initiative to limit development.The years to reach the size and benefits of the huge support both students and staff.We have the op- lar MY VIEW deadlines.In the U.S.there overwhelming embrace by the various allied/ad- trees they remove.What is to be done? portunity on Nov.2 to pass a new school bond is bipartisan support to pro- visory groups for the city's referendum is not a Perhaps it is time to inform the public.It is that will allow our community to continue the Duke Castle vide increased financial in- sign that it will benefit the land or the regular cit- time to call for conscience and accountability amazing work being done to improve our centives to accelerate the izens.It only benefits them.Answering the ques- for Renaissance.It is long past time to call for schools.This bond will make LOSD a much more transition. tion"Who decides"clears up a lot of confusion. trees over greed. sustainable district by upgrading school build- So now is the time to begin considering Finally,in order to save Springbrook,and to Roberta Badger-Cain ings to reduce energy use and dependence on which EV is right for you. extend the same charter protection to the re- Portland fossil fuels,modernize kitchens to allow inclu- Fortunately the list of available EVs is rap- maining parks,you need to vote yes on the citi- sion of local and school-raised foods in the lunch idly growing.Two of the hottest new EVs zen's initiative,measure 3- ,but you also have Increased jobless benefits program,and to allow students to use their available this year are the Ford Mustang Mach to vote no on the city's competing referendum. school buildings as examples of sustainable prac- E and Volkswagen ID.4,both larger SUV sized Whichever of the two gets the greater number of would hurt businesses tices as they develop the critical thinking skills vehicles.Right behind them is an increasing affirmative votes will win. that will guide our community in the future. number of trucks from Rivian,Ford and Tesla. Theresa Kohlhoff It was very interesting to read in the Lake I hope you will join me in voting for the 2021 Concerned about cost?Take a look at the Lake Oswego Oswego Review last week about Senator Ron Lake Oswego School Bond and providing our Nissan Leaf S which goes for$17,400 after fi- Wyden's plans to"work hard"to increase un- students and staff with a sustainable future. nancial incentives.Concerned about range? Trees over greed employment benefits.He has always seemed to Stephanie Wagner Take a look at the Lucid Air Sedan with antake pride in how much of other people's mon- Lake Oswego EPA rated range of 520 miles or the Tesla Mod- Yet another huge tree in Southeast Portland, ey(actually,our money)he can give away. el S Long Range at 405 miles. a gigantically tall fir,on the edge of a property But in the very same newspaper was a de- School bond vote will bolster The way to really find out what's going on is acquired by Renaissance Custom Homes LLC, tailed report about the impact of very lucrative to talk to EV owners at our fourth annual EV is about to be demolished so that this Lake Os- unemployment benefits granted in the name of education, property values Fair on Saturday,Oct.2.It will be held in the wego-based home development corporation COVID(and written into law primarily through parking lot of the Lake Oswego United Meth- can,once again,maximize profits.In June,Re- Wyden's influence).All of this while congress Much has been said and written about the odist Church at 1855 South Shore in Lake Os- naissance took down all the trees on another contemplates a spending bill larger than most Lake Oswego school bond on which residents wego from 10 a.m.to 2 p.m.There will be over SE property,including two huge,healthy ce- of the large expenditure bills of the last several are about to vote.I add my endorsement.We all 40 EVs there with their owners to answer your dars,also at the property's edge,despite Re- years...combined.Our Senator wants to know the quality and reputation of our schools questions.There will also be a section devoted naissance putting up fencing encircling the proudly display this as helping the American and it only stands to reason that we would want to electric bikes,bikes that can make the hills largest trees with signs,"Do not disturb root worker while forgetting he would give this to continue to enjoy the superior education that of Lake Oswego more manageable. systems,"misleading neighbors and the caring money by stepping down and crushing small our schools provide.Something that might es- And if you want to get a head start on doing public into thinking the trees would be saved, businesses and average taxpayers.Please don't cape the understanding of residents,and that your homework,consider attending our pre- only to have them removed,both above-ground present his promises as some kind of welcome bears mentioning,is the indisputable link that fair online event this Thursday,Sept.23 at 6:30 and their root balls below ground.Similar fenc- news.It's a disaster. exists between a quality school system and prop- p.m.where we will have a panel of four owners ing and signage surrounds the fir. Harold Rust erty values.LO property values are in the top 4% available to answer your most pressing ques- Such large,mature trees are beings of mag- Lake Oswego of residential property values in the state.Any- tions.You can register at bit.ly/LOSN-EVFAQ nificent beauty.They are of inestimable value one who owns property in LO can expect their or at losn.org for reducing CO2 and adding oxygen to our at- School bond will help build property to increase in value as property values So if you want to help deal with the climate mosphere;they enhance the water table.Huge continue to rise generally,except that LO prop- crisis,improve air quality while having fun trees are also known to provide a sense of well- a sustainable future erties outpace those of other communities in the and saving money begin researching the ques- being and a sign of thriving neighborhoods. state.That is a direct consequence of the quality tion:Which EV is right for you? They provide cooling in hot weather and pro- I have had the pleasure of working with excep- education children in LO receive.Vote yes on the tection from extreme weather events.They tional students and teachers at all of the schools Lake Oswego School Bond. Duke Castle is the co-founder of the Lake Oswego provide sanctuary for birds,pollinators and in the Lake Oswego School District.We have Steven A. Stupak Sustainability Network. wildlife. worked together to support development of a Lake Oswego ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MedlaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING - Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 9 • • uPlnlon Pamplin MediaGroup A6 • Wednesday, October 6, 2021 /Thursday, October 1, 2021 — Howtraumar m t frustrates me that years work itsf in DNas prejug mily in Otaw , hiao, o e wn in a cuay , he lan Lake Oswego Scho ol District in stillthe still reelingel fromtomy the suddenA— deathwhenI ofw the townBeyond isissues an anomaly.ofrace I'andve lived indice, jinn gtofan,D.C.,Rwt anda.a C I'vec taken gWash soli- it toth dissociateto entirely.ople wTherest's p an take up space in my brain. my mother and the tragic loss of a be- many places,from the tart'drives up and down ocean of respect in my heart for those The city that loved cousin in 2015—I West Coast to New the Golden Coast and who still fight for the improvement of shrunk my once-gigantic can only imagine the England to South Afri- RXBPOND TO RACISM Lo visited friends,includ- this small town. world down to one sub- MYVIEW challenges Black people ca and back.There's ing reconnecting with a But out of love and respect for a bro- urb finds new ways to face who live their none other like LO. .b t, few old ones from South ken 14-year-old boy who neglected his punish me. Daniel Nsengimana whole lives in LO. Maybe that's why so 9 I. 0 Africa and exchanging own wounds to lick those of a town It manifests in the I dealt with anti Black many people find their A A. old photos and words of that wasn't even his,now I choose my- 0 R painful memories them- taunts from my peers, way back there,and G N P love.I even wrote a self.And I want the Black children of selves,as well as the new understand- racist graffiti on the walls and an ad- children attend the , I novel and was rein- this town to know that they can do the ing of just how messed up things were. ministration that danced around its rot same schools their G troduced to a boy same. It also frustrates me that the expecta- until it no longer could. parents did,and the who loved to tell sto- tion seems to still be that Black chil- I've tried to find hope when that strange language of ries. Daniel Nsengimana attended Lake Oswego dren are supposed to solve the age-old same administration would eventually the city moves through genera- In my life after LO,I reflect on a High School from 2014-17,where he was problems of the town. feign interest in positive change,only tions. lesson that's been brought to me in heavily involved in issues of race and so- It's a lot to move with,and there are to watch them retreat to the status quo It took me a long time to remember many forms since I left:it's hard to let cial justice.He still resides in Portland and many from this town who carry it and the stability it provides each time. that there was life before Lake Oswe- go of pain while holding onto the thing his current focus is publishing his novel. around wherever they go. Sometimes I still find myself balling go.I remembered this through revisi- that gave it to you. More information can be found at childre- If the city only needed three years to my fists as the memories take over. tations of the world I once knew,visit- So,while I still find myself attached nofthesunbook.com. Ci• SC11001 d1StrlCt READERS'LETTERS Support LO school bond While supporters of both measures change,the Referendum opens the partners ur Lake Oswego School Dis- value the same things,only Measure door to reducing the natural parks. partnership can trict does an outstanding job #3-575 offers both preservation and Understandably,the large dollar providing a supportive envi- the balance for protection within a donations to the Referendum's PAC • ronment for students to management framework based on the are by development,real estate and b e improved learn and grow,setting them up for individual uniqueness of our natural business individuals. p successful careers and lives. areas. The Sierra Club and Oregon Wild Like many of our neighbors,the Voters will choose one of these compared the two measures and strong reputation of Lake Oswego measures which will change the strongly endorsed the Initiative as he city and Lake Oswego should,but no money has been al T schools was a determining factor in City's Charter,which sits at the very better protecting our natural parks. School District(LOSD) located to possible increases in our moving here over 20 years ago. highest level of our municipal struc- ture. The referendum eliminates the full leaders agreed by at least the cost of the planned aquatic Our two children thrived attending Charter protection for Springbrook 2020,if not sooner,to center. schools in the district and have now Since the current amendment has Park.Initiative 3-568 continues full evenly split the capital construe- Indeed,there has been no as- moved on to careers of their own. lasted for 43 years,any change must protection.The initiative supports tion costs of an aquatic and recre- signment whatsoever of possible We urge you to support LOSD come after careful consideration.We natural material trails that meet ation center that is now bond premium monies School Bond Measure 3-577 to help as- need a measure that is balanced and ADA standards,including wheelchair planned for a chunk of from the proposed$180 sure that future generations of chil- provides the best preservation and access.To state otherwise is non- the property at the mu million measure or inter- dren will have access to the same enhancement of the natural areas sense. nicipal golf course on est earned on the differ- (perhaps better!)experience. while allowing for prudent use and "Maintenance"defined in the Initia- Stafford Road. / - ence between the timing Bond funds will be used to replace access. tive does not prohibit rehabilitation of But that is not the way .r - of the issuance of the two of our older schools(Lake Oswe- Please visit friendsofloparks.org to existing facilities or facilities that are it appears to be working 1 `r--"►' ' bonds and the expendi- go Junior High and River Grove Ele- read about three examples that show otherwise allowed.It does not prohib- out,with the city on the I tures of dollars for proj- mentary). how these measures fare when ap- it storm clean-up.It allows the re- hook for an increasingly ects. In addition,bond funds will allow plied to prospective changes at Iron moval of dead or other trees that are larger share of a rapidly n�n.IEw The bond premium is LSD to make repairs,improve acces- Mountain Park. dangerous to trail use or facilities and growing price tag. 11r�11��Y� the amount of money the sibility,enhance safety and security, Clearly,when balancing ecological for removing invasive species. Initially,the project Jeff man Gud School District will get and modernize classrooms through- care and stewardship with respectful Vote"Yes"on BM 3-568 and"No" was projected to cost$30 because of issuing more out the district.Please see buil- human use and access,the City's Nat- on BM 3-575. million,not including debt than anticipated dinggreatloschools.com to learn more ural Preservation Measure 3-575 de- Michael Kohlhoff transportation improvements to compared to projected cash flows the bond and how the funds will be serves your support.Join the mem- Lake Oswego surrounding roadways,etc.,with or if it receives a lower interest used. bers of the many Friends groups who capital costs to be shared equally rate when the bonds are issued Our school buildings average 51 endorse Measure 3-575 so we can deal Confused yet? between the City($15 million)and than it had included in its budget years old.They are becoming outdat- with the real threats. the LOSD($15 million). projections. ed,overcrowded,and inefficient.Now Mike Buck, Vote yes on 3-575 According to the most recent The LOSD also is likely to re- is the time to reinvest in these com- Friends of Iron Mountain chair report to the City Council,howev- ceive interest income for the peri- munity assets. Lake Oswego There are two seemingly similar er,the projected capital cost of the od between when the bond money Please join us in supporting Bond ballot measures about protecting our aquatic/recreation center now is is received and when it is spent by Measure 3-577. natural resources.Only one,the Ilel $36 million and change(still not the district. Alan and Davina Doby p school district City's Measure 3-575,is comprehen- including transportation improve- For the sake of comparison,au- Lake Oswego continue transformation sive,responsive to climate change ments). dited LOSD financial statements and provides the best access to all our Yet the School District's contri- for 2017-18 show the last school This November, Lake Oswego vot- residents to our natural areas.It re- bution remains at$15 million. bond measure approved by voters Continue excellent work ers have the opportunity to continue quires citizen participation in any Meanwhile,the city's share has yielded a bond premium of ap- of school bond the transformation of our school dis- proposed changes to our natural ar- ballooned to$21 million and proximately$17.8 million. trict by supporting the 2021 bond to eas. change—a$6 million increase Given the likelihood of a similar This November,we have the oppor- build safe, modern, exceptional This ballot measure was initiated that will be paid by deferring or financial result,it becomes abso- tunity to continue the excellent work schools. by the hundreds of volunteers in our eliminating other Parks&Recre- lutely clear that equalization of of our last school bond.Lake Oswego The school district has demonstrat- Friends groups who actually do the ation projects and using Parks re- capital contributions for the pro- is highly regarded for its high-quality ed that it is a good steward of taxpayer work to repair,maintain and enhance serve funds. posed aquatic/athletic/recreation public education and school facilities. dollars. With its dedicated, expert our natural areas.It has the endorse- That is certainly a worrisome project,including transportation The upcoming bond will help en- project management team, overseen ment of those Friends groups along trend,especially when you consid- improvements,between the city sure the long-term health of our exist- by a citizen accountability committee, with the endorsements of our current er that the project is still in the and the School District should be ing school facilities and replace two of LOSD has delivered on what was mayor,city council,former mayors, planning stages and is not even the goal. our schools,which have become obso- promised in the first bond—a brand- former city councilors,the Oswego scheduled to break ground until The city should demand that lete and are at the end of their practi- new Lakeridge Middle School,renova- Lake Watershed Council,the Sustain- summer 2022. any bond premium and interest cal lives. tion of Oak Creek Elementary,and in- ability Network,and dozens of Will the city's share continue to earned be allocated to increasing As a member of the previous Bond frastructure improvements at all of thoughtful and concerned citizens of increase exponentially?And is the LOSD's share to 50%of the fi- Accountability Committee,I observed the other buildings,including seismic Lake Oswego. that fair,given that School Dis- nal capital cost of the aquatics/ the expenditure of the last bond first- upgrades. Measure 3-575 is the product of the trict teams will likely have priori- recreation facility,including hand.I am impressed with the team The seismically upgraded buildings many citizens who care about and ty access to the pool and other fa- transportation improvements. LOSD has in place to manage and uti- will not only provide shelter for com- work in our natural areas.It truly cilities? If the projected cost of the lize bond funds effectively and effi- munity members in the wake of a cata- protects and preserves the ecologic To be fair,shared-use arrange- aquatics/recreation center and ciently. clysmic event,but also enable the dis- and environmental functions that are ments between the City and the needed transportation improve- I urge Lake Oswego voters to sup- trict to reopen schools quickly. needed for healthy natural areas. LOSD are still being worked out. ments rises above the$36 million port the new bond and vote yes in No- The 2021 bond will continue this Visit https://friendsofloparks.org/ Also being discussed is the appro- plus projected today,the goal vember.Let's all work to ensure we good work! It will fund the replace- for more information on why 3-575 is priate sharing of the net(revenue should still be equal contributions. have 21st century schools to meet the ment of the aging and outdated Lake the better choice between these two less expense)operating costs of There really is no other conclu- education,technological,and environ- Oswego Junior High and River Grove ballot measures.Vote Yes on 3-575! the aquatic/recreation facility, sion,especially when you realize ment demands of the coming decades. Elementary schools, modernize high Rosie Stephens which audited School District re- that the School District has a big- Bruce Brown school science and engineering labs, Lake Oswego ports put at about$100,000 a year ger tax base than the city;that the Lake Oswego and improve safety features and ac- for the smaller existing pool prior LOSD will have priority access to cessibility at all schools. Citizens' measure would to the COVID-19 pandemic. the pool(s);and that the city is do- For more information on the bond, Nevertheless,the School Dis- ing the School District a favor by Invasive species are real please visit buildinggreatloschools. fully protect parks trict's capital contribution re- letting the LOSD get out of the threat to natural areas com mains at$15 million because all of "pool business." The 2021 LO School is good for our I have done my research into the the capital dollars from its upcom- The city in turn can use the Supporters of Measure 3-568 would students and our community. Please competing parks measures.3-568(citi- ing$180 million bond measure on money it will not have to spend like voters to believe that"develop- join me in voting YES on Measure zens'initiative)was written with the the November ballot are commit- on the aquatic/athletic/recreation ment"constitutes the biggest threat 3-577! full and clear intent to protect our ted to rebuilding Lake Oswego facility and associated transpor- to our natural areas. Courtney A. Clements parks without the influence of corpo- Middle School and River Grove El- tation improvements for other We volunteers engaged in restor- Lake Oswego rate development and the Spring- ementary School;modernizing Parks&Recreation projects,in- ative stewardship on these lands brook Park tennis center. science,technology and engineer- eluding the purchase of land al- share this concern,and yet we know vote t0 truly rotect arks Measure 3-575(City Council initia- ing labs at the high schools for ex- ready for sale in the Stafford ar- that the biggest threats come from a y p p tive)was written late,quickly and is panded STEM and career techni- ea. much different place. Initiative 3-568 better protects our coming from insiders'interest that al- cal education;addressing capital That will allow all of the resi- Critical threats to our natural areas natural area parks than the City's lows expansion of development,cell priority repairs like replacing dents of the city to cast our imagi- come from impacts of invasive spe- Referendum 3-575.Initiative 3-568 towers and other items that don't pro- roofs,HVAC upgrades,seismic nations forward toward future cies(both plants and animals),the ef- places the current natural park areas tect our natural parks. upgrades,etc.;improving accessi- needs,while at the same time un- fects of climate change with loss of into the Charter. It's easy to see if you compare- bility;and making safety and se- derstanding what is truly essen- hydration and exposure to extreme Referendum 3-575 causes the natu- Vote Yes and No curity upgrades in facilities dis- tial versus merely desirable. heat,lack of diversity,encroachments ral park boundaries to be described Yes on 3-568(citizens initiative) trict wide. and human uses,ignorance about by ordinance,changeable by City No on 3-575(City Council initiative) Those projects'capital costs in- Jeff Gudman was a member of the Lake habitat values,fragmentation and ne- Council amendment and eligible for Tom Finnerty elude contingency funds,as they Oswego City Council from 2011-2018. glect. development.In spite of climate Lake Oswego ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING — Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 10 Opinion LGr0uP m Pamplin A6 • Wednesday, October 13, 2021 /Thursday, October 14, 2021 • f: 1 A tale of and : 4. �. • he longest con T munity could con- the morning,followed by breakfast Special thanks to our communi �� Iort;oht i' ! tinuous hanging tinue to enjoy the provided by Joe Buck/Gubanc's. ty partner,Pamplin Media,who • µ basket program MYVIEW color and beauty The pandemic took that very fun, reach out to our donors and recog f -�iv,vti I "' in Oregon is in Julia Fowler these baskets community building experience nize them in the pages of the Lake , ., �•�?� ti y I Lake Oswego,just corn- bring. from us but we will roar back in Oswego Review.Donations are * `' pleting 31 years.It's easy This isn't an 2022 just like founder Doug Oliph- welcome now as we plan for 2022 .' „' ¢`✓'t'I 1 I '� to tell when fall arrives easy program to ant envisioned. and bringing baskets back to < ,' �`' - 1 Ir.in Lake Oswego—by the first of continue.The costs of maintaining Boones Ferry Road baskets will Boones Ferry Road.Go to Takeo- } •1 :b1a,. l', • October,the flower baskets have these gorgeous baskets continues return in 2022 after taking a break swegochamber.com/village-flower- retired.They always go out with a to climb—not because of the cost due to the road construction.We baskets to donate online,mail a �'''ice 0.� •,, w. +. bang,with the most beautiful flow- of the baskets,but because we will need to increase our donations check to LO Chamber Foundation, :. • -4, ,>*. x a to ,,,,� i i i I ers and foliage of the entire season. must continually water them in in- and volunteers to bring baskets PO Box 368,Lake Oswego,Oregon { • - .,� < 4 - , John Karsseboom,owner of The creasing challenging weather. back to Lake Oswego's refreshed 97034 or call 503-636-3634. ‘ ,, ,4 ` 4 4� Garden Corner and supplier to You've seen the trucks at night af- and refurbished business area.If Thank you for your past support ,,;q, ':,a I f Lake Oswego for 31 years,has been ter the traffic dies down—long wa- you think it looks good now,just —thank you for your upcoming _ f €1+ •�� - , , I:;(„ instrumental in providing out- tering wands by very caring gar- wait until we add the floral accents support and we look forward to the y, r. f standing quality and care for our deners.They all deserve extra and flair of flowers. return of the flower baskets in May • 1 ^ ,_ I flower baskets.There are hundreds thanks this year for supporting our You will see flower baskets in 2022.To volunteer,email Julia s," ; no,), , I 9;i of donors in our community who baskets through the hot summer. May when you enter the City from Fowler,flower basket chair, Ju- ,,; ; , c keep this program going with pri- The Flower Basket Committee is Kruse Way,from Highway 43,from lia@bluemoonlo.com. •. vate donations.The Chamber planning now for 2022.Dozens of Stafford/McVey and next year on w�. j Foundation partnership with these volunteers have assisted in the Boones Ferry.Five months of care, Julia Fowler is the chair of the Lake Os- donors '`' '� kept the program going past,raising the flower baskets to five months of beauty,five months wego Chamber of Commerce Flower Bas- PMG FILE PHOTO during the pandemic so our com- their perches in the early hours of of grateful appreciation. ket Committee. It was another successful year for Lake Oswego's flower basket program. . • READERS' tifically,and which guard the ecology Sympathizing with main.They explicitly granted this 42 Citizens can and sanctity of every park and open acres as a natural park under the LETTERS space, and that are developed with nostalgic reader condition it remain free of future input from the stakeholders of our commercial development and it stay parks.Our park is beautiful,and we Oh,how I sympathize with Jim Mc- "forever wild." help bond want to keep it that way.The compet- Carthy ("What happened to the old Measure 3-568 is more than just The name is ing measure is a purely defensive ini- Lake Oswego?;Wednesday,9/29),be- Cooks Butte. It addresses concerns tiative and is not forward looking. cause I grew up in Palo Alto,Califor- neighbors across LO shared for their No, not James but School Bond. Vote NO on Measure 3-568 and YES nia,a town very similar to Lake Os- neighborhood natural parks. And yes, it is time to support Lake on Measure 3 575. ego: civic-minded citizens, out- City Council's opposing measure LakeOswego Oswego School District's second w Thomas C.Bland standing schools, urban-adjacent, won't protect our natural parks;fur- bond so we can continue upgrading Lake Oswego and even affordable once upon a time. thermore, their measure is vague, our educational facilities. But guess what?Times change,and filled with loopholes,and moves park In addition to a professional city f • when you live in a vibrant city, it definitions out of the charter and into government,great police and fire de- The Devil s m the details evolves. The Palo Alto that my par- ordinances which risk future devel- MYVIEW partments,extensive open space and LO voters have an important deci- ents arrived in after World War II opment.And,it's funded by develop- park system,solid economic base and sion on the direction to take to protect was gone by the time I was in high ers. We must protect these natural Lake Oswego Preservation Society friendly neighbors, Lake Oswego's our natural parks this November. school,and Silicon Valley was begin- spaces before they're gone. high quality of life includes a re- This isn't a popularity contest about ning to become a phenomenon.And 3-568 is more precise and focused nowned school system that prepares who we like;it's about how we best it's even more exclusive today,which on leaving our natural parks alone.It ecently an opinion piece wasR children to be productive citizens of protect these neighborhood natural is why I can't afford to live there any- allows for good stewardship includ published in the LO Review the world.In the past few years,we habitats from future development ex more. ing tree thinning and fire mitigation. asking:What happened to the have come to realize that our school ploits. Lake Oswego is changing too,and It allows benches,trails,boardwalks, old Lake Oswego?The writer buildings were not state-of-the-art Like most voters,I prefer making I'm grateful to you and your parents and ADA access.It's led and funded grew up in Lake Oswego's First Addi- and needed significant changes in- informed decisions on the issues.As for making it a place that we came to by citizens for citizens. tion/Forest Hills neighborhood and volving safety,security,energy and they say,the devil's in the details.I've so willingly and found so comfortable. Our natural parks should be pro- was lamenting the loss of charm,open sustainability as well as labs where learned much about LoveLOPark's Howard Baldwin tested and stay free from exploits- space,and neighborhood character in teachers can teach 21st Century Measure 3-568 over the past 18 months Lake Oswego tion and development by LO politi- recent years STEAM(Science,Technology,Engi- from their outreach efforts.They sent cians.Our parks need your help! mainly due to massive amounts of neering,Arts and Mathematics). the full text of their proposed Charter Let's work together Vote YES on Measure 3-568 and demolition of older homes,large old It is difficult to maintain a top-rated amendment and quick reference u—a NO on Measure 3-575. trees,and the creation of smaller lots school district without safe,healthy simple read in plain English. But, I to protect parks Brad Home covered with huge houses. and modern school buildings.LOSD's know little about the details for City Lake Oswego We at the Lake Oswego Preserva- work on the first bond included ex- Council's Measure 3-575.The Voters' The November ballot will have tion Society agree. tensive security and building im- Pamphlet won't have the full legal two competing measures concerning All of LO should Most Lake Oswegans would say that provements for several schools and LO natural areas. One will win and text of either charter amendment, preserving our history,valuing sus- construction of the much needed Lak- only summaries and explanatory replace Chapter X in our City Char- support school bond tainability,and recognizing climate eridge Middle School. Bond #2 will statements.This is insufficient to un ter(Constitution).If you signed the change are values we embrace.But continue this excellent work and re- initiative,good for you to care about I no longer have school-age kids, derstand the effects on our natural just like with climate change,unless place Lake Oswego Junior High and parks —voters need more! Where our natural areas. I read the initia- but I still believe it is important for we take action to support those values River Grove Elementary.It will also does a voter go to easily access and tive and decided not to sign it.I was all residents to support public now,it will be too late.In 2019,sixty- address lab upgrades at both high read the full text of City Council's pro- not alone.My fellow Friends Groups schools. That's why I urge support seven demolition permits were issued schools,while enhancing HVAC sys- posed Charter amendment? leaders,etc.were also concerned.In for the 2021 school bond. in LO.Several of those houses were tems,kitchens,restrooms,sidewalks, I found a helpful resource with 2019 we started meeting regularly to For the last several years some built before the turn of the century playgrounds and parking lots both measures' text and compari carefully examine and discuss the Lake Oswego schools have been up- thus contributing to the loss of our throughout the District. initiative. We became the "Friends graded or rebuilt thanks to the previ- sons(not surprising,on the LoveLO- unique history.Since Jan 1,2021 there As a father of a child about to at- Parks website). You might find it of LO Parks". And, we really do ous bond.Now,LO Junior High and have been 30 demolition permits is- tend elementary school, a recent LOVE our parks.Our members have River Grove Elementary need to be sued. Lake Oswego City Councilor and a helpful too:lovelo 'm voting compare worked in the natural areas for replaced. Other schools don't need I Architect Carl Elefante's commonly professional City Planner who has It s now clear. YES on years,most for decades. replacement but do need efficiency quoted phrase,"the greenest building worked in the public and private sec Measure 3 568 and NO on Measure After careful consideration, we improvements, safety and seismic is the one that's already built"sus- tors,I know the value of a strong pub- 3-575. reached out to see if we could collabo- upgrades, better disability access, cinctly expresses the relationship be- Tic school system.Modern school fa- Ann Savage rate with the initiative leader. The improved HVAC systems, modern- tween preservation and sustainability. cilities allow children to be inspired Lake Oswego answer was no.We turned to the city ized kitchens and STEM facilities to When we leave all the decisions up to and thrive. They are work environ- and asked them to take our ideas and improve safety and learning opportu- the developers,we encourage demoli- ments for teachers to truly do their Measure 3-568 create an alternative measure that nities for all students. tions,and are complicit in the loss. jobs. Schools are also neighborhood better preserves, protects, restores Good public schools benefit our en- When we are passive about losing our gathering places and emergency has integrity and maintains our natural areas. tire community by educating our fu- historic assets,they will disappear, community shelters.A strong school Residents have been working Measure 575 is more comprehen- ture workforce and community lead- and our lack of action permits the loss system, with modern facilities, also hard for at least 18 months, as a sive:allows paved paths and parking ers.We should continue investing in of our history. contributes to stable property values. where needed providing access for the buildings themselves to support What can we do to step up to the It is time again to back the Bond. Part of a grass roots effort, to get all citizens;permits service roads for the educational mission. plate?Actually,a lot.But we have to Please vote Yes for Lake Oswego's the Citizen's Measure 3 568 on the wildfire prevention, public safety Tom Atwood get involved and let our City Council School District's Bond#2 on this No- ballot. The driving force has been and ongoing maintenance;promotes Lake Oswego know that we support and want chang- vember's Ballot. the shared belief that Lake Oswego active management; promotes col- es to our code that encourage renova- John LaMotte natural parks urgently need pro- laboration and cooperation and al- tion over demolition,that when demo- Lake Oswego tection from development. lows for future natural areas to be Progress on health care litions are warranted,the buildings are Upon close inspection, Measure added without a city-wide election. shouldn't be halted deconstructed vs.being thrown in the 3-575 actually does little to protect Measure 575 protects ALL natural landfill,and that our historic resources Friends of Springbrook our nature parks. For example, af- areas,22,not the 16 of the initiative. One of the most important lessons must be maintained and not left to rot Park Supports ter the election,City Council has 60 Other city leaders have compared we learned during this pandemic is resulting in demolition by neglect. days to decide which areas within the initiative and are endorsing 575: that far too many Americans lack ac- We as citizens have the resources measure 3-575 specific parks are"Natural Areas." All of the Friends Groups, several cess to affordable health care.Yet,we and the power to make changes.Let As a long time board member of So, the Measure would not neces- Neighborhood Associations,the LO are making headway because of a re- your voice be heard and get involved. Friends of Springbrook Park, and a sarily include the entire area of Sustainability Network,the OL Wa- markable federal program that low- Our City has a dedicated Historic Re- nearly thirty year resident of Lake each park! Furthermore, a map of tershed Council,the P&R Board,the ers the cost of health coverage.This sources Advisory Board(HRAB),and Oswego, I want to share with the the boundaries of"Natural Areas" City Council, former mayors and year,the American Rescue Plan ex- a Mayor and City Council who actively community why Friends of Spring- would be adopted "by ordinance." councilors and scores of individual panded subsidies for those who pur- listen to the community about the brook Park supports measure 3-575. This removes Charter protection citizens. Please visit our website: chase insurance through the insur- Building Code and ordinances,but The original City of Lake Oswego allowing City Council to easily FriendsofLOParks.org and join me in ance marketplace. they need to hear from you.There is Charter section was designed to pro- change the boundaries in the future protecting our natural areas by vot- But much of this progress could also the Lake Oswego Preservation So- tect Springbrook Park.We want that with a 4-3 vote. This is especially ing YES on 575."Our city is stronger soon be lost if Congress fails to make ciety which welcomes your participa- section replaced with a forward look- alarming for Springbrook Park when we work together." these tax credits permanent before tion in our work to preserve,protect, ing measure. Our Friends group is which is currently under the urn- Barbara Fisher the end of the year. Without subsi- and advocate for Lake Oswego's built probably the most committed and in- brella of Charter X. Lake Oswego dies,millions of Americans and thou- environment and historic assets. volved guardian of Springbrook Park. In comparison,the Citizen's Mea- sands of Oregon families would be Check out our website at lakeoswe- Collectively we have invested thou- sure 3-568 is transparent and much Don't be fooled forced to choose between paying the gopreservationsociety.org.Join us to sands of hours into the preservation, stronger. Upon ratification, all 15 bills and their premiums. This in- make change! maintenance and improvement of the parks listed will be designated as a We can't trust the City of LO td eludes Oregonians like my brother park. It is long past the point when "Nature Preserve." Furthermore, protect our natural parks. Three and his wife,who operate a small or- The Board of the Lake Oswego Preservation Springbrook Park,and in fact every the entire area of each park will be times since 1993 the City has tried to ganic family farm in Forest Grove. Society consists of Jon Gustafson,Rachel park and open space in the City,can protected under Chapter X. build a large communications tower These subsidies are now the only rea- Verdick,Craig Prosser,Susan Stier,Denise be effectively preserved,maintained Please vote YES on Measure 3-568 in Cooks Butte Park.Our community son they've been able to afford care. Bartelt,Emogene Waggoner,Randy Arthur, and managed without a site specific and NO on Measure 3-575! was there each time to protect this Gail Toft-Vizzini,Larry Snyder and Joan management plan.We need manage- Ann Mikulka natural habitat as grantors John and See READERS'LETTERS/Page A7 Moore. ment plans that are developed scien- Lake Oswego Marjorie Emery intended it to re- C1ackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LalceOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinnl'iding� CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING - Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,October 13,2021/Thursday,October 14,2021 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News • West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman A7 READERS Help LO schools pie 4:3 vote. 3-575 is nothing No accident natural parks. the appropriate forum to en- more than an ordinance in char- Vote NO on the City Council's gage citizens in hammering out LETTERS build strong ter disguise.The revolving door Oregon Wild and the Sierra open ended "do as they want" comprehensive and effective foundation of City leadership, staff, their Club's Oregon Chapter chose to Measure 3-575. Vote YES on direction for the city's natural Iu4� own agendas should concern endorse Citizens' Measure Citizen's right to vote on chang- area protection and preserva- 30 years ago, my wife and I every resident. 3-568.Let that sink in.These or- es that may be made to these tion policies. • From Page A6 moved back to Lake Oswego to As residents of 50 years,our ganizations are recognized natural parks with Measure Noel Klein ensure our three daughters had community has one opportunity leaders in environmental and 3-568. Lake Oswego a strong school system to help to enact lasting legal protec- conservation efforts. Their en- Do not let the whims of each Senator Ron Wyden and Con- shape their futures.Their years tions for our natural parks. Si- dorsements were neither acci- new City Council forever take Dona be fooled gressman Kurt Schrader play a attending Lake Oswego schools f'rra Club and Oregon Wild en- dental nor a token handout,but away and change our natural critical role in Congress over gave them a strong foundation Corse 3-568;you should,too! were achieved only after scru- areas that were designated and by City measure health care policy,and they can for their college experiences, YES on 3-568 and NO on 3-575. tiny of both the citizens' mea- given to the city to remain as play a key role in making sure careers,and life.I encourage all Stephanie&John Detjens sure and the city council refer- nature at its best. They paved Paradise and put these expanded subsidies are LO voters to help current and Lake Oswego endum. Both organizations YES on Measure 3-568 up a parking lot! made permanent.This is a sig- future students in your commu- have recognized that Measure NO on Measure 3-575 The politicians are up to their nific ant opportunity to help nity build a strong foundation in 3-568's development limitations USE YOUR VOTE TO SAVE old shenanigans. This Novem- even more Americans get the LO schools by voting YES on LOCAL Citizens protect our natural parks best. YOUR VOTE! ber there are two measures on coverage they need and deserve the upcoming 2021 School Bond. and community Would implementation of Anne Carter the ballot both seemingly to pro- - people across Oregon are This $180 million bond will Measure 3-568 continue to allow Lake Oswego tect our natural parks.But the counting on them to deliver for replace the expiring LO School leaders endorse our steward groups,friends of citizen's initiative — Measure us. bond and result in no additional Measure 3 575 parks, and City to tend and Measure 3-568 3-568,was led and funded by vot- Cay Borduin tax increases. It will allow the maintain these parks?Absolute- ers like you.The politician's— Lake Oswego school district to replace both Measure 3-575 is citizen-led ly!Measure 3-568 specifically al- introduces concerning Measure 3-575,which happens to Lake Oswego Junior High and is endorsed by Lake Oswe- lows building"trails for hiking, use very similar language to the Look to Woodmont School and River Grove Ele- go's Friends groups, the Lake jogging,horseback and bicycle charter change citizen's measure,is a slight of mentary. These new buildings Oswego Sustain ability Net- riding,may provide benches,in- Measure 3-568 attempts to re- hand with the intention of trick- when considering both will be built to current seis- work,the Oswego Lake Water- terpretive displays, and may solve a NIMBY neighborhood ing voters into voting yes on mic standards and can be con- shed Council, current and for- provide picnic and sanitary fa- dispute with a one-size-fits-all both measures.Don't be fooled. measures verted quickly into emergency mer mayors and city councilors, cilities." It also encourages Charter limitation on citizens' If you vote yes for the citizen's Woodmont Natural Park community shelters in case of a many Neighborhood Associa- maintenance for"ecological res- ability to manage the city's nat- measure(3-568)and yes for the would be in a more natural state natural disaster.In addition,the tions and dozens upon dozens toration that provides a safe and ural areas. politician's(3-575)you will be ne- as life-long resident Donald bond will help improve the of individual citizens.They en- healthy natural area that is ac- The Charter is the city's Con- gating the citizen's initiative.It's Meyer had intended under citi- STEM programs at both high dorse it because it protects all of cessible for public enjoyment, stitution describing"why"the the ole "heads I win tails you zen-initiated Measure 3-568. schools, enhance HVAC sys- the city's natural areas, pre- provides a healthy habitat for government exists and"what" lose"trick. The deed included language tems to improve air quality,and vents development,enables the wildlife, eliminates invasive it is intended to be.The thresh- Think about it. Why two such as: "be maintained by more. means to combat climate species,restores native species, old to change the Charter is measures?A grassroots group Grantee in its historical natural I encourage all Lake Oswego change and provides access to and mitigates fire hazards." high i.e., a citywide vote. A canvassed door-to-door and ob- condition;" "retain such of the voters to join my wife and I in our natural areas to all of us. Measure 3-568 has been inten- Charter is not usually cluttered tained enough voter signatures tall nesting grasses." After voting YES on the upcoming The citizens who endorse tionally endorsed by two gold- with details about"how"things to get Measure 3-568 on the No- much public debate and rede- 2021 LO Schools Bond to help 3-575 are the people with the standard environmental organi- should be done.To lead this ef- vember ballot.Then,cunningly, sign,this natural park is more ensure a strong foundation for most skin in the game when it zations,while the city council's fort,the Charter creates a gov- City Hall politicians introduce developed than natural. our community's future. comes to protecting,preserving opposing measure 3-575 has erning body of elected citizens, their own measure.Odd isn't it? Had Woodmont been a"Na- Jay Hamachek and enhancing our natural ar- been funded by developers and the City Council. And who might be behind this? ture Preserve"under Measure Lake Oswego eas. They have volunteered special interest groups.None of Lake Oswego's attractive- According to required contribu- 3-568, unnecessary develop- thousands of hours of their time this is an accident. ness today is due in large part tion filings,developers like Re- ment could have been avoided: Measures couldn't in clearing invasives, planting Please vote YES on our to the work of hundreds of dedi- naissance Homes who contrib- • Size of developable land natives, working on manage- LoveLOParks Measure 3-568 cated citizen volunteers donat- uted $10,000 to fund it, are area(4.8 of 6.8 acres) be more different ment plans,attending meetings and NO on the City's Measure ing thousands of hours of ser- working behind the scenes to •Increased water consump- and working with the city's 3-575.Visit www.LoveLOParks. vice on City Councils, various thwart the voters'will. tion with permanent irrigation One would think that Lake stewardship coordinators to im- com for more information com- Boards and Commissions,Advi- I have to give them credit. •Major grading of 40%of de- Oswego citizens have two rea- prove our natural areas. paring these measures. sory Groups and other involve- It's a brilliant strategy! By in- velopable land sonable measures to protect our These local citizens are the Kirsten Sommer ment activities; all engaged in troducing their ostensibly in- •Stockpiling existing topsoil natural parks.Digging deeper, ones who understand and know Lake Oswego the process of balancing a vari- nocuous measure they win if •Removal of original grass- you'll find they couldn't be more our natural areas and who are ety of competing ideas that you vote for theirs even if you es and 393 trees. different. working to ensure that the oat- shape the community. also vote yes for the citizen's •Erosion from grading Measure 3-568,led and fund- ural areas are here for all of us Save your right to vote Measure 3-568 promotional measure.What a scam. •Incompatible planting con- ed by neighbors for 18+months, now and in the future. Look at the so called"Nature materials dismiss these efforts Make no mistake. If you ditions seeks to enshrine sensible legal Join our local citizens and Park" on Iron Mountain Road as "a tedious public process." want to restrict the develop- •Contentious public process definitions into our City's Char- community leaders in support next to the Hunt Club.Where is By sowing discord and a lack of ment of our parks you must —original plan was rejected by ter for our natural parks,their of 3-575. the natural beauty in the large trust in the process,they set the vote yes on 3-568 and no on City Council due to strong pub- acreage and boundaries, and Vote Yes on 3-575! paved parking lot the city built stage for proponents to lock 3-575.Don't fall for the City Hall lie opposition (including parks development limitations.If rati- Nancy Gronowski there? limitations to their liking into chicanery! board members) fied, these parks and protec- Lake Oswego Save your right to vote on fu= the Charter. Jeffrey Bowman •Loss of carbon sinks due to tions can only be amended by ture similar development of our The public process remains Lake Oswego loss of mature vegetation voters. Springbrook Park's We must change the current Charter Chapter X established • 1 city processes with those that by citizens in 1978 is proof posi 1.10BBY 1.0BBY FIND A LOCATION NEAR YOU OR SHOP.ONLINECLO E H UNDAY BY.COM STORE HOURS:9A.M.-8 P.M.• CLOSED SUNDRYprotect natural resources,limit- live that strong charter protec- PRICES GOOD IN STORES MONDAY,OCTOBERi11—SATURDAY,OCTOBER 16,2021. ing climate change.There's no lions work. PRICES GOOD ONLINE SUNDAY,OCTOBER 10—SATURDAY,OCTOBER 16,2021. SOME ADVERTISED ITEMS NOT AVAILABLE ONLINE.SALES SUBJECT TO SUPPLY IN STOCK.AD DOES NOT APPLY TO PRE-REDUCED ITEMS. question Citizens' Measure Measure 3-575, led by our 3-568 will improve protection of Mayor, City Council and City- natural resources with endorse- affiliated groups and funded by Fl 0 M E DECOR 5007F �,..ments from Sierra Club and Or- special interests and develop- / , 1 ' egon Wild. ers,seeks to defer natural park FEATURING TABLE DECOR 1 - _ Please consider voting"YES" definitions, their acreage and Categories Listed on Measure 3-568 and"NO"on boundaries,and development to Glass Decor A Glass Department and Does not include Seasonal Department or items labeled Wall Decor and Gifts Measure 3-575. City ordinances—AFTER we /� craft glass containers (II4P., ) Ceramic,Resin DecorativeDoes not include craft stained glass Floral Containers ,fir/1�, Bill Jaursch vote. City Council can amend � Lake Oswego ordinances any time with a situ , storage Wicker e,boxes,Department Decorative Table Clocks,Spheres &Vases Ceramic,glass,pottery, il► ray ' &Pottery Decor trays,metal&cloth &Globes resin,wood&metal Does not include"Your Price"items Does not include I e ,III "Your Price"items jpff UNITED STATES Statement of Ownership,Management,and Circulation Decorative Lanterns, Metalme a Decor Enamel galvanized& decor Lamps Wooden Table Decor POSTAL SERVICE®(All Periodicals Publications Except Requester Publications) Birdcages&Terrariums Includes Crafts Department &Plaques ,.Publiwaon rue 2.Pudlwtian Number 3.Filing Dam Lake Oswego Review 3 0 2 5 4 0 October 1,2021 re 00 y 6"pmb P"blieceda tipsily 6 A^pal6pb dpnq. Fall,Christmas,Summer and items labeled The Spring Shop®are not included in Home Decor sale. Weekly q 52 $50 DPmpleeMa"gAaare apfxnP nDM amPpbll.non(NPlpdnm„(3lreegm wn,Y,n°,,.aw=IP<®, DPMadParean REWARD POINTS ARE DELAYED AND INCONVENIENT DISCOUNTS.WE HAVE THOUSANDS OF PRESENT-TIME DISCOUNTS EVERY WEEK, Kim Stephens 400 2nd St,Lake Oswego Oregon 970343127 Telephone(lovwle area cone) 9712047818 FALL DECOR, PARTY, CHRISTMAS DECOR CHRISTMAS 8.Cnwplem Mailln9 Address or Heedq,wte,e or General Business OMca ofP,,hf,0er(NM«,44) PO Box 548,Lake Oswego Oregon 970340248 FLORAL & CRAFTS �� Q/Q p �� , _, TREES Arrangements,bushes, 40 O • ompMm Ma ngAmreaeaa pb aher Ea mr aria Manag lg Ea mr(DPpPI"am wanx) $ Publ sltear(NemeeM wmPlam meilin9 eEtlreu)rP - �p""- N wreaths,garlands,swags, OFF "''Bran Mon hen,PO Box 548 Lake Oswego Oregon 9]034-0248 ;, ,. stems,picks,ribbon and fabric IIncludes fabric. 1.O ' O Eamr(NameaM wpm,am°x'"g°°ors, Litt " U Does not include OFF Patrick Melee,PO Box 548 Lake Oswego Oregon 97034-0248 4n%OOFF CHRISTMAS needlearthtacc sore - _ light sets,light accessories 12 in 12 ft __ _ Be,eare Eaimr(Nan.u00000pam mairng aaamaa, Does not include floral custom designs,candy or food or Scotch®tape - --- CHRISTMAS FLORAL CHRISTMAS _ CHRISTMAS LIGHT SETS O.Oynnr(Do rKK Issas Wank.lime WONce,mn la avnedbYa corywmmn,glue fhe name aM seeress Mme corpwefmn hnmadlamlY fgnoasdbY Ills ®°. antes an reuse ofallsmdbdaen oamlrgwMlaing,perrontarm°reol Na laRl amountol9aax.l/rwf owrrea5Ya c«porekn,glve,ba Arrangements,bushes, wreaths,garlans,swags, AliCRAFTS — �_- — & ACCESSORIES aneada fire imMnduel owners l/asmedbyepMmrsWpw WlreruMncwporstedflrm give as name endedtlreuuareNea,hors of � - • ;gin�aipmp., ll new.WiPadgniaw.Wianaaera,mnproMorgaM:ar giya4anamaamadareaa, I=__.... Complete Mailing Address stems,picks and ribbon _ - Q/ "` Oregon Publications PO Box 22109,PONand Oregon 97269-2109 Q/ MI Q % ° 250F Fiit 4O i 40OFF . OFF ' i Includes Mini Lights,C9s,Net Lights,LED Lights Does not include custom designs and Battery Operated Light Strands Knoaq�da re Mq� a antl�M1er3�M1yHgaare�nng«HCo^pl teMem°rAdre�Tp�AmP"nrgfaq as Mq^g see gr WEDDING 501. CA1111 ALL YAR N lips araeondhd roans d gee,,u .©Nana FUII Nama Complete Mantua Address Categories Listed All Items Labeled Studio His&Hers® Everyskein,brand, color and size Lam' Invitations,toasting glasses, I ring pillows,bouquets and more y 'q" r,' i ) O i 1�Sra°r. eimip,., ,... Ribbon&Trims by the Roll Ip %1 1' /O Ribbon,bows,tulle&deco mesh in our z ( ) ( �'bi, �,, OFF =stunts rF«awn„m000o, ,000nenizat�00e000zaammelarngn,00,eloe)(Coe,00,e) Wedding,Floral and Fabric Departments - Does not include thread and floss m vpmoaa,rpnPaon,ala nonproM alma W this organbalmn ala ma a.ampl amwa ror raaarel InPpma m.ppmp.aa: WEARABLE ART BEST—SELLING BOOKS PARTY PS Fo,m 3S26,Juy 20,4 ryape,eld(sre inrtrucliw,°peae 4))PSN:T5300,-000-993r PRNACY NOT;CE.See cur pr;racy p°liryen www.ueps.°m. 4c_m , Does not include Seasonal Department a • Gildan®Youth Always T-Shirts % Bibles,Devotionals, ':�'oa'-' and Adult Always 30%off the marked price* GET OUT Streamers Candy Wafers :vni ,a.Publication Tee ,a.lswe Dam ror amgla9Pn Dam fielpw Z gg OFF Gift Books and YOUR HE 200'Ro 990 12 oz ba 1.99 Short-Sleeve 9 Includes Youth and Adult Short-Sleeve T-Shins, Regular 2.99 Lake Oswego Review September 22,2021 T-Shirts Marked price* Baseball&Long Sleeve T-Shirts,Sweatshins, Children's Books __ Solid Color 9 ��s?,1V, IS.extant and Nature m circulation S4.27 Infant&Toddler T-Shirts and Creepers ALWAYS - Tissue Paper gg q•" AwagaNCl pP amaiaola 8count ¢ and �• os "one ce404a Bandanas Does not include Cricut°branded apparel 4OOf _ 5O0/O Ham(aiue24 of Fondant 5.996 �4t Prep.ams tz Month.x realm Fllmg oat. P y AM AS AII TUII O All Paper Napkins,Cups yw•ai a.Total soecc,Mconi,e(Nelpress tun) 4261 ° 5222 gg Prised p'40/o Boas 3 M 99 OFF OFF &Plates 50'4 white Fondant 1 J pp + ��&•' PFOCIUCts OFF THE MARKED PRICE* Solids&Prints OFF 5lb Vanilla 1 J a7 a7 �a'�i:'� n) i4cB bummecouny Pam s°bs«ip,iona stunts On PS Fom,3sa,Unease pals 209 196 s u n enom nal ram.ad44 44-Lu oor wqu,aria exchange mpma) b Paid M'iw i3)a, , re; wrate,'rod ,a ; a, ' iea) 2355 2900 FRAMES 50o F CRAFTS 30o '0104 Categories Listed OD Categories Listed °M°'d° MDIamaMmo,mma me roans mapelnpsa�mce%noeaana came'', eM°`° "' Mve«m �Meraal ,antlDl^er alaD^ �m DecoArt®,Ceramcoat®, Candle Wax,Candle Gel, Mosaic Tiles,Gems, °aP�` 591 700 Wall Frames Shadow Boxes,Display ® TM Pad D'mtibubon b Xier Classes of Mail Through Me LISPS Poster,document and FolkArt and Anita'sTM Soa Blocks&Bases Chi s&Stones lei log R"0m'°"°®' 0 0 portrait frames with glass Cases&Flag Cases Craft Paint P P c.Toml Pea D'smbuoon lsumdfuryl(z)(3).aria Mll 3155 3795 -\ ,,,` ,y. 2 oz,4 oz,8 oz and 16 oz Leather and Leather Kits Individual Photo Frames Collage Frames Priced$4.99&Up Diamond Dote Free f (1) Free or Nominal Remomaaacounycwiesha aedo,es00 n3541 o o ' Our entire selection of ClayIncludes open stock Rate a' F-- basic&fashion table frames Pcoo]z• p a Dshibmkm(2) FreewNomlrelem,lnCouny0050,lnd4acd,oPOCO,ed541 0 0 and wooden photo storage Ready-Made Open Frames : . Modeling,oven-bake&air-dry Krylon®Spray Paint &sampler pack (9YMaa °"a rel Ram Copies Mailed al Other Classes rough Me LISPS the Ma(0 (31 Fire[-Geuecle T ° ° PAPER CRAFTS 400 Cricut Explore AirTM 2 ART SALE Master's Touch® (d) F,ee«Noe,fuOcleoidnbuaonou;aiae0400)lce,eersw«narmaana, 708 1021 Categories Listed All Master's Touch®&Fine Touch® Art Sets 50% OFF a.Total Free orNommal Ram Daemon(Sum of IWO),n,.(3)a,w(d» 708 1021 The Paper Studio°& Planners&Planner Stickers All Punches& 199 00, Acrylic,Oil,Watercolor,Pencil&Pastel Cricutr Vinyl by The Happy Planner' Punch Sets O 1.Total D,da„neon(Sant anxana sat ' 3863 eels and Agenda 52® Single Sheets,Rolled Vinyl Cricut Maker® 5L1oFF &Iron-On 9.Copies rim Didnbama(sae,rwrac5'PnsrowWisbers sea(page,l3A ' 398 406 Siuix°Momenta' Rubber Stamps &Packs ed Brushes,Artist Pads& Super Value Pack Canvas 8x10-10 pack Does not indude machines, Single8 EasyPress.and BdghtPad*" &Spellbinders° and Ink Pads $329 Sketch Books,Art Canvas&Panels,Tube&Jar Paints, ALWAYS *Marked price$19.99 11x14-7 pack h.Tidal(Sum of 4261 5222 Die Cutting Products Includes Clear,Cling Mediums and Art Tables&Easels 1//� Q Q per 12x12-7 pack nI PaM Tim Holtz'Products Does not indude machines and Sets Does not include"Your Price"items `.V V Pack 16x20-5 pack (ie,diedelby,Sltime3100) It 82% 79% "If you ere deimilg Medronic copies.go to line than page 3.If you are rim Griming electronic copra,aklpmline t7 an page 3. JEWELRY MAKING 500 --WRS FABRIC S; CORD Categories Listed ,e.EledronlccovvclmplallPn g Categories Listed Strung,Tubed& Explorer by Traditions14 Scissors&Rotar Cutters Ribbon,Trim&Tulle Spools PreQ^ee'�"ant"° xa°rea,,or'e m " Packaged Beads Pendants,beads and filigrees y P A' by Color Gallery"Bead Treasures®and inspired by world travels _ Fiskars®and Singer® Does not include tulle e.veld Electronic Copes ' 2216 3482 Czech Glass Beads Bead Stringing ° sold bySeasonal theDeyardartorment'u'_ Ob.Total PaidPrintCopies(LineI5c)+PalaElectronicCopies(ht...) 3821 7277 Includes Beads,Flatback and by On-A-Cord',On-A-string"&On-A-wire- Sewol0 ®SewingNotions5 )3f p 50 O/ Hotfix Crystals by Preciosa® c Total Pent oldabueon(Una,6n.Pale Electronic Copies(Una lea) 5323 e29e Vintaj° OFF Home Decor& OFF Bead Design Co.T" Unique artisan components made in I ' a.PermPamiaMh Pdmaaeetr«,m 000ieau+6b ai"mea 001,00fool 72% 88% - Bulk beads&gems in a variety of materials the USA Home Decor Pillow Covers Apparel Trim By the Yard o;aedi6 hates%Wallmdiatritrmea°Pi,,(el,,lreeiaandedm,arePaida�ean°m;nalrace. CUST0M FRAMES 501 FURNITURE n.Ppbnmtmn W5lcue tit Woanerehm Always 5o%off the marked price" 1E10Applies to frame only.See store for details. ALWAYS 9 i,uc WMicaeon is a general pu9lra1Ion,publiralion mlhis sMmmenl in required.WII be Dnnmtl Publralun not requires. ,n,„°October 13,2021 ap°m„apse Compare our prices to our 3O% 19.Signelu,eendTillsorEdimr.Publisher.Business Manager.orOwner Dam competitors'prices. '� Kim Stephens Circulation Director October 1,2021 FREE QUOTES 1Fr 1 1- - (— OFF — ,e,00 tlwtell inro,meuon famished on this rorm kbue end wmpmm.luMersleM min anyone wtrommishea false or misleading infwmeuon on this mrm See our Great Selection. THE MARKED PRICE` - pocua',ec pe al 000 rmabanre00eamapnmemin,may be cobiedw Pdminal ce,oens l,aodi,g sties aria,epieonmem)anwpr aoil aanwpna Satisfaction Guaranteed. ` *Discounts provided every day;marked prices reflect general U.S.market value for similar products.No coupons or other discounts may be applied to"Your Price"items. , Exhibit 11 Opinion Pam diaGplin Meroup A6 • Wednesday, October 20, 2021 /Thursday, October 21, 2021 Voteyes to reaffirm commitment to Lake Oswego schools is very difficult to cess to drastically over would be made across the district. At$0.92 per$1,000 of assessed val vulnerable world,one might argue build a consensus OUR haul the Lake Oswego LOSD's playgrounds are outdated ue,the bond would add about$385 that schools have never been more these days. U ��II ''11N School District's aging fa- on a primary level,and the bond will per year to the tax bill of a home as- important.Today's students will lead We've seen that to UY1111VN cilities.Voters will recall add new equipment that can be used sessed at Lake Oswego's median val- the way as Lake Oswego and the cally during this election that the first$187 million by a larger group of people.The bond ue of$420,000.Between the 2017 world at large grapple with issues cycle,as the city and a bond passed with 59%of will also fix less noticeable barriers school bond and the 2019 Lake Oswe- like climate change,social justice group of preservation-minded activ- the vote in 2017,and as a result the like cracks in sidewalks and hard- go parks bond(which was also ap- and inequality.More than a year of ists battle with competing measures district boasts a brand-new Lak- ware on doors.Multiple studies show proved),we suspect there may be distance learning since the pandemic over how to protect our parks(we'll eridge Middle School along with ma- that inclusion and accessible schools bond-related fatigue from some vot- began also underscored the impor- weigh in on that debate next week). ny other capital improvements at are beneficial for all students—not ers.However,this is not the time for tance of schools as physical founda- At times it feels as if we argue for the schools that address safety,technol- just those with disabilities.More in- the community to pull the plug on its tions of growth and opportunity. sake of arguing,rather than to arrive ogy and other elements. elusive schools are linked to im- support for schools,and we urge vot- As Courtney Clements,the leading at some sort of collaborative solu- If approved,Measure 3-577 would proved mental health,social lives ers to think of this bond as a reaffir- parent advocate for the 2021 bond, tion. usher in similar improvements.This and grades. mation of the commitment made to put it:"To progress as a society,the It is our hope that this trend will time,rebuilds would take place at The bond also emphasizes im- students and faculty in 2017.It most important investment we can not apply to Measure 3-577—the Lake Oswego Junior High and River proved accessibility at all district fa- should also be noted that the district make is in education." Lake Oswego school bond. Grove Elementary,while science,en- cilities and other capital repairs like has a track record of responsible We agree.Vote yes on Measure This$180 million general obliga- gineering and computer labs at both enhanced HVAC systems,upgraded stewardship;projects from the 2017 3-577. tion bond is the second of what's en- high schools would be renovated and kitchens and a new roof at Lake Os- bond are on schedule and on budget. visioned as a three-part funding pro- additional safety improvements wego High School. In this ever-changing,increasingly —Review Editorial Board READERS'LETTERS CifiT , LOHS Green Team an extraordinary group of parents and S supports school bond teachers,but the building is dilapidated Vote es on Measure 3 575 and in disrepair.Kindergartners have _ As members of the Lake Oswego High been in portables for most of a decade. School Green Team,our main emphasis is The library is tiny.This bond will replace to promote sustainability and environ- River Grove and Lake Oswego Junior mental consciousness in both the high High. s members of the Lake Oswego ing broader community feedback.Here school and broader community through I would encourage anyone undecided City Council we urge you to vote MYVIEW are the results: education,hands-on events,and activism. about the LO Schools Bond to compare YES on Measure 3-575,the Natu- -Measure 3-575 protects the entirety of We support the 2021 Lake Oswego River Grove and LOJ with the new Lak- ral Area Preservation Charter Lake Oswego our natural parks plus the natural areas of Schools Bond because it will allow new eridge Middle School campus.Lakeridge Referendum.We were each elected individ- City Council active use parks against incongruent uses ways for students to become involved in Middle is an incredible facility paid for ually and represent the myriad of different such as public roads and communications the environment through a wide array of with the last school bond passed in 2017. perspectives illustrative of our city and do towers. improvements that support both sustain- It provides students and teachers the not always see eye to eye.But we can all -It allows for the community to decide if ability and learning.For example,this space they need to thrive.It boosts home gratefully agree that a primary value we hold true is amenities such as hard surface trails and parking bond can pay for new sidewalks that will values.It demonstrates,for all to see,our a sincere care for our natural areas and parks,mani- lots are appropriate for a given natural park. encourage students to walk or bike safely common commitment to education and fested through many decades of community invest- -It allows for equitable access to nature for people rather than driving,helping cement active student success.Vote your values.Vote ment and stewardship. of different ages and abilities.Access to nature is habits at a young age.It will also promote your pocketbook.Vote yes for the LO Natural parks are a defming point of pride for one of the primary reasons we preserve natural ar- landscaping with native plants,which Schools Bond. Lake Oswego,enriching the environment and our eas within our urban environment. supports clean water,clean air and wild- Taylor Murdoch quality of life,and we know future generations want -It allows us to maintain natural areas in re- life habitat.The bond will help pay for im- Lake Oswego to ensure these community assets are not only pre- sponse to wildfire risks exacerbated by climate provements to school buildings that will served but cared for to engender an even healthier change. lead to lower energy usage,which is bet- resource for the Oswegans yet to come. Most importantly,Measure 3-575 builds on the ter for our climate and our future. Please vote YES For the first time in our city,there are two mea- collaborative,active way our community has man- This school bond reflects our communi- for the school bond sures competing with one another on the ballot.The aged and invested in natural areas for decades.If ty's desire to live more sustainably.It bal- measure with the most"yes"votes prevails. we've learned anything this past year it is that con- ances environment,equity and economics Next month we LO residents can dem- Measure 3-575 came about in response to con- ditions can change rapidly,requiring dynamic,sci- as a means of creating a more just,resil- onstrate our community's support for our cerns regarding the competing measure(#3-568) ence-based management of our natural areas now ient and beautiful community for all. children by voting YES on the school from residents deeply involved in parks steward- and in the future. Please vote yes on the 2021 school bond. bond,Measure 3-577.The bond will re- ship including the members of our Parks&Natural We recognize that there are well-intentioned com- Lake Oswego High School Green Team build LO Jr.High and River Grove Ele- Resource Advisory Board and the leaders of neigh- munity members advocating for both measures and members mentary Schools thereby eliminating por- borhood park volunteer groups such as Friends of we applaud all their efforts.Undoubtedly we can all Lake Oswego table classrooms,relieving overcrowded Hallinan Woods,Springbrook Park,Iron Mountain be grateful for the fact that in Lake Oswego we de- classrooms and common areas and imme- Park,Luscher Farm,Southwood Park and Wood- bate how to best care for natural areas,not whether Citizens tahin initiative diately provide a safer environment for mont Park. or not we should.That said we're honored to have g our students in case of a seismic event. The concerns centered around the fact that 3-568 been entrusted by your votes to guide our communi- Springbrook Park,Canal Acres,Bryant The bond will modernize classrooms to did not contemplate the need to prepare for climate ty's future.Please join us along with trusted parks Woods,Cooks Butte,and Stevens Mead- support new and expanded STEM and Ca- change and take preventative measures in response advocates and advisors in casting a YES vote for ows are examples of natural habitats reer Technical Education programs and to wildfire dangers,it did not protect all of our natu- Measure 3-575 and give a NO vote to Measure 3-568. within our neighborhoods resulting from replace computers throughout the dis- ral areas,and it created barriers to access to nature Learn more at www.lakeoswego.city grantors'foresight to convey development trict.It will enable needed capital repairs for members of our community with mobility chal- restrictions and/or decades of citizens' to be made and ensure safer,more secure lenges among other concerns. The Lake Oswego City Council is made up of Mayor Joe painstaking activism pushing back City campuses throughout the district. In response to this input we worked with resi- Buck,Council President Daniel Nguyen,Councilor Jackie development.Could you imagine our Two of my grandchildren attended LO dents and parks experts to craft Measure 3-575 and Manz,Councilor Massene Mboup,Councilor Aaron Rapf, beautiful City without these natural sane- schools even though they lived outside then conducted a public engagement process solicit- Councilor Rachel Verdick and Councilor John Wendland. tuaries and abundant wildlife? the district because their parents wanted For decades,the City has failed to adopt them to have the high-quality education strong protections;therefore,citizens they could receive here.Let's keep that have taken the initiative.Over the last 24 high quality going forward and give all On Sch o o l board• ♦ O�e yes cation we canprovide them.Please joina $64,000(!)from friends and neighbors to: ing the school bond by voting YES on •craft a Charter amendment with pre- Measure 3-577. �' O O d cise,deliberate and intentional develop- Esther Schwartz e�J�` phase ment limitations to protect 16 natural Lake Oswego parks •inform our community going door-to Clt should door(pre-Covid),sending 40,000+mail- ommUnY y now,Lake Oswego voters have VIEW hands-on STEM and career education- ings to—15,250 households(-30,000 vot- invest in education received their ballots for the No- MY 1' IEW focused classrooms across the district. ers),and through our website,email,and vember election in the mail and And for two schools where replacement is social media One thing is clear from the"year that have the opportunity to vote on Lake Oswego more cost-efficient than repair,the bond •collect 4,800+voter signatures to wasn't":Our students desperately need Measure 3-577,the Lake Oswego school School Board will allow the district to rebuild Lake Os- qualify Measure 3-568 our brick-and-mortar schools.We learned bond.We,the members of your school wego Junior High and River Grove Ele- •obtain prominent environment and that students need in-person learning en- board,ask you to join us in voting yes. mentary to the level of educational excel- conservation organization endorsements vironments,which are shaped by our This is the second bond in a planned lence our students need to succeed in their Citizen initiatives aren't easy.They re- school buildings and classrooms. three-phase bond program that is a critical part of lives and careers. quire tremendous patience,persistence, This November,we have an opportuni- the Lake Oswego School District's long term plan- In Lake Oswego,our students are so fortunate to and perseverance—then,add a global ty to invest in this future by voting YES ning.In 2017,Lake Oswego voters overwhelmingly have the strong support of our citizens:parents, pandemic,wildfires and ice storms.None- on the LO School Bond Measure 3-577, approved the first bond,which revitalized every as- grandparents,neighbors,business owners,teachers, theless,we forged ahead ensuring our which advances a thoughtful and conser- pect of our school district's facilities.Hundreds of and caregivers who care about our students'future community could choose to enact proven, vative approach to needed maintenance miles of fiberoptic cables were pulled through newly because they know strong schools mean a strong sensible legal safeguards protecting these and repairs in our School District.It is seismically upgraded walls at every school;new and vibrant community for everyone,not just the natural treasures.Our only gain,the en- phase two in a three-part plan. learning spaces for STEM and career education students who experience the schools every day. joyment they provide our families and The first phase,a bond passed in May were created;a rehabilitated Oak Creek Elementary Many of you were able to tour our upgraded facili- community. 2017,was well managed with public over- School was opened;and a state-of-the-art Lakeridge ties during the summer;if you missed out on a tour Measure 3-568—the ONLY citizen-led sight.Projects were completed on time Middle School was constructed to meet the educa- of the new Lakeridge Middle School,there is a link natural park initiative on the ballot— and under budget.The centerpiece was a tional needs of young teens—many of whom,in- to a virtual tour on the district website:https://www. vote YES! new Lakeridge Middle School.The second credibly enough,may lead our city into the 22nd cen- losdschools.org,as well as a link to a list of all the Scott Handley phase,Measure 3-577,will rebuild Lake tury. projects the new bond will get done.Finally,we in- Lake Oswego Oswego Junior High and River Grove Ele- The remainder of the projects that are part of that vite you to visit BuildingGreatLOSchools.com to mentary. bond will wrap up in a matter of weeks—on time, learn more about the bond and the community lead- School buildingsOur students deserve innovative,inten and well within budget,thanks to the leadership of ers who strongly support its passage. tional learning spaces with their peers, our citizen-led bond accountability committee. Please remember to return your ballot before 8 need investment not over-crowded classrooms in rundown This 2021 school bond continues our bond cycle p.m.on Nov.2,and please vote YES on the school buildings that were built in the 50s and and will execute on the district's long-term plans to bond,Measure 3-577.Help Lake Oswego keep its One thing that the last eighteen months 60s.Students deserve updated security keep our schools safe,modern,and exceptional. well-deserved reputation for educational excel- has taught our family is that our commu- and capital improvements that will make Funds from the bond will replace portables with lence and our buildings on track for repairs and nity's school buildings matter—a lot. our schools more habitable,sustainable, modern,permanent classrooms.The bond adds Ca- updates.There are remarkable students in our dis- While most of us adults have adapted to a and energy efficient. pacity to overcrowded classrooms and common trict with dreams of becoming outstanding citi- remote environment,most children need Education for our youth is a valuable spaces where needed.It invests in energy-efficient zens.Let's do our part to help them realize those to learn in person,and they need space community investment,so whether you heating and cooling systems,with improved air cir- dreams. designed to help them succeed.I am sup- have a student in the district or not, culation systems that improve air quality,whether porting the 2021 LO School Bonds because please join me.Vote'YES'for LO School impacted by smoke from forest fires or the spread of The Lake Oswego School Board is made up of Chair Kirst- that success is on the line. Bond Measure 3-577. airborne viruses. en Aird,Vice Chair Neelam Gupta,Board Member Brian Three of my children have attended Elizabeth Welsh Bond proceeds will pay for technology upgrades, Bills,Board Member Liz Hartman and Board Member River Grove Elementary.River Grove has Lake Oswego including new computers and AV system,and funds John Wallin. ClackamasReview OregonCityNews IPamplin MediaGroup LakeOswego Review Wilsonville Spokesman WestLinnTidings CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING — Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 vine Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-.Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 12 Opinion Pam diaGplin Meroup A5 • Wednesday, October 21, 2021 /Thursday, October 28, 2021 is ar measure e a e ma tt er oftrus Publisher's note:Mistakes hap- I t is telling,and en- Butte as a potential ea,Hallinan Woods,Iron Mountain "friends"groups and many longtime pen.Unfortunately,when we make a , couraging,that OUROPINION site for the tower,but Park,Kerr Open Space,Lamont volunteers,have rallied around the mistake,it's not something that we i Lake Oswego resi- some concerned resi- Springs Natural Area,River Run, city's measure. can easily hide,or that we should. dents have spent dents felt their work Southshore Natural Area,Springbrook Ultimately,this is a matter of trust As your local newspaper,we ' the past several months debating wasn't done and began working on Park,Stevens Meadows,Waluga Park- and process.It is laudable that many strive to be fair and balanced in ev- ; how best to protect the city's beloved what became Measure 3-568. West and Woodmont Nature Park. residents care so deeply about main- erything we do.So,when we make a I parks and natural areas. By July of this year,the group of Both ballot measures also place new taming the city's natural environment, mistake,especially one on a politi- i This underscores a central truth: residents—organized under the name development restrictions on these ar- even if they disagree about the best cal ad,it is important that we ac- that long before climate change roared LoveLOParks—had garnered 4,433 eas.The city's measure prohibits"con- way to do so.LoveLOParks advocates knowledge the error even though , into our collective consciousness,envi- signatures(more than the 4,300 need- struction of new athletic facilities, have expressed a sense of distrust to- many of our readers may have not ronmental preservation has been a ed to qualify)on an initiative petition commercial logging,construction of ward the city—based,they say,on be- even been aware. core value for a city that boasts more to place the measure on the ballot.Ex- new public streets and roads,and con- trayals both recent and historic—and This was our situation last week, than 600 acres of parks and natural pressing concerns about the limita- struction of new telecommunication they believe more power should be when due to the complexities of how , spaces. tions of the measure and claiming that facilities."The LoveLOParks measure, vested in the voters when it comes to we print the Review newspaper we Yet the recent debate over how this LoveLOParks had not cooperated with meanwhile,bars"any athletic facility, future park projects.The city and its mistakenly ran the West Linn Tidings should be accomplished at city proper- city representatives and volunteers any telecommunications facility,or allies counter that LoveLOParks'more page A7 in the Lake Oswego Review. ties has been fierce and,more than who proposed alterations to the mea- any parking lot,road,or trail for mo- restrictive language—and the re- The correct page should have been , anything,confusing.For what some sure,the City Council responded by torized vehicles within a nature pre- quirement of voter approval for cer- alf page ad from believe to be the first time in Lake Os- placing its own initiative on the ballot. serve"as well as the cutting of any taro projects to move forward—would published with ah the Lake Oswego half group L wego's history,voters on Nov.2 will Both measures would repeal and re- tree for these purposes.Further,the waste time and money while potential- consider competing ballot measures— place the original chapter 10 of the city LoveLOParks measure states that the ly halting needed improvements in ac- OParks.Because their ad was about ' 3-568 and 3-575—on the same topic of charter,which was created in 1978 to city can't construct"any facility or any cessibility,wildfire prevention and the current Lake Oswego Measure : natural area preservation.Whichever preserve Springbrook Park(it could structure above ground that would im- other areas. 3-568,most people would understand i measure garners more"yes"votes will also apply to other areas,but only with pair or be inconsistent with the natu- Each side has accused the other of their frustration that such a mistake I be put in place,affecting a slew of voter approval).Specifically,the char- ral conditions of a nature preserve." refusing to collaborate,and it is disap- would have happened.At the time,we I changes to the city charter in the pro- ter language stated that an athletic fa- Crucially,the LoveLOParks mea- pointing that an area of common inter- did our best to correct this issue by re- cess. cility,parking lot,road or trail for mo- sure also states that projects outside of est in Lake Oswego has become so di- sending out almost 4,000 copies of the The backstory:In 2019 a group of torized vehicles could not be devel- these limitations would need to be ap- visive.However this vote plays out, digital Lake Oswego Review to all our i residents led by Scott Handley pushed oped at Springbrook or any other proved by voters in a May or Novem- we hope activists on both sides can digital subscribers last Thursday. I back against a communications tower parks covered by that chapter. ber election. learn to work together in plotting a This week we had planned to offer at Cooks Butte Park that was proposed With either of the ballot measures Beyond the 4,433 residents who course for the future of our beautiful our endorsement in the debate over , by the city of Lake Oswego and the in place,the new charter would be signed the petition,the LoveLOParks parks. the two park measures,but due to this i Clackamas 800 Radio Group to im- more expansive in naming parks and measure is supported by the environ- Lake Oswego needs all of its resi- mistake we will instead share the de- I prove emergency services in a sector natural areas such as Bryant Woods mental groups Oregon Wild and Sierra dents to support natural preservation. tails of this measure and allow our of the city.Ultimately the city and Park,Canal Acres,Cooks Butte,Glen- Club.The Lake Oswego Sustainability That much we can all agree on. readers to decide: , C800 opted to move away from Cooks morrie Greenway,Cornell Natural Ar- Network,as well as most park —Review editorial board L TtI_11 Parks. Vote READERS'LETTERS Upon further review,I realized this novation and restoration in order for our text was sent to deliberately spawn con- parks and natural areas to thrive into the fusion.I believe in transparency.I believe future. o nCitizens/ � � � all LO citizens should have a voice if our We are strongly committed to using Don t let politicians natural park lands are to be developed. the well-established process involving yes exploit parks, But Measure 3-575 was NOT a citizen-led citizen stakeholders during planning. initiative.Only Measure 3-568 is the re- Measure 3-575 requires that any changes Measure 3-568 natural areas sult of a lengthy citizen petition effort. to a future master plan for parks be ap- We,as voters,deserve to be provided proved by citizens.This process will pro- As a 28 year resident of Lake Oswego, with factual information to make the best vide better outcomes than having a city- please don't be confused.Don't let the choices for our public parks. wide election to change the city charter Lake Oswego politicians exploit our natu- Only Measure 3-368 is endorsed by for each problem that does not fit into to- 0n behalf of every vol- fail to recognize the signifi ral parks. both the Sierra Club and Oregon Wild, days proposed box. unteer,donor,and cance of our accomplishment to We need to protect and preserve these and is the only one of these two disparate LOSN urges you to vote yes on Ballot 4,800+petition sign qualify for the ballot. natural areas from development.Of the initiatives that empowers voters to de Measure 3-575 and to vote no on 3-568. ers,the LoveLOParks Instead,city politicians two competing ballot measures,only the cide any future development in our pub Dorothy Atwood Steering Commit- chose to forward a citizens'initiated Measure 3-568 will pro- lic natural parks.Measure 3-575's misin- Lake Oswego tee hopes you'll rushed,disingenu- vide our natural parks with the strong le- formation campaign is disrespectful to join us and vote MYVIEW ous and flawed gal protections needed.City Council's our community and all who worked hard �Nh we buy local YES on citizen-ini- LoveLOParks competing mea- referendum 3-575 opens the door for ever bringing Measure 3-568 to voters.The Y Y tiated Measure sure giving wide more commercial exploitation and devel- truth does and should matter.YES on Frequently we say"buy local"and I be- 3-568—the only Steering Committee latitude through opment. 3-568. lieve many citizens do just that.We have natural parks mea- city ordinances to For a detailed comparison of these two Nancy Fleming purchased floral arrangements and gifts sure on the ballot with careful- change park boundaries and to ballot measures,please go to-https:// Lake Oswego from Lake Oswego's R.BLOOM for years. ly vetted and unbiased en- develop them in the future, loveloparks.org/compare However,this latest just reminded me dorsements from Oregon Wild while running a campaign cen- Then,join me and vote YES on 3-568 Not confused on measures WHY we continue to utilize R.Bloom's and Sierra Club. tered on misinformation. and NO on 3-575. for floral arrangements!I smile every Measure 3-568 started from a They have even omitted Sec- Michael Louaillier My Voters'Pamphlet and ballot ar- time I walk by our Halloween arrange- genuine concern to protect our tion 46A that restricts struc- Lake Oswego rived today.I found it surprising the ment. natural parks from city devel- ture heights over 50 feet in resi- stark contrast between the quality in the Carolyn Arnston opment ambitions. dential zones!City politicians explanatory statements,arguments,and Lake Oswego Time t0 Ste It wasn't one episode,two,or fear losing the option to devel- p up for schools endorsements between the two LO natu- even three;it has been decades op these natural habitats. We are fortunate to have many won- ral park measures. Voting yes on 3-575 in of city exploitation,attempted Why did a major developer derful young people actively participat- The Citizens'Measure 3-568 explanato- g development,and an appetite contribute$10,000 to their ing in our community.Many families ry statement is concise and focused on support of natural areas to demolish land at the expense PAC?Why did two high-end come here because of our great schools. protections limiting development;the ar- of our natural environment. realtors donate$3,000?What is As a member of this community,I care guments come from citizens with history For the past five years I have worked Measure 3-568 is the only expected in return? about the schools even though I don't about past City exploits and a genuine with the Coalition for Hallinan Woods measure that precisely defines Our efforts have been rooted have a child attending them.Through my passion to protect nature. Nature Park to advocate for the expan- in the City Charter 16 natural in transparency and integrity work with the Lake Oswego Sustainabili- Measure 3-568 is the only measure on sion of Hallinan Woods. parks,their boundaries and with a focus on communication, ty Network and the Oswego Lake Water- the ballot endorsed by leading Oregon During this time,I have had the honor acreage. collaboration,data,and facts. shed Council,I am fortunate to interact environment and conservation organiza- to get to know and work with community The charter can only be al- We attempted to collaborate directly with amazing students from the tions:Oregon Wild and Sierra Club—or- leaders and organizations that have dedi- tered by voters—the ultimate with City politicians to no avail High School Green Teams. ganizations removed from our local poli- cated years to the stewardship of Lake citizen involvement;whereas, even as they repaint history by Their contributions in making the tics. Oswego's natural spaces.I am proud to city ordinances can be altered saying otherwise. schools and our community more sus- City Council's Measure 3-575 explana- join with these local leaders and stew- by any current or future City We have no vested interest tamable and dynamic are inspirational. tory statement,on the other hand,is ards to recommend that you vote YES on Council at any time.This legal except protecting our natural The school bond that is on the Novem- vague and confusing and doesn't tell me 3-575 and no on 3-568. safeguard has protected parks for our community's con- ber ballot will provide funds for replacing much about what and how it plans to pro- Meaure 3-575 is endorsed by the Oswe- Springbrook Park for 40+ tinned enjoyment of their for- Lake Oswego Junior High and River tect natural parks.In fact,it doesn't even go Lake Watershed Council,the Friends years. ests,meadows,and abundant Grove Elementary with buildings meet- guarantee the"natural areas"that are of Hallinan Heights Woods,the Friends Measure 3-568 is the only wildlife and preserving our ing immediate occupancy seismic stan- protected until after we vote—what's of Springbrook Park,the Friends of Iron measure that deliberately fo- way of life. dards.These buildings along with the this about? Mountain Park and the Friends of Wood- cuses on sensible development Over the last 24 months, other school buildings constructed in the Would you buy a home only to fmd the mont Park.These are our neighbors who limitations to keep our natural we've mailed Measure 3-568's past couple of years are a core part of our kitchen wasn't included?And,one can't volunteer their time to remove invasives parks safe,accessible,healthy, Charter text to—90%of voting community's disaster preparedness as help notice this measure's arguments are and trash from our city's natural spaces, and vibrant natural habitats. households.The City's Charter they can be quickly converted into emer- all from politicians,many involved in who coordinate native plantings with city ADA compliance,park and text has not been widely avail- gency community shelters. past exploits,and City-affiliated groups; staff,and who passionately believe in infrastructure maintenance— able.As such,we've provided We benefit from both the terrific kids they're attempting to confuse voters.I'm preserving our natural spaces.3-575 also including fire prevention,eco- both texts to voters to help and from school campuses that are es- not confused. has the endorsement of the Lake Oswego logical care,climate change them make an informed deci- sential components for our community. I'm with citizens who worked diligent- Sustainability Network,an organization mitigation,and stewardship sion. Now is the time for the community to ly bringing us Measure 3-568 to protect that is a constant advocate in our com- will continue as it has for Voters should read both full step up and support the schools that nur- nature from development. munity for local action on climate mitiga- Springbrook Park. texts and not rely solely on the ture the students passing through our It's YES on Measure 3-568 and NO on tion and adaptation. Measure 3-568 is the only limited information within the schools by voting for the 2021 LO School 3-575! It's unsurprising that these local orga- measure that intentionally ex- Voters'Pamphlet Bond. Kirsty Reilly nizations support 3-575—3-575 offers ad- pands and enhances Spring- We hope we've earned your Mary Ratcliff Lake Oswego ditional protections to our natural areas brook Park's proven,strong support for Measure 3-568.If Lake Oswego while allowing the city to prepare for cli- and legally-binding Charter you've already voted,you can mate change.The competing measure, text providing transparency still help inform and encourage LOSN backs Measure 3-575 3-568,does not protect all of our natural and clarity to the improved your friends and neighbors: Voters deserve the facts I'm a founding board member of the parks,restricts the city's ability to pre- protections and additional Vote YES on Measure 3-568 Did you receiving a text on behalf of Lake Oswego Sustainability Network pare for climate change and wildfire parks. and NO on Measure 3-575. Measure 3-575 this week asking to sup- (LOSN).LOSN supports the Friends of risks,and restricts options for access to Our opponents want you to Learn more about both mea- port a citizen-guided initiative to pre- LO Parks M3-575.We believe it provides our natural parks. believe our intentions have sures at loveloparks.org/com- serve our parks? the best way to protect our natural areas. For Hallinan Woods,the passage of the been nefarious,misguided and pare. I experienced a moment of doubt.Of Our world is an interconnected system competing measure,3-568,would mean lacking collaboration.They course I believe that the protection of our that is dynamic in response to changing that options for a trail at the new Yates want you to believe that The LoveLOParks grassroots effort vulnerable park lands should be decided conditions.Locking in today's approach Street entrance would be restricted.A 4,800-plus petition signers and is made up of hundreds of Lake Os- upon by LO citizens.Our natural parks to manage our natural areas in the city hard-surface trail—the best option for a hundreds of volunteers are a wego residents guided by a steering provide much needed respite to so many charter is not the best protection from trail through a wet woodland area that "vocal minority."They refuse committee:Scott&Joey Handley, of us,yet they remain in jeopardy of fu- the challenges that we face—especially sees year-round use by children walking to accept Oregon's democratic Betsy Wosko,Michael Louaillier, ture development without stronger pro- climate change and biodiversity loss. to school—would be forbidden. citizen initiative process and Kirsten Sommer and Brad Home. tections. These existential issues will require in- See LETTERS/Page A6 ClackamasReview OregonCityNiews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn fiding5 CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING - Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. A6 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News • West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman Wednesday,October 27,2021/Thursday,October 28,2021 • Pamplin Media Group Letters another school bond measure ers who have endorsed 3-575 only because efforts were LO grad supports but in the end,after all the adding the additional cost to would let them be developed or made to preserve. 2021 schools bond smoke clears and you come up our tax bill.We personally need compromised in any way.It is The most"conservative"ac- out of the weeds,you need to to prioritize our needs and also absurd to think that the tion toward our natural places Growing up in Oswego,I was look around and ask yourselves • From Page A5 wants.It is not unacceptable to city would let them be devel- is to do nothing...to leave it fortunate to be able to attend why both the Sierra Club and expect our schools to do the oped or compromised since and allow just a bit of wild to Lake Grove Elementary School, Oregon Wild endorsed the citi- For the sake of our natural same and continue with what these lands were purchased or remain. LO Junior High and LO High.I zen sponsored measure and not areas,I am voting YES on 3-575 they have for the time being. acquired expressly for their By now you have your bal- received a great education that the city's.Or to put it another and no on 3-568. We passed the$187 million natural resource values. lots,please give the wild plac- has benefited me and my family way,why did one of the area's Sarah Ellison bond measure in 2017 to pro- Don't be fooled by scare tac- es protection,and vote YES on ever since. biggest developers,Renais- Lake Oswego vide the schools what they tics that are being employed for Measure 3-568;vote NO on I strongly support the pro- sance Homes—someone you need. a cynical political advantage. Measure 3-575. posed 2021 Schools Bond to en- wouldn't want to be around if Rightprocess — YES Ridge Taylor Our natural resource groups Developer money is behind sure our community continues you were a tree,contribute gLake Oswego and our citizens are fierce de- the city's Measure 3-575;volun- to have safe,modern and ex- $10,000 to the city's campaign, on Measure 3-575 fenders of our natural areas, teers and a grassroot effort by ceptional schools for our stu- but not a single penny to help All parks should with a deep appreciation for neighbors initiated Measure dents today and into the future. get the citizen measure on the Lake Oswego citizens,most them.We will not let them be 3 568...Preservation and pro- The bond will enable us to ballot?" being nature lovers,are urged be protected exploited for commercial gain. tection can offer so many bene- provide safe buildings con- When you think about it that to vote YES on ballot Measure Vote Yes on 3-575. fits to our quality of life.Pass- structed to earthquake stan- way you start wondering if a 3-575 and NO on Measure 3-568. I love Lake Oswego,the peo- Dan Anderson ing Ballot Measure 3-568 is a dards with new HVAC systems vote for the city's measure is As former chair of LO's ple and our natural areas.I love Lake Oswego gift to the future;a legacy for so important for the health of kind of like giving them the key Parks and Natural Resources that we care so much we have children,for trees,for animals our students,teachers and to the tool shed where all the Advisory Board,it's been grati- two initiatives on the ballot re- and for Lake Oswego. staff.It will allow us to offer chainsaws are locked up. fying to me to see that Measure garding the best way to love Join me in voting We can't do better with the modern,high-quality science, I'm not willing to give them 3-575 is the spot-on strategic re- our nature parks. yes on Measure land by developing parking,or engineering and computer labs the key.That's why I'm voting sult of strong cooperation be- I am concerned that Measure 3-575 ball fields,or playgrounds.Im- so that our kids can thrive in yes on Measure 3-568 and no on tween dedicated citizen leaders 3-568 only includes some nature provements mean desecration the 21st century. Measure 3-575. (including Friends of Parks areas and excludes others,for This November,LO voters of unique and all too rare plac- Our schools have always Pierre Zubrinsky members,Parks and Natural example the woods in Freepons have the opportunity to further es. been the backbone of our com- Lake Oswego Resources Advisory Board Park. protect our natural areas while YES on 3-568!Thank you. munity enabling us to attract members,Watershed Council Another concern I have is also keeping them accessible to Mark Chambers young families who support our S •n brook Park members and Sustainability that we are limiting the ability people with limited mobility. Lake Oswego local businesses,parks,and cul- r g Network members)and the of our Parks Department to ful- To do this,I encourage you tural institutions that help and BM 3-575 City(led by our Parks and Rec ly engage in their job.They are to vote YES on measure 3 575, Citycan be trusted make Lake Oswego a great Dept). professionals that are experts the city's measure.And vote place to live. Our community is being di- Measure 3-575 is the poster in maintaining our natural ar- NO on measure 3-568,a compet- with natural areas Please join me in voting YES vided by fanciful rhetoric dis- child of how the process should eas. ing measure. on this important school bond. paraging Ballot Measure 3-575, work.So,let's pass the Mea- As a member of the Friends Measure 3-568 is a well- As one considers the mea- Tom O'Connor including speculation that,if sure that was thoughtfully de- of Hallinan Heights Woods,I meaning measure from well- sures to alter the city charter, Lake Oswego 3-575 passed,Springbrook Park veloped the right way—YES see firsthand how much the meaning people.But it's too it appears the question is,who would lose its legal protection on 3-575. Parks Department cares for our strict and narrow minded be- do you trust with our natural Don't miss chance and be developed. Bill Gordon natural areas and supports us cause it will prohibit paved areas? That's nonsense. Lake Oswego in our efforts to maintain and trails in our natural areas.It's Side by side,both measures to protect parks Ballot Measure 3-575 prohib- manage them.I rely on their the equivalent of setting up are hard to distinguish.The its construction of athletic facil- Not the time for expertise.The work they have small wilderness areas in our messaging from the petition I am a research scientist with ities,commercial logging,con done to keep the balance in our city,making it nearly impossi- supporters is that you can't over 25 years of experience ex- struction of public streets and another school bond natural areas after last winter's ble for people with limited mo- trust the City and the only an- amining the many factors that roads,and installation of tele- extreme storms is a great ex- bility to enter our natural ar- swer is their citizen's initia- affect water quality. communication facilities in the As you know,there is anoth- ample. eas. tive. I enthusiastically support park. er Lake Oswego bond measure I am also concerned that Everyone deserves to experi- Lake Oswego has a history ballot measure 3-568 because it Unlike the competing mea- 3-577 for$180 million out to the 3-568 restricts too much.I want ence nature in our city.People of citizens working with the places sensible limits on the de- sure,3-575 requires the city: voters for the November 2nd to see ALL of our nature areas in wheelchairs,walkers,crutch- City and Parks Department to velopment of our natural parks to manage the park"to pre- special election.This measure protected.Measure 3-575 pro- es and more.And to do that,we preserve,protect and enhance while allowing important ex- serve and enhance the biologi- is projected to raise property tects all our natural areas and need to be able to have some natural areas.Paul Lyons, ceptions to maintain existing cal,hydrological,ecological and taxes$0.92/$1,000 of assessed works to keep them properly areas with safe,flat,paved Mike Buck,Nancy Gronkows- facilities,add new trails,re- environmental functions and value. maintained.I'm voting Yes for trails. ki,Heidi Schrimsher,Stepha- move invasive species and pre- promote a healthy ecosystem," Four short years ago,we ap- 3-575,and on No 3-568. Measure 3-575 is the solution. nie Wagner and scores of dedi- vent fires. and to manage the park"in a proved bond measure 3-515 for Christy Clark, It will protect natural areas and cated citizens have been work- Protections provided by Mea- way that protects their scenic $187 million that raised proper- Lead of the Friends of z prevent development,but allow ing within the current system sure 3-568 can only be removed and aesthetic qualities and pro- ty taxes$1.25/$1,000 of assessed Hallinan Heights Woods paved trails where they are and partnering with the City. by the voters while the protec- vides access to nature for the value. Lake Oswego sensible. Their voices and wisdom are tion provided by competing public,consistent with their en- Add that our property tax is So I urge you to vote YES on in Measure 3-575. Measure 3-575 is weaker and vironmental values and ecolog- up again from 2020 to 2021,just 3-575 and NO on 3-568—be- I appreciate that the Save can be completely negated by a ical function." as it does every year.And it's Don't develop — cause everyone in LO deserves Our Parks authors have elevat- simple majority vote of the city I've volunteered in Spring- worthy to note 42.96%of your Vote yes on 3-575 nature. ed the conversation about nat- council. brook Park for over 15 years, property tax dollar collected by Natalie Bennon ural area protection.They Measure 3-575 does not even spending hundreds of hours re- Clackamas County already There is a great deal of mis- Lake Oswego were asked to team-up with provide a map of the protected storing this beautiful natural goes to K-12 schools. information and willful mis- our storied group of preserva- areas until after we vote.So,it area. For the 12 months ending reading of ballot measure 3-575 Measure 3-5G8 is tionists but declined.They've is not surprising that the Ore- I've studied measure 3-575 September 2021,the U.S.Labor inferring that if it passes,it is now harnessed our political cli- gon Chapter of the Sierra Club and the competing measure. Department is reporting the an- open season on our natural ar- gift for the future mate of mistrust to signal that and Oregon Wild support Mea- Both are well-intentioned,but nual inflation rate of 5.4%.Last eas,that developers are going we can no longer trust the City. sure 3-568,while people in the 3-575 will give us a superior year it was 1.4%and hasn't to descend on them,and that "Don't it always seem to go Measure 3-575 is endorsed real estate business are some of framework for protecting and been over 3%the last decade developers helped write this ...You don't know what you've by Lake Oswego's Friends the major contributors to Mea- managing Springbrook Park (2011).Gasoline is up 42.1%,en- measure.None of this is true. got`till it's gone..." groups,the Lake Oswego Sus- sure 3-575. and,for the first time,17 other ergy up 24.8%,fuel oil up 42.8%, 3-575 was initiated and written The notion of"improve- tainability Network,the Oswe- Putting Measure 3-568 on the natural areas. used vehicles(cars and trucks) by local leaders in our natural ments"means"development", go Lake Watershed Council, ballot required a major effort Don't be fooled by the rheto- up 24.4%,food up 4.6%,clothing resource community in early and loosing forever the tiny current and former mayors and by many volunteers to gather ric.Vote YES on Ballot Mea- up 3.4%and transportation ser- 2020 in response to 3-568 to en- plots,the hidden places,the city councilors,and many over 4,000 signatures.This was sure 3-575. vices up 4.4%.And the Federal sure that our natural areas are realm of other creatures,to Neighborhood Associations. a monumental task so you may Doug McKean Reserve is most certainly going protected and available to all. short-sighted human requests. They understand who can be never get this chance again. Lake Oswego to raise interest rates. Developers were not remotely Cherished places,landscapes trusted. Please support Measure 3-568 Is education important to our involved. without the mark of contempo- I urge a Yes on 3-575. and oppose Measure 3-575 to Measure 3-568 future?Sure it is!But I do not It is absurd to think that the rary man can be known and Sandy Intraversato preserve the few natural spat think now is the time to pass many Friends groups and oth- appreciated in our community Lake Oswego es we have left for current and is too restrictive future generations to enjoy. Anthony Tesoriero Vote yes on Measure 3-575 Taking Care o f What's Lake Oswego and no on 3-5 3-568too re strictive. haveI lived here over Facts and the future 40 years,served on the Lake Grove Neighborhood Associa- M o st Important to You I--Nationwide I've had several interesting tion many years,been to many is on your side conversations with my young ivy pulls,worked hard to save Since 2004. granddaughter where we've our trees and support the envi talked about the upcoming elec- ronment. Lion and the two competing bal- In my experience I have AUTO HOME BUSINESS I LIFE lot measures regarding Lake found our City government to Oswego's natural parks. be supportive and willing to lis- _Ir +� Recently,after talking about ten to citizen input.I was the issues once again,she among the citizens involved t Jw� looked up at me and said, with designing Iron Mt Park in "Grandpa,it's really about the cooperation with Parks and planet you guys are leaving me, Rec.It is a beautiful park that Winston S. Ray, CLU and just what kind of future all would not exist under 3-568 A ' Ray Insurance Agency my friends and I are really go- Jerry Nierengarten V ing to have." Lake Oswego 8600 SW Salish Lane . > You could go round and Wilsonville OR 97070 round about the facts all day, See LETTERS/Page A7 (503) 682-3200 Products underwritten by Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company and Affiliated Companies.Home Winston@rayinsagency.com 04,v. FOJ, CITY COUNCIL AND Office:Columbus,OH 43215.Subject to underwriting guidelines,review,and approval.Availability tt varies. ide Nationwide,u Nationwide Is Onp Your Side,1Na the Nationwide -0 N and Eagle 16are1 service33 marks of '- REDEVELOPMENT Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company.©2019 Nationwide CPO-0836A0(08/16)10533208 www.rayinsagency,com �" G� U O �R,G0/ AGENCY MEETING HEADACHE#2461 THE CURE? WillTHE RIGHT PROFESSIONAL Tuesday, November 2, 2021— You are$2,00173„1„ o apart in YourTake two aspirin-and call ,.ih11 'i • 5:30 p.m. will budge.Come°Hour home Kevin Costello in the morning! 'iii_AilL • Council Chambers - 3rd Floor really want to busy Y The right professional at the right time C O S T E L L O back for$2,000. AT THE RIGHT TIME The Lake Oswego City Council and Redevelopment Agency will hold its next Picture . .4„.„,,,,- a• ' Remodeled to • regular meeting on Tuesday, November 2, Perfect so ; — , �� Perfection �° -� _ ti r '44:t ' 2021 at 5:30 p.m. The meeting will take 849,900 ''%, = i �. 1,600,000 This great Lake Oswego home boasts4Bedrooms _,f - Tastefully remodeled in 2010 and it holds , - '>; place in Council Chambers on the 3rd Floor 2.5 Baths and a main floor den.Hardwood floors up to 2021 standards.4 Bedrooms, ti of City Hall at 380 A Ave. on entire main level.Neil Kelly remodeled kitchen. 3 Baths,bonus room,den.Lake /' I IN•;A • Level lot.3 boat easements.So close to Lake easements.Great backyard with outdoor ,T„,- - - - v Grove shops.This house will not last! lik covered area with bar and fireplace Visit httpS://WWW.CI.OSWego.Or.US/meetings 16033 Reese Road 2600 Dellwood Drive to review the meeting agenda and packet RMLS 21086780 RMLS 21618664iiii materials. Just ..,-,.• G One Level! i'M The meetingcan be livestreamed on the Listed ��o�e Lake Haven! So\° '' $899,900 1 185 00o City's YouTube Channel and on the City's AH!Delightful Dellwood.Lovely 4 bedroom,2.5 baths,bonus website — www.ci.oswego.or.us. The traditional.4 Bedrooms upstairs,main room,2 car garage.RV/boat meeting will also be broadcast live on floor den.Full basement with bonus °u — — ' ''1 storage.12,000 sq ft level lot.2 -- room and workout room.2 Decks.2 great boat easements. IF Tualatin Valley Community TV; check their full and 2 half baths.Lake easement. - I I + L 17543 Lake Haven Dr h- website for details. 2915 Dellwood Drive "Y RMLS 21558221 RMLS Dellwood —_ -. For more information please contact Kari HASSON Email:costellok@hasson.com Linder at 503-534-4225 or CityRecorder@ COMPANY Kevin Costello • 503-534-1528 Web:kevincostello.hasson.com lakeoswego.city. 0 REALTORS® 12 Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,October 21,2021/Thursday,October 28,2021 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman Al arves season wines own West Linn vineyard owners excited ?_ ' - . -•: if:,,, tk. j 7 _.::"_____:,:_ : =„ir ' Ir vr„ about quality of grapes this year _ a =.. I 4 , v w * ` 9 By HOLLY BARTHOLOMEW erything easier,"Skinkis said. explained.Rain or hail can dam- 4-: ,•*„`*'. -:11, - I Pamplin Media Group Despite this summer's record- age the grape's stem, meaning ," • ,1. f '-,. ,� - ' ., setting heat, Thayer said this the fruit wont mature like usual - .4 ,0 : - •' , As harvest season comes to year's harvest was good, with "There were pockets of heavy ,, #41 ' ,: II r r . ,r :„ I an end for vineyards across the vineyard's pinot noir and rain that we had up on our vine- � Q�' . _� x� ,�, �, �, s+► the Willamette Valley,a trio chardonnay grapes producing yard.The damage didn't happen % ,- u_ F of West Linn wineries—Os- more fruit than most years. throughout the vineyard,but the - `"= y : � < 9":`1` —0 + 4 wego Hills,Campbell Lane Overall,Parks said yields for yields were impacted in differ ',y _ 1 '; -' -► ) Ci-4-c and Pete's Mountain Vine- Campbell Lane were slightly ent areas,"Parks said."A light r' . , � '' • y • Y Yregular rainfall didn't impact ' -,-.0 '"'`, '` 'U k, ' ". " : ' P and—reflected on this less than normal but noted it or p ` - year's harvest. wasn't due to the heat. the grapes,but certain areas got : .'' `r� ,� - ► 5 Both Andy Parks of Campbell Both Parks and Thayer said hit with what appeared to be , ._' ,� ' " `y ` F` Lane and Mike Thayer,owner of the extreme heat was early heavier doses of rain." Pete's Mountain Vineyard,not- enough in the season that it Around the same time rain COURTESY PHOTO:CAMPBELL LANE WINERY ed that this year's harvest came didn't impact the grapes. may have damaged vines at The crew at Campbell Lane winery put in a lot of work during harvest season,but noted it was well worth it. a little earlier than usual. "The real hot heat was well Campbell Lane,the cross-polli- By the start of October,Camp- before the grapes were of any nation of pinot gris grapes was the sites where they were erage. Like Parks and Thayer, higher than normal. bell Lane and Pete's Mountain size,so that didn't really impact disrupted at Pete's Mountain. grown.Like Thayer and Parks, he said the fruit did not seem to Though he couldn't say for Vineyard had already harvested them as far as we could see," "Usually pinot gris is the high- she also noted that rain during be affected by this summer's in- sure why those harvests were all or most of their grapes. Parks said."A few leaves were est yielding of the Oregon the bloom was an issue for vine- tense heat,though Marshall at- better this year, Thayer sug- "(The harvest season)is a lot sunburnt but the vast majority grapes we grow here,"Thayer yards across the valley. tributed that to the unique irri- gested it may be due to below of work but a lot of pleasure were in fine condition." said. In total, Campbell Lane gation system at Oswego Hills. average yields last year. comes out of it,so(it's)all worth Rather than the heat, Parks According to Thayer, the brought in slightly more than 85 At Pete's Mountain,the har- The vines only supported a it," Parks said. explained that the reason for vineyard brought in 3 tons of tons of grapes this year.Parks vest of pinot noir and chardon- small amount of fruit last year, Patty Skinkis, an Oregon Campbell Lane's below average grapes per acre of pinot gris said Campbell Lane would use nay was surprisingly good. so there was more stored energy State University professor of vi- yields was a spate of hard rain in vines,about 2 or 3 tons less than 14 tons for the winery's own Thayer said while the vineyard in the vines and root structures, ticulture,said the harvest came June. The vineyard brought in the yearly average.Thayer said products and sell the rest to oth- typically produces about 3 tons Thayer hypothesized. early for vineyards across the about 65% to 70% of its typical he's heard similar tales of low er winemakers. per acre of pinot noir grapes, Marshall was also pleased valley. harvest this year,he said. pinot gris yields from other Oswego Hills Winery owner this year yields were closer to with the quality of grapes har- "It was a very early harvest so Hard rain or hail when the winemakers in Oregon. Jerry Marshall said across the 3.5 tons per acre.The chardon- vested at Oswego Hills this year. a lot of it was done well before grapes come into bloom disrupts Skinkis said the strengths of vineyard,yields for grapes were nay harvest was equally robust, "The fruit has never been any the rain began,which makes ev- their natural pollination,Parks yields are largely dependent on about on par with the annual av- with yields about 15% to 20% better,"Marshall said. Letters ability as well as mobility challenges. much more than that—it's a power is- titions,verified signatures and finally Oswego in 1975 as a wilderness park. Hard surface trails are the best alter- sue.Look no further than the history placed Measure 3-568 on the Novem- In 1994 there was a Palisades neigh- native for the blind who are depen- of Cooks Butte Park. ber 2021 ballot. borhood meeting about a cellphone dent on a white cane for guidance. In 1975,the Emery Family granted What did City Council do?They tower being built in Cooks Butte. ■ From Page A7 These trails can be designed to allow the 42-acre Cook's Butte portion of rushed a competing Measure onto the When the company representative users to independently experience na- their property to the people of Lake ballot.Interestingly,their measure was told Mrs.Emery would be con- ture and identify interpretive informa- Oswego.The city received this grant does NOT limit the City's ability to tacted about this blatant violation of Watershed Council tion in braille.This sort of notification under the stipulation that it"be pre- place a communications tower on park her agreement,he responded she was supports 3-575 cannot be incorporated into a gravel served in as close to a natural state as property.If City Council can't be trust- dead.Not true,Marjorie Emery was r►' trail that may be accessible to people possible." ed to limit commercial activity in one very much alive and incensed by the Oswego Lake Watershed Council with mobility impairments. Three times—in 1993,2002,and natural park,how can we trust them City's action.I drove her to sign an af- endorses Measure 3-575.The Council Oswego Lake Watershed Council 2019,City Council violated the Emery with the rest? fidavit that further stated her previ- has worked with other natural areas encourages you to vote yes on Mea- Family wishes by approving large We believe that 26 years of broken ous intention for a wilderness park Friends groups for almost two years sure 3-575 and no on Measure 3-568. communications towers in Cook's promises is enough. Let's act with with no development. to counter the competing measure put Stephanie Wagner Butte Park.Three times the Emery honor and do what City Council won't The City was at it again in 2002 to forth by Scott Handley.From the be- Lake Oswego Family unanimously signed notarized do.Please vote NO on Measure 3-575. put a cell tower in Cooks Butte.And a ginning we were concerned about the documents expressing their firm oppo- Then join us in asking the City of Lake third time in 2019.Each time a group language in Measure 3-568 and how it ►s he Our OmiS6S sition.Three times there was loud Oswego to keep its promise.Please of concerned citizens have successful- could affect the long term protection public outcry from Lake Oswego citi- vote YES on Measure 3-568.Do it for ly fought back.The Emerys had of City natural spaces.As we face the As 32+year residents of Lake Os- zens.Three times over 26 years City yourself,your community and the hoped the City of Lake Oswego would challenges of climate change(particu- wego,it pains us to think that we can't Council backed down. next generation. be good guardians of the park they larly drought and wildfire)we need to trust Lake Oswego City Council. It begs the question:"What does it Mike and Debbie Wilkins created,but they have shown not to be able to make thoughtful plans.That Rather than work with the community take to protect our natural parks from Lake Oswego be. planning capability will be limited by they represent,City Council chose to each new version of City Council?" Please join those of us who have Measure 3-568, place a competing Parks Measure on It takes the hard work of a grass- What,would a do? fought the City for almost 30 years to We also need to guarantee all of our the November ballot that confuses and roots citizen initiative.So in 2019,Lake YY/ll� safeguard Cooks Butte,and now other natural areas are accessible to resi- misdirects Lake Oswego voters. Oswego citizens held collaborative In 1993 I purchased the farmstead wilderness parks.Vote Yes on Mea- dents with a variety of disabilities.All Please don't be fooled by City Coun- public meetings,collected donations, from Marjorie and John Emery that sure 3-568. ability trails need to be designed to en- cil's attempt to re-frame the Citizen's hired competent attorneys,wrote a bordered the 42 acre Cooks Butte Park Jan Holibaugh courage use by people with vision dis- Measure as a verbiage issue. It's well-crafted ballot measure,signed pe- that they deeded to the City of Lake Lake Oswego Professional Gutter Installation 0 , In Portland & Surrounding Areas ,-ealUaardA *yam.4'„:‘.j"'4 i41•I,-lii1.",/l._.Ni" �- 4ic)_'V1I 0 44-s4--k-.-v""41‘2'1 . 174,'. ENGLERT ® o \.__ .-,-P'„ N"'. •..,..i_.-l'•,'._5.,r ,.,k /II!7 ,- ,....- ': .k.....„..,. .,..c. . , .. , ,,,, ,. And y.fr •, ett. *._� ... , r.. .0,,..„:. 4 3/44,,,,,J4 , ..., s -,.4.1 ' ,• , , ; . -.'"61±'' Ci '' 4,- . - ". 1 It .t. :-.1. r ...:,,, i. \ . lit:,,,, ,, ... .11) ' f '' .4( .. , Zki 0, At -• -'-.- 1 InstaIIation ! * {•� ir1�•• l6•. . S Y t t. .3, 'y' •• ,4.: ` ., XN- v 4 - QUALITY TESTED �_� a . '� • GOOD• \, • - . 'I' •,- i • '=,,,.r HOUSEKEEPING • •R �'-' ling Since * 7909 e Rely on LeatGuard's ��� ��: 'rv�°w,_R AN ..--, iv�r \R Y•ghseal.co% Excellent Customer Service � `� Receive a $25 Amazon Call Toda ' . gift card with FREE 5 41_I— .3 ''''4I1i ± 3 - 'iLi in-home estimate. i j** \gm ...._ *Does not include cost of material.Expires 10-31-2021. ""Consumer Disclosure/Award Rules:All participants who attend an estimated 60-90 minute in-home product consultation will receive a$25 gift card.Retail value is$25.Offer sponsored by LeafGuard Holdings Inc.Limit one per household.Company procures, sells,and installs seamless gutter protection.This offer is valid for homeowners over 18 years of age. If married or involved with a life partner,both cohabitating persons must attend and complete presentation together.Participants must have a photo ID and be legally able to enter into a contract.The following persons are not eligible for this offer:employees of Company or affiliated companies or entities,their immediate family members,previous participants in a Company in-home consultation within the past 12 months and all current and former Company customers.Gift may not be extended,transferred,or substituted except that Company may substitute a gift of equal or greater value if it deems it necessary.Gift card will be mailed to the participant via first class United States Mail or e-mailed within 30 days of receipt of the promotion form provided at presentation.Not valid in conjunction with any other promotion or discount of any kind.Offer not sponsored or promoted by Amazon and is subject to change without notice prior to reservation.See https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeld=G7KXB4EYEHXZRUMA for gift card restrictions.Expires 10-31-2021. LeafGuard operates as LeafGuard of Oregon in Oregon under CCB# 223377 Exhibit 13 Cda°0 NEWS RELEASE a AI, o oREGo� For Immediate Release Contact: Madison Thesing, Assistant to the City Manager November 2, 2021 503-534-5285 Citizen's Initiative 3-568 Passes Lake Oswego, OR— Citizen's Initiative 3-568 Passes—Amending Chapter X of the Lake Oswego Charter to restrict improvements on certain Lake Oswego park properties. During the November 2, 2021 Special Election, Lake Oswego voters passed the Citizen's Initiative 3-568. Through voter approval, the City will amend Chapter X of the Lake Oswego Charter to include additional protections of our natural areas. Any future property-specific changes will include voter approval. "I would like to give special thanks to all the community members engaged in the parks measure campaigns," Mayor Joe Buck said. "Love LO Parks elevated the issue of natural area protections for a broad set of acreage within the city. The City will continue to work together with the Friends Groups, Oswego Watershed Council and the community on the comprehensive approach needed to enhance ecological conditions throughout the City." "The election brought forth our community's passion for the natural environment and enlivened the dialogue around how we care for natural areas. Now, we must commit to continuing to put that dialogue into action, improving upon it, and working together on the multitude of community topics framing our City life with unity and a neighborly respect," Mayor Joe Buck said. "We grow stronger when the hands of many neighbors manifest our values in lasting stewardship, good practices at home and in all parts of our city. No one has all the answers, so we are thankful for the wisdom gained from working together. Even if at times we disagree, we can all find truth in the sincere love we share for the community and our shared desire to continue to make the community an exceptional place to live, work and play." The City will share more information about the charter amendment process in the coming weeks. For information about the City of Lake Oswego, visit www.lakeoswego.city. ### Exhibit 14 LoveLOParks Customize 17 * 1 -I New Edit Post Insights © SEO 6 Howdy, Love LO Parks LOVELOPARKS ABOUT US OUR CAUSES LATEST NEWS RESOURCES =1:010 • I - N CITIZEN INITIATED MEASURE 3-568 PASSES! 11 HOME » PROTECT LO PARKS » NEWS » CITIZEN-INITIATED MEASURE 3-568 PASSES! L L LATEST NEWS E O THANK yru LOS ,� • r ^ Parks group unhappy with Lake Oswego's interpretation of nature preservation charter amendment 7:00 pm 22 Nov 2023 POEM LU 23-0002/AP 23-04: Development Review �-Y `�`• Commission • k. a 7:00 pm 20 Nov 2023 CITIZEN'S Lake Oswego development IERI r � J VIEW violates voter-approved nature preserve charter protections 12:01 am 15 Nov 2023 Citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 Passes! — �"... ' City Tentatively Approves CATEGORY : NEWS NEWS, PRESS RELEASES AUTHOR : LOVE LO PARKS Development Violating Voter- approved Nature Preserve FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE _+ Charter Protections 1:00 am 10 Nov 2023 LAKE OSWEGO, Oregon — November 2, 2021 — LoveLOParks announces Citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 passes to enact legal safeguards to limit development in Lake Oswego natural parks. Parks Plan 2040 During the November 2, 2021 Special Election, Lake Oswego voters had two measures to consider that offered different 5:45 pm 27 Oct 2023 legal instruments for protecting Lake Oswego's natural parks; the Citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 and City Council's referred Measure 3-575. Voters approved Citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 with 8,267 votes, or 62%, and winning by a substantial margin of 7%, or 875 votes, over City Council's referred Measure 3-575 with 7,392 votes, or 55% (official '" Resolution 22-32: City Council Approves Natural Areas Natural results updated Dec 7, 2021). ' Habitat Plan • "We're proud our community recognizes the value of strong protections to conserve our cherished natural areas and that 7:00 pm 22 Dec 2022 we raised this important issue to the attention of our community," stated Scott Handley, LoveLOParks grassroots organizer. "This not only is a win for our community, it is a win for the abundant wildlife that calls these natural habitats Open House: Natural Areas home." S Habitat Management Plan 4:34 pm 25 Oct 2022 "We're thankful for every volunteer, donor, and petition signer who made Measure 3-568 a reality," Handley continues. "Two years ago, we set out with one goal — to provide our community the opportunity to consider and vote on sensible development limitations to keep our natural parks natural. And, that's what we did while maintaining our integrity, EX Lake Oswego City Council honesty, and transparency even when embattled by our opposition" bendidates comment on tension between development and environment Measure 3-568 repeals and replaces Chapter X in the City Charter. Chapter X was originally enacted by Lake Oswego citizens in 1978 to prevent Springbrook Park from being developed into a major athletic facility. By voter approval, 5:47 pm 07 Oct 2022 Chapter X will be amended to include additional protections for 15 additional natural areas. Any future natural park changes that would involve development otherwise restricted by Chapter X will require voter approval. Mayor says City will recognize ` will of voters "Everyone involved with the LoveLOParks effort should be proud of their participation in this significant accomplishment 12:00 am 19 Jan 2022 to give our community this choice and the protection of our parks. A special thank you to every Lake Oswego voter for choosing to protect nature for our future," concluded Handley. LoveLOParks Steering IMP Committee Condemns City To commemorate this historic moment in Lake Oswego's history that will have a profound and positive impact for Council's Rebuke of Voters conserving these natural habitats for future generations to enjoy all their wildlife and natural splendor, we invite the Lake Oswego community to express their feelings of gratitude below with a reply below. 12:30 am 15 Jan 2022 More information: • City of Lake Oswego: PRESS RELEASE Nov 2 Parks Measure Results — Citizen Initiative 3-568 Passes • Clackamas County Elections: November 2, 2021 Special Election • Multnomah County Elections: November 2, 2021 Election Results • Citizen Initiative 2020IN-1 Qualifies for the November 2021 Ballot • Citizen Initiative Petition 2020IN-1 Receives Approval to Circulate • Prospective Petition for a Local Initiative Meets Constitutional Provisions • Emery's Rescind Consent for Telecommunications Tower at Cooks Butte LoveLOParks is a Lake Oswego grassroots citizen coalition that seeks to enact sensible legal safeguards that limit development in Lake Oswego natural parks to keep them safe, accessible, healthy, and vibrant natural habitats rich with wildlife for future generations to enjoy their splendor. https://www.loveloparks.org NOVEMBER 2, 2021 12 COMMENTS Edit VOTE YES ON MEASURE 3-568 LoveLOParks: Vote YES on Citizens' Measure 3-568 Vote for parks is historic moment 12 thoughts on "Citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 Passes!" RMelinda Hunt on December 18, 2021 Edit I lived with Marjorie and John Emery in 1977-79 and enjoyed riding horses through Cooks Butte. It was a wonderful peaceful place. It inspired me to to turn 131 acres in New York City into parkland in 2019 and begin a campaign to designate Hart Island and National Monument. I hope this place inspires others to preserve and restore wilderness areas across the globe. Congratulations on your efforts and success. Leanne Bilstrom on November 6, 2021 Edit What a relief and again my sincere thanks, heartfelt, for your work to get this initiative on the ballot and to help get it passed Sandi Peskin on November 5, 2021 Edit In our small corner of the world, citizens of Lake Oswego made a difference regarding the persistent march forward of development and mitigating the effects of climate change by passing the measure to protect our precious wild spaces. I feel a soul satisfying joy in this victory! I am honored and proud to have been a part of this successful effort. Thank you to Scott for the incredible amount of work he did; for his integrity and unflagging dedication and to all the others who contributed to this effort. It is hugely rewarding to recognize the power of citizens' grassroots efforts coming to fruition. Congratulations to all! (I can almost hear the our wild spaces exhaling with a sigh of relief!) Mark E Chambers on November 5, 2021 Edit Nature takes a course with an intelligence beyond our own; sometimes the best action we can take as stewards of the community is no action. Let it be, let it be; and when we do this wonders are revealed by the Trilliums in March, the busy nesting of birds, the quiet assured by the wall of firs, cedars, and vine maples, the wonder of hidden fungi showing fruits with fall rains ... so much that cannot be improved by our ambitions. Too much development and industry happens with later regret; we can indeed celebrate "no regrets" with the passage our the initiative. On behalf of the wild things, special places, and those of us who take solace and find peace with nature: Thank you to Scott Handley and all the others who worked and won! Sandi Hansen on November 5, 2021 Edit WE THE PEOPLE of Lake Oswego have come together to preserve the splendor of the natural parks and protect wildlife habitats that make this community special. I am so grateful to Scott Handley for his leadership, perseverance, providing us with true information to protect nature as it is meant to be and connecting so many of us to pivot the direction of our future in the right direction. I am also grateful to all the volunteers that contribute their time and love keeping these areas healthy & beautiful. Thanks to all of the awesome citizens — visionaries — who took the time to care, get involved and continue the journey those so lovingly started centuries ago. Jonathan EBeckon November 5, 2021 Edit Congratulations to all. We did it. Shari Gardner on November 5, 2021 Edit Thanks to Scott and team and all of the voters that made this happen. Overtime it will only become more apparent how precious our natural spaces are — and how important it is to seize the moment before they slip away. Isabel Sturman on November 5, 2021 Edit I have not met most of those who campaigned for 568 but it's nice to know that we worked together to save special places for people to enjoy long after we are gone. Meg Wilkinson on November 5, 2021 Edit I am so grateful to Scott and Joey for their vision and leadership. There were times when it felt like the battle was lost, especially when everything shut down for Covid. Who would have imagined that we could have pivoted so seamlessly to a virtual campaign? I am sure that the city did not. This all in spite of countless personal attacks on Scott's credibility and honesty. Lisa Brisleyon November 5, 2021 Edit "THE GREATNESS OF A COMMUNITY IS MOST ACCURATELY MEASURED BY THE COMPASSIONATE ACTIONS OF ITS MEMBERS, A HEART OF GRACE AND A SOUL GENERATED BY LOVE." Theresa Kohlhoffon November 4, 2021 Edit I am beyond happy with the results of this election. It really showed that citizens knew the score and no matter what or how many logs were tossed to block the flow, we patiently stayed with it to the successful outcome. Let's savor this memory and acknowledge our strength when a righteous challenge presents itself. Scott Handleyon November 4, 2021 Edit THANK YOU LAKE OSWEGO VOTERS and every volunteer, donor, and supporter who made this moment a reality!!! This is a historic moment for Lake Oswego. This journey began long before my family moved to Lake Oswego (we've only been here 3 years). It began with familys' like the Emery's (Cooks Butte), Shipley's (Stevens Meadow), and Donald Meyer (Woodmont Park) who wanted to leave a touch of wilderness to future Lake Oswegans. It began with those citizens who fought for Springbrook Park, Bryant Woods, Canal Acres, and Cooks Butte when threatened by development. And, now we can add those citizens, our friends and neighbors, who persevered through the Covid-19 global pandemic, the firestorms of September 2020, and ice storms of 2021 to reach and inform nearly every household in our community and to collect over 4,800 petition signatures to quality our citizen initiative petition 2020IN-1 for the ballot that gave our community this opportunity. Voters have chosen to leave a lasting legacy of nature for our community and its future. Voters have chosen to help in the global fight against climate change (at our local level). Voters have chosen to conserves these natural habitats for the abundant wildlife that call them home and for future residents to enjoy all their splendor. What a tremendous gift you all have provided our community. You have made history! I'm proud of our community and honored to have met so many great neighbors along our 2 year journey. This is truly a magical place! Comments are closed. STAY INFORMED. GET INV0111111111 I SUBSCRIBE LoveLOParks.org is managed by Lake Oswego residents who architected and supported the voter-ratified Chapter X — Park Development Limitation in Lake Oswego's City Charter. LoveLOParks remains as the steward providing oversight to hold the City accountable to Lake Oswego residents. Chapter X provides legal safeguards to insure all development in a Nature Preserve is consistent with the preservation of a Nature Preserve as a natural area. Copyright 2019-23 LoveLOParks, All Right Reserved 0 info@loveloparks.org f O n u Exhibit 15 E © 1-6 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES November 2, 2021 ©Rt=GO 1. CALL TO ORDER, CITY COUNCIL Mayor Buck called the regular City Council meeting to order at 5:31 p.m. on November 2, 2021. The meeting was held both virtually via video conferencing and in-person. 2. ROLL CALL Present: Mayor Buck, Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Mboup Staff Present: Martha Bennett, City Manager; Jason Loos, City Attorney; Evan Boone, Deputy City Attorney; Paul Espe, Associate Planner; Erica Rooney, City Engineer I Public Works Director; Shawn Cross, Finance Director; Nadia Ahmed, Human Resources Specialist; Scot Siegel, Economic Development Director; Gert Zoutendijk, Fire Marshal; Kari Linder, City Recorder 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Buck led the Pledge of Allegiance. 4. PUBLIC COMMENT No Public Comment was provided. 4.1 PRIOR PUBLIC COMMENT FOLLOW-UP No prior follow-up was provided. 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS 5.1 Ordinance 2874, Annexing Property at SW Kimball and SW Baleine Streets (AN 21-0003). Jason Loos, City Attorney, read the parameters of the public hearing, and asked if any members of the Council had any ex parte contacts, including a site visit, any bias, or any financial conflicts of interest. None were heard. City Council Meeting Minutes Page 1 of 13 November 2, 2021 Paul Espe, Associate Planner, presented the Council Report for three properties being considered for annexation at the southeast corner of Kimball St and Baleine St. One item of public testimony was received from David Brown, included in the packet as Exhibit F-200, against the annexation. The concerns raised in his email would be addressed with the future partitioning of the property in terms of wetland delineation, tree removal, storm water provision, etc. The proposed annexation was owner-initiated and would result in the addition of approximately 2.07 acres of residential land to the City. The property was currently under Clackamas County's jurisdiction and was zoned R-7.5 low-density residential in the Comprehensive Plan and would also be zoned R-7.5 on annexation. The City's Sensitive Land Map designated a resource protection (RP)district over the northeast side of the properties. Pursuant to Code, the RP overlay district would be applied to the properties upon annexation, and the property owners had been informed of such. He addressed other related items including installation and mitigation of a sewer line by the applicant, future improvements to Baleine St., and stormwater facilities. Staff recommended tentative approval of the annexation with the final enactment being deferred until the owner had executed and recorded the covenant to construct and connect to the City sewer line. In response to an inquiry by Councilor Manz, Mr. Espe confirmed other annexations had taken place in the area, and the location of the sewer system 500 feet away from the property added complexity to the application. In response to a question from Mayor Buck, Mr. Espe confirmed the applicant would need to execute the covenant to install the sewer line before the ordinance came back to Council for signature. Council was being asked to tentatively approve the annexation tonight. He further clarified that it would be necessary for the applicant to delineate the wetland, the RP, and file a land use application for the sewer construction. The delineation would be through a standard land use application, including a public process. Lastly, he confirmed the lots were currently vacant. Councilor Wendland asked for a review on what could be developed on land with an RP designation. Mr. Espe replied that if a property was totally encumbered by an RP resource, the Code allowed for the development of a reasonably-sized house-like development on the property. Mayor Buck noted the report stated the single-family dwelling access was taken from Kimball St. Mr. Espe responded that an access from Kimball St already existed, but no dwelling was located on the property. Applicant's Testimony Ed Brockman, Applicant, stated quite a bit of planning for the project had been done already and he would be turning in a pre-application request on Thursday. Meetings had been held in Waluga Park with the Parks Director, City Engineer, and the person in charge of sewer maintenance. Pacific Habitat had examined, surveyed, and conducted a full delineation of the wetlands on Tax Lot 2902. The location of the resource on Tax Lots 3000 and 100 had been tentatively identified and flagged by Pacific Habitat and was yet to be surveyed. Tax Lots 3000 and 100 were originally each platted as two lots and could be reclaimed simply through a request by the property owner through the Clackamas County Assessor according to State Law. In other City Council Meeting Minutes Page 2 of 13 November 2, 2021 words, five lots of record existed and could be assigned new tax lot numbers and addresses. If the property was annexed, the applicant planned to do some lot line adjustments but had no plans to develop a home, even though he legally could. The lot line adjustments would move the proposed five residences out of the RP zone entirely. • The sewer would be 1,100 ft long in total and would be expensive. The owner had recently purchased the properties and because of the RP zone and no plan for how to develop properties, the cost had not been great. The owner could pay for the sewer and still have a project that made financial sense. • The home builder had built other homes in Lake Oswego. The planned lot sizes would not be less than 8,000 sq ft. Councilor Mboup asked how many trees were located on the property and how the applicant planned to deal with them upon annexation. Mr. Brockman replied the property would be surveyed, and the location of every tree on the property 5 inches in diameter and greater would be mapped and its species identified. He declined to provide an estimate of the number of trees on the property without more data. Tax Lot 2902 was the yard for Tax Lot 15868 and had been cleared, but had some good-sized trees. He had photos of the property before it was cleared, but they were not readily available. A lot of undergrowth and blackberries had moved into the lot. Tax Lots 3000 and 100 in the RP zone would be protected and nothing would be removed other than invasive species, such as blackberries. The impact on the lots to be built on as well as the size of house would be limited according to Code. Tax Lots 3000 and 100 were not full of big Fir trees, but some big Firs existed on Tax Lot 2902 that could be seen in an aerial photo on the City's website. • Neal Bauer Mr. Bauer spoke on behalf of the Carman Garden Homeowners Association (HOA) and was a resident of Tara Place. For as long as he had lived in the neighborhood, the wetlands had turned into a lake for a good part of the winter. The area of the cul-de-sac had been flooded in the past, and the builder had brought in many truckloads of rock and sand to build it up for the four homes developed there. Subsequent runoff from the rain had taken away the land, and the residents had to fill up their backyards with dirt on two occasions. Once someone had dug into the field across from the cul-de-sac to determine if it was buildable and could not find any dry areas. They had taken down trees and carved into the land and could provide no documentation in response to the neighbors' request. The wetland had several hundred trees, including big Birch trees, which provided beautiful scenery, a root structure for the land, and also deadened the sound of traffic from 1-5. His neighbors had just sold their home and had brought someone out who reported the existing sewer already had a belly because of subsidence from the rain it had not been equipped for. Building five homes on Tara PI was outrageous and he found the proposal to be scary because of the fill that would be required and would direct the water through the other houses in the area. He confirmed he was opposed to the annexation. • Stephanie Glazer City Council Meeting Minutes Page 3 of 13 November 2, 2021 Ms. Glazer stated she was neutral on the annexation, but she was concerned about the sensitive area that she lived adjacent to. She agreed with Mr. Bauer's testimony that the land was under water for many months out of the year. She wanted to make sure that the RP remained in place after annexation and would not be diminished when development was considered. Tax Lots 3000 and 100 had even more standing water than the wetlands already delineated. She wanted the management of that water to be part of the annexation to make sure the water stayed where it was. Allowing the trees to remain would help. The neighbors who had lived there longer than her had spoken about the earlier development on Tara PI that made their properties flood. The sensitive lands overlay was intended to protect the water resource and to maintain the water in its current location. With a few exceptions, most everyone in the area was on a septic system and many residents had invested significant financial resources to install, upgrade, and maintain them. She did not know what the implications were to the neighbors of a new sewer on Kimball St and whether they would need to pay for it. The sewer line would cut directly through the sensitive lands and it seemed like proper care was not being taken to protect the resource. Baleine St was currently a walking and biking path and a very narrow area and she would not want to see it become a major cut-through street. The intersection of Baleine St and Carman Dr was not safe enough to handle additional traffic. Mayor Buck clarified that the installation of the sewer line was part of the Sewer Master Plan and would not have any bearing on others in the area, other than that its extension would make it easier for someone to connect to it if they wanted to, so, in a sense, they would be bearing that expense for the other neighbors. Properties within a close distance to a main were required to connect upon annexation due to the plan that everyone would be on the sewer and not on septic tanks. Martha Bennett, City Manager, added that if someone's septic tank was leaking and creating a health hazard, and they were located within a certain number of feet of a sewer line, they would be required to connect. • Kathy Lundeen Ms. Lundeen said she was neutral to the application and she agreed with the others who testified that standing water remained on the site even during the drought. Tara PI had been a marsh with nesting water birds, turtles, and cattails and it was filled in for a development. The backyard of the neighbor to the left of Tract A had flooded and she needed to dig a pond because the water was displaced from the marsh into her backyard and then into the RP areas. She believed that if the area was annexed, it was Council's responsibility to make sure the remediation was done. She was neutral to the application because she did not know Council's position on the matter. She also believed the wetlands needed to be preserved as habitat. She inquired who would replace the Surface Water Management of Clackamas County as they would no longer be responsible after the annexation. Baleine St was paved only to Carman Dr and the rest was gravel. The City frequently had to add more gravel due to the roadway washing out. It had been a walking path for many years. The condition of the trees on Tax Lots 3000 and 100 was not as good as it used to be which she suspected was because of the extra water and subsequent rot. She had lost several trees to wind and rot. Some beautiful Willamette Valley Oaks were on Tax Lots 3000 and 100 and she strongly believed they should be preserved as habitat for Douglas squirrels and Western gray squirrels. When she needed a new septic system, the City told her that a pumping station or a lifting station was needed, but she had not heard either system mentioned in regard to this annexation. City Council Meeting Minutes Page 4 of 13 November 2, 2021 • Willy Paul Mr. Paul stated he had been neutral to the application but was now against it due to what he had heard from Mr. Brockman. His home was located on the southwesterly corner of the proposed annexation. He was in complete agreement with the previous testimony about the water issues. The wetlands were necessary for the standing water on the property throughout the winter. The sewer on his property had an easement to allow a tie-in from Tax Lot 2902 to Kimball St but he understood it would be for a single-family residence behind his property. He heard Mr. Brockman state the intention to make lot line adjustments to Tax Lots 100 and 3000 through the county to mitigate some of the RP boundary issues. He understood the intention was to develop five homes on the subdivided tax lots which meant to him five homes located on a remainder of Tax Lots 3000 and 2902. It seemed to be an extremely dense amount of development that would take advantage of the RP area in order to gain that density. He proposed R-15 zoning instead of the R-7.5 designation to help mitigate some of the density issues and some of the water issues relative to the RP area. He was concerned about the mention in the application that no additional impervious surfaces would be introduced to the properties which to him meant no paved streets and no driveways and he asked for clarification. He also asked what provision was made for the neighbors to be involved in the development process after the annexation. He asked if a storm drain system was also considered part of the mitigation to address some of the water accumulation issues. Lastly, he asked about how Goal 10 would apply to the properties in the RP area as it was not mentioned in the Council Report. Councilor Manz clarified with staff that only the annexation was being considered tonight and not the development of the property, nor was consideration being given to the ruling on proportionality of what can or cannot be done with development on the property. Mr. Paul understood that the recommendation in the Council Report for annexation maintained the R-7.5 zoning and asked if a process existed post-annexation for reconsideration of that zoning. Ms. Bennett clarified the annexation would come in under the pre-determined zoning in the Comprehensive Plan. HB 2001 was not material in this case regarding zoning. Mayor Buck added that rezoning would be a separate consideration in another public process. • Natalie Diloreto Ms. Diloreto stated she lived in the field Mr. Bauer referred to in his testimony earlier. Her home backed up to Baleine St which was now just a beautiful walking trail for families and their dogs. The wetlands started about halfway through her property and the water reached knee-depth in winter. She was concerned that if it already became that deep, where it would go if more development took place and what studies would be done to make that determination. The residents took great pride in the existing trees and her property backed up to some beautiful trees. Though it was private property, kids were allowed to play there and in her field when it was dry enough. It offered a great sense of community and she asked if the trees were removed, would it mean that Baleine St would become an actual street instead of a trail. Her backyard was a whole ecosystem with several types of wildlife and it would be sad if it was taken away. Councilor Manz clarified that the part of Baleine St indicated in blue was a trail and became gravel at the location of Tax Lot 3000. She confirmed with staff that it was a right-of-way in the City Council Meeting Minutes Page 5 of 13 November 2, 2021 City of Lake Oswego. Ms. Bennett cautioned against assuming Baleine St would become an improved street. She advised questions to staff be held until Council's deliberation. Mayor Buck called for the applicant's rebuttal. Mr. Brockman noted he had spoken to the tentative plans to develop the area, though his application was for annexation because he believed it would be helpful to Council and the public to be upfront. Engineering advised against having Baleine St cut through to Inverurie Rd to avoid cut through traffic. He had no plans to improve Baleine St now, but that did not mean it would never be improved. His responses to questions raised during public testimony were as follows: • Access was planned on the southern border of Tax Lot 3000 and not on the 15-ft easement at 15868 Kimball St, and plans were to bring the sewer through Tax Lot 3000 and not through 15868 Kimball St. Anything north of Tax Lots 3000 and 100 was strictly a path, though sewer would be brought through there. He anticipated it would remain a path in the future and he had no plans to disrupt the neighborhood use of foot traffic there. • The Code required management of storm water, and that was probably one of the most limiting factors to the development potential of the site. Initially, he had informally inquired of the Planning Director about annexing and developing the area with septic systems for a couple of the homes. The Planning Director seemed to believe that was reasonable, but Mr. Brockman understood he was not the decision-maker and when he applied for annexation, he was told staff would not recommend the annexation to Council unless sewer was brought to the property. In order for that to pencil out, more than two houses would need to be developed there. • He had paid $7,000 to an engineering firm to guarantee that the sewer system could gravity flow without a pump station, so no pump station would be involved. • On Tax Lot 100 toward Inverurie Rd an area existed that was a lake virtually all winter long, but it was not the entire area indicated for annexation. Mayor Buck noted for the public that the Council Report contained an attachment that explained annexation. Mr. Espe explained staff had not been given details on what could happen with the property in terms of partitioning or recognizing legal lots of record. Mr. Brockman indicated he wanted to reestablish the legal lots of record through Clackamas County which would not require public noticing. Once the property was annexed, a lot line adjustment could be done through the City which would have limited noticing and was also an administrative process. If re-platting was required, it would be necessary for him to go through the noticed land use process. The land use process that would be noticed first would be the delineation of the wetlands, followed by a noticed land use process for the construction of the sewer and the re-delineation of the existing RP lines. He confirmed the relationship between the lot lines and the RP designation was irrelevant; the lot lines would not dictate the location of the RP area. The public would have the opportunity to participate in the wetland delineation process and comment on the criteria as well as on a Type 2 tree removal. Councilor Mboup said he was very concerned about the issues raised in testimony. He asked if developing the property would have consequences in terms of engineering. The neighbors were worried about damage to their property resulting from development. He asked if from a scientific standpoint they could be told that the damage from flooding would not happen. Mr. Espe replied City Council Meeting Minutes Page 6 of 13 November 2, 2021 that the applicant would determine through the future land use process whether a storm system would work so the adjacent properties would not be inundated. Additional related requirements would also have to be followed. Councilor Mboup referred to the testimony about the previous development flooding a home and asked if any guarantee could be offered to reassure the residents that would not happen again. Mr. Espe replied he did not believe that staff was equipped to make any such scientific guarantee for the adjacent properties until a land use application was before them for review. The burden of proof would be on the applicant to bear that out and determine whether or not their development would meet the City Code requirements regarding sensitive lands, storm water, providing the sewer, etc. Councilor Manz confirmed that this part of the process was only for annexation and any future development would go through a very rigorous process defined by Code. Ms. Espe further confirmed additional procedures would include land use review for the wetland delineation, partition requirements, and building permits for individual houses. Storm water would need to be managed on site and the storm water Codes followed. Councilor Wendland confirmed the three tax lots had already been determined and asked how often changes to an RP area were allowed once the RP designation was placed. It was difficult to imagine how five houses would be built in the area indicated in red on the diagram provided by Mr. Brockman. He asked why Tax Lot 100 would be connected to the sewer when it was not intended to be developed. Mr. Espe replied that the sensitive land designation shown on the map was a generalized location because the wetland scientists were not able to ground truth every lot when the overlays were established for the wetlands. The idea was that final delineation of the RP resource would take place in the future based on field surveys. Secondly, the sensitive lands designation allowed for modifications to dimensional standards, setbacks, and floor area of the underlying zone, and for variation in the lot dimension, lot size, and depth without a variance if the transfer of allowable density in the R-7.5 zone was not increased and did not have a greater negative impact on the natural resource. Other limitations in the Sensitive Lands Code also existed. If one lot was completely designated as an RP resource and occupied most or all of the lot in any residential district, the property owner was permitted development on the parcel of a single-family dwelling or the equivalent based on the minimum lot area of the underlying zone. If they owned only Tax Lot 100 and it was completely encumbered by the RP resource, the owner would be legally entitled to build one reasonably-sized house on the property based on the setbacks and requirements of the R-7.5 zone. Councilor Wendland inquired if a similar situation had occurred on Tara PI, and if the same could happen on Tax Lots 100 and 3000. The property owner could go through the same process to erase some of the blue area if they met the criteria. Mr. Espe agreed it was possible if the criteria were met and the property owner could establish that the location did not contain a wetland, but they could not fill or place fill in an RP resource. Councilor Nguyen thanked Mr. Brockman for providing additional insight on his future plans for the annexed property. He believed the question should be asked if the applicant would continue with the annexation if it was determined later that five houses could not be built on the three lots. He understood it was a chicken-and-egg scenario, but it would be good to know to save staff and the applicant time, and whether the project made financial sense. Ms. Bennett responded that it was not possible because the City did not review the idea of a development proposal, just the proposals themselves. The property owner had to do their own due diligence to determine the viability of the project. Councilor Nguyen noted the four manholes for the sewer and asked if City Council Meeting Minutes Page 7 of 13 November 2, 2021 another way existed to connect the sewer without impacting the natural areas. Erica Rooney, Public Works Director/City Engineer, replied that a master plan based off of high-level geography showed a slight rise to the west necessitating that the sewer flowed to the east. As part of the annexation package, the applicant looked into the feasibility of having the sewer flow by gravity because the area was so flat. Having the sewer flow to the west would require a pump. The City had placed sewers in parks before, most recently in Rivergrove Park, in the interest of keeping sewers in a gravity formation. In this application, they wanted to attempt to bore instead of using an open cut to lessen the impact to the natural area. Councilor Verdick asked for more detail on how the zoning was determined for the site in the past. The residents had mentioned during testimony the possibility of different zoning to preserve the neighborhood character. Ms. Bennett replied it was the result of the State Goal 10 Housing Rules where every community of a certain size had to achieve a certain housing density community-wide. Down-zoning in the subject neighborhood would require up-zoning someplace else. Councilor Verdick asked for further information about requiring sewer versus septic. Ms. Bennett replied that was also a statewide requirement prohibiting septic systems in a development in an urban area with urban services. A failed septic system within a certain number of feet of a sewer line would require a connection to a sewer and, under City policy, an annexation was required before a sewer connection could be made. Mayor Buck moved to tentatively approve Ordinance 2874 and direct staff to return with findings and an Ordinance for enactment upon the owner recording the Covenant to Construct and Connect to City Sewer Line in the official records of Clackamas County, Oregon. Councilor Rapf seconded the motion. Councilor Nguyen received confirmation that the approval would be tentative and the applicant could withdraw the application if he decided to do so. Councilor Wendland noted the city welcomed those who wished to annex in and did not force the issue. He would support the application under those circumstances with the understanding that a lot of work had to be done on Mr. Brockman's part. Councilor Rapf was in support of the application because he believed government should not get in the way of wealth-building or in making life better and that it was not Council's job to state whether or not the applicant could build on the site. If the property ultimately could not be built upon, the city would have a nice wetland that would not be developed. He believed many people tonight might have expected something more from the process than just a decision on annexation. He fully supported annexation and believed that City staff and others would make the right decision on developing the property when the time came. Councilor Mboup stated he would have voted against annexation of the property, but he had faith in staff and accepted their statements tonight. The property had a visible problem and he had reservations about it, but would vote in favor of the annexation. A roll call vote was held, and the motion was passed, with Mayor Buck and Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Rapf voting `aye', (7-0). City Council Meeting Minutes Page 8 of 13 November 2, 2021 Mayor Buck reiterated this decision was tentative and that staff would return to Council with findings on November 14tn Council took a break from 7:13 p.m. to 7:22 p.m. 5.2 Ordinance 2775, Vacating the Remaining Portion of a Public Alley located South of A Avenue between 3rd and 4th Streets. Jason Loos, City Attorney, read the parameters of the public hearing, then asked if any members of the Council had any ex parte contacts, including a site visit, any bias, or any financial conflicts of interest. None were heard. Ms. Rooney presented the Council Report for the vacation of a public alley, describing the location and applicable statues. She described the changes in the area that led to the development of the alley into a plaza, and other details leading up to the proposed ordinance. The City Recorder had received no public comments on the matter. She clarified that the plats were typically set up to each contain a side of the right-of-way so, when a vacation took place, the two sides returned to the original holders. Council had the option of a future lot line adjustment if desired. Mayor Buck opened the public hearing, confirmed there was no public testimony, and then closed the hearing. Councilor Manz moved to enact Ordinance 2775. Councilor Mboup seconded the motion. A voice vote was held, and the motion was passed, with Mayor Buck and Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Rapf voting `aye', (7-0). 5.3 Resolution 21-36, Adjusting the Budget for the Biennium Commencing July 1, 2021 by Adopting a Supplemental Budget, Approving Resources/Requirements, and Making Appropriations. Resolution 21-37, Authorizing the Prepayment of Certain Full Faith and Credit Obligations Previously Issued. Sean Cross, Finance Director, presented the Council Report, noting the City had sold some bonds in 2011 that were now callable. Usually, the City would consider refunding them for a lower interest rate, but staff realized the fund balance was sufficient to pay off the bonds. By doing so, the City would save about $1.6 million in interest payments. He clarified that because the maximum indebtedness had been reached, TIF (tax increment financing)funds could not be used toward projects anymore, and the money needed to go to repaying the debt. Mayor Buck opened the public hearing, confirmed there was no public testimony, and closed the hearing. Councilor Mboup moved to adopt Resolution 21-36 and Resolution 21-37. Councilor Manz seconded the motion. City Council Meeting Minutes Page 9 of 13 November 2, 2021 A voice vote was held, and the motion was passed, with Mayor Buck and Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Rapf voting `aye', (7-0). 6. STUDY SESSIONS 6.1 Certification Office for Business Inclusion and Diversity (COBID) Update Evan Boone, Deputy City Attorney, spoke to the development of rules regarding equity in public contracting. Council's goal was to foster diversity, equity and inclusion by reaching out to businesses that met the Certification Office of Business Inclusion and Diversity (COBID) certification which focused on emerging small businesses, minority and women-owned businesses, businesses by service-disabled veterans, and disadvantaged business enterprises. He updated on some of the questions posed to Council on August 3rd as follows: • How many COBID-certified businesses should staff contact when doing a solicitation? Staff had no strong feeling either way. • Should staff advertise in the OregonBuys E-procurement Program? Doing so would not further Council's goal in reaching out to COBID firms because the OregonBuys program applied to everyone. • Should the City be adopting a specific percentage of COBID firms as an aspirational goal for contracting? If so, which contracts do they apply to? Staff recommended not setting this goal until the tools were in place to determine the percentage. • Should good faith efforts apply only to construction contracts or to others as well?Architectural engineering and public improvements could also be considered. Mr. Boone said staff had also identified internal tracking challenges they would work to address with the new Equity Program Manager, Guilian Del Rio, who would also work with City departments on reporting to be presented to Council. He noted a section was inadvertently omitted from the Council Report regarding the evaluation criteria for when bids were sought for goods and services and for personal services where not less than 10 percent of the points for evaluating a bid was based on one or more of the following criteria: The business is certified through COBID; the public contracting officer could elect to use an effective plan for identifying and using COBID-certified subcontractors; or, the business had demonstrated a previous history in reaching out to COBID firms. He then provided the following answers to clarifying questions from Council: • The OregonBuys program was a statewide system that resulted in a broader bid solicitation but did not have any COBID-type leaning. Some of the other cities that have moved toward the COBID process did not use OregonBuys. • The Good Faith Effort(GFE) program was required by contractors in the construction industry to determine whether a firm was COBID or not and how those firms would be sought. The City did not yet have a separate GFE program yet, but would be developing one with the help of Ms. Del Rio. She would also make a recommendation to management on whether a computer- based tracking system would be necessary and how it would be implemented. Having the data be part of the Finance Department's online dashboard was a possibility that would be considered. • It was not likely that staff would reach out to the same COBID-qualified vendors repeatedly; the greater problem was getting enough responses from COBID firms due to more City Council Meeting Minutes Page 10 of 13 November 2, 2021 governments reaching out to those firms. If insufficient numbers of responses were seen, the net could be broadened. • The City had not previously stated it was necessary to reach out to any particular classification of business from a contracting point of view. The COBID database would help in that regard. Council's goal from January was to broaden the outreach to inclusive and diverse businesses. • A conference call was held about the COBID program with a number of Oregon cities including Tigard, Beaverton, Eugene, and Portland. Beaverton already had an equity program manager, and had provided a model to emulate. • The City would participate in outreach activities to encourage eligible businesses to obtain COBID certification. COBID firms would be notified of contract opportunities and events such as trade shows. The Equity Program Manager would assist with those activities. Beaverton, Tigard, and other cities already had an event they did in common, so Lake Oswego could join with them on the advertising. • Cooperative agreements did not need to be advertised by the City on the theory that they were nationally or regionally advertised. The City could buy off of agreements, but would also have to solicit a bid from two COBID certified businesses. Council directed staff to proceed with a public hearing in December on amending the public contracting rules to require staff to review the COBID database for at least two COBID-certified firms to contact. 6.2 Commercial Temporary Shelters (COVID) — LU 21-0068 Scot Siegel, Community Development Director, presented the Council Report regarding the use of temporary shelters for commercial uses, particularly for restaurants. Earlier this year, the City Council amended the Community Development Code (CDC) to allow temporary shelters or tents for more than 14 days consistent with its goal to support business expansion and primarily to provide relief during the pandemic by allowing greater social distancing. The ordinance was in addition to Code that already allowed seasonal enclosures that restaurants could use on a recurring basis during the fall and winter months. Those enclosures required a higher level of design and went through design review. • Staff sought Council's direction on whether to extend the allowance for the shelters this fall and winter, and had issued an anticipatory public notice for a prospective Planning Commission hearing on November 8th. Staff would return to Council on November 16th for a public hearing and consideration of an ordinance. The language of the ordinance would change from referencing physical distancing requirements to referencing any emergency or state regulation relating to COVID. Key points of Council's discussion touched on the possibility that some of the small number of restaurants using temporary shelters were not ready to open at full capacity due to the ongoing pandemic; impacts of vaccinations on restaurant staff and patrons; the future usefulness of such structures; the assistance shelters might provide to restaurants financially; and how temporary outdoor structures might provide a sense of normalcy during the pandemic. Mr. Siegel confirmed Council wanted staff to move forward with the temporary shelter extension process. City Council Meeting Minutes Page 11 of 13 November 2, 2021 6.3 Council Goals Update— 3rd Quarter Martha Bennett, City Manager, provided a brief update on the progress on Council goals, noting the topic was covered in more detail in the Council Report. Council was making steady progress on 16 of the 18 initiatives set for eight overall goals, and the remaining two initiatives were scheduled for Council action. She highlighted the progress made on the community dialog on policing and on major capital projects. 7. CONSENT AGENDA— FULL COUNCIL 7.1 Approval of Meeting Minutes September 14, 2021, Draft Special Meeting Minutes September 21, 2021, Draft Regular Meeting Minutes September 28, 2021, Draft Special Meeting Minutes Councilor Wendland moved to adopt the Consent Agenda. Councilor Verdick seconded the motion. A voice vote was held, and the motion was passed, with Mayor Buck and Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Rapf voting `aye', (7-0). 8. CONSENT AGENDA— COUNCILORS ONLY 8.1 Resolution 21-39, A Resolution of the City Councilors of the City of Lake Oswego Approving the Appointment of an Alternate to the 50+ Advisory Board. Mayor Buck thanked outgoing board member Janine Hawthorne and incoming member Susan Bailey. Councilor Wendland moved to adopt the Consent Agenda. Councilor Mboup seconded the motion. A voice vote was held, and the motion was passed,with Councilors Mboup, Manz, Nguyen, Wendland, Verdick, and Rapf voting `aye', (6-0). 9. INFORMATION FROM COUNCIL Councilor Manz reported the house had been removed from Hallinan Woods and the work was anticipated to be finished by the end of the week, weather provided. Councilor Wendland reported on the Lake Oswego Recreation and Aquatic Center (LORAC). Another design review meeting had been held and the plans could be seen on the Parks and Recreation page on the City's website. The operating agreement was being worked on with the School District. City Council Meeting Minutes Page 12 of 13 November 2, 2021 Council Verdick reported she had talked this morning with Amanda Watson, Sustainability Program Manager, and learned the City had met its solar goal. Mayor Buck noted that for Native American Heritage Month, the City was hosting a traveling exhibit called Oregon Is Indian Country in part at the City Hall and at the Public Library starting mid-month and going through the early part of December. He reported a presentation was given at the Metro Policy Advisory Committee meeting on the garbage system and the increased tip fee's impact on providers. Councilor Manz reported that Lake Oswego Reads chose How Much of These Hills Is Gold for 2022. The book was a story about the children of Chinese Immigrants. 10. REPORTS OF OFFICERS No reports of officers were given. 11. ADJOURNMENT, CITY COUNCIL Mayor Buck adjourned the City Council at 8:21 p.m. to call to order the Redevelopment Agency. The LORA board met from 8:21 p.m. to 8:23 p.m. Respectfully submitted, veiLe4 Kari Linde , City Recorder Approved by the City Council on December 7, 2021 Joseph M. Buck, Mayor City Council Meeting Minutes Page 13 of 13 November 2, 2021 Exhibit 16 LOHS' -: • Black student Ii Local store . n, I ' -' S ING,,- 'K .x Peters , t mentorship �s hosting wins state • �,� program seeks mini quilt o , A P ' 1 XC title ,ar members " s show l See B10 See A9 See Al2 �, Owner&Neighbor Dr.Robert B.Pamplin,Jr. L k 0 R • Pamplin MedlaGroup Wednesday, November 10, 2021 • Vol 101, Issue 13 • Building a stronger Lake Oswego through great local journalism • lakeoswegoreview.com • $1.00 NEWS IS CHANGING RAPIDLY I For breaking stories, COVID-19 news and the latest headlines, visit pamplinmedia.com Steering committee selects 2022 Lake Oswego Reads novel The er NATIONAL BESTSELLER PrizCopies of C By CLARA HOWELL draws the American West to book that we are excited to nity relationships and discus- H O W Pamplin Media Group center the lives of siblings bring to our community." sions,among other factors. MUCH The Lake Pam Zhang Lucy and Sam,the children of The 2021-22 Lake Oswego "The Lake Oswego Public y' `� Oswego The Lake Oswego Public Chinese immigrants. Blazing Reads Steering Committee— Library is committed to the Library book to be Library has announced the their own paths out of a child- which is composed of 18 li- freedom to read, and to the THESE announces chosen novel for the 2022 hood torn by prejudice and brarians, teachers, retired values of anti-racism,diversi- the 2022 distributed Lake Oswego Reads pro- loss,Lucy and Sam carry for- professors and students—re- ty, equity and inclusion,"the .T\\s gram. ward their parents'dream to ceived more than 50 book sug- press release read. "As such, Lake Oswego at 2022 NextReads book year, community find home and belonging," gestions to consider. the library seeks to lift up his- r O D "How Much kickoff members participating in the said Library Director Melissa When selecting a book,the torically marginalized voices 16th annual program will read Kelly in a press release. "De- committee evaluates the qual- in our programs,with the goal of These Hills "How Much of These Hills Is spite many heart-wrenching ity of the writing,the opportu- of engaging all community z H A N" rt is Gold"by C event _ Pam Zhang. Gold"by C Pam Zhang. challenges, their strength of nity for events and whether „a ., "Zhang's stunningnovel re- spirit endures.It is apowerful the book strengthens commu- qillic— See READS/Pa a A3 '„» COURTESY gP g PHOTO:AMAZON SETTING THE PACE Lake Oswego school bond No. 10 Lakeridge measure passes earns 28-14 win ` ` ' $180 million bond will update over Grant in first ' . p round of state playoffs *, ��11 schools, add $385 to tax bills Pamplin Media GroupIt , �� � ' By MIA RYDER-MARKS ��; '� " f s Pamplin Media Group o far,so good.S � " After a slow start, the Based on the unofficial Clackamas County et No. 10 Lakeridge High �, . vote count released Thursday,Nov.4,the School football team dou Lake Oswego School Bond Measure 3-577 bled up No.23 Grant High School „ �` .,,) * will pass.The"yes"count leads the"no" by a final score of 28-14 in the $ i • Ilik count 56.9%to 43.1%,according to Oregon first round of the Class 6A state ) Secretary of State and Clackamas County playoffs Friday, Nov. 5. After , . numbers.The total vote count is 14,726. hosting Grant last week, the rt "I'm so grateful that the citizens of LO believe 'Pacers will hit the road this -- $ ; - that schools are an integral part of our commu- week for a second-round match- # nity worth investing in," Courtney Clements, up with Sheldon High School Fri- \' I the leading parent advocate for the 2021 bond, day, Nov. 12, said to the Review. at 7 p.m. Lakers The bond is the second installment of the The Pacers a a three-part funding process for upgrading every roared to vic- WILL school in the district.This year,the school dis- tory in the Lake Oswego _ ti . trict asked voters to approve a$180 million bond second half of defeats New- projected to cost an additional$0.92 per$1,000 of last Friday's berg 49-40 in ` See BOND/Page A3 contest after first round of \ being shutout playoffs.Seems 14-0 in the our story on first half. Se- page B10 " nior running back Jake 4/ . ' A Reichle kicked the scoring off salute with an 18-yard touchdown run, , followed by a 40-yard touchdown A f I pass to tie the game from junior - quarterback Ryan Oliver to ju- COURTESY PHOTO:DAVID BARSS ti service nior wide receiver Joey Olsen. Lakeridge junior Joey Olsen makes a touchdown catch during his team's 28-14 win over Grant in the first round of the Lakeridge took a 21-14 lead on Class 6A state playoffs at Lakeridge High School on Friday,Nov.5. a four-yard touchdown pass from Oliver to Reichle, then 193 yards passing and three ceiver Jace Swygard led the gained the Generals 402-246, Pamplin Media Group tacked on an additional score in touchdowns, while Reichle car- team with four receptions for 77 forcing two turnovers and com- the fourth when Oliver hit junior ried the ball 24 times for 173 yards, while Olsen added four mitting none themselves. honors local veterans wide receiver Baylor Corbin for yards and two touchdowns (one catches for 72 yards and a touch- Check out more of Pamplin a 13-yard touchdown. on the ground and the other down. Media Group's state playoff cov- Oliver finished 13-of-22 with through the air).Junior wide re- As a team the Pacers out- erage on page B12! Pamplin Media Group Lake Oswego resident Robert Windus wishes those with a dim view of the United States military could see through his own Love passes ar s measure ; Unofficial Nov 2 eyes. Windus, who served in Vietnam and other election results say areas around former has 62% yes the world for ��tNAM A SApmeen cityeasure I three de J over competing m I votes, latter 55% cades, shares 7 TE 1 '�NORNGEHO his story and THOSE W SERVD OUR perspective in COUNTRY �._ I By CLARA HOWELL the Love LO Parks Measure 3-568 tive petition to place a measure other parks "acquired by a bond the pages of ' Pamplin Media Group tallied 8,136 votes in favor, or that would amend the city's char- issue after the effective date of Pamplin Me- 0r . , 62%.Though both measures were ter on the November 2021 ballot, this Chapter if (and only if) the dia Group's A While the November ballot technically approved, only the the city decided to present a com- voters specifically designate Salute to Vet- '>`. IL.. l, boasted two competing Lake one with the most votes passed. peting measure. such other park as subject to this erans 2021 iiii"' Oswego park measures that "We're proud our community While both measures had simi- Chapter." special sec- j} claimed to protect and pre- recognizes the value of strong lar intentions of protecting the The charter language said an tion. TT *' serve the city's natural spaces protections to conserve our cher- city's parks, Love LO Parks athletic facility,parking lot,road In honor of o ..ME�.eo..•. ,Ee== and parks,Measure 3-568 put ished natural areas and that we claims its measure protects the or trail for motorized vehicles Veterans Day forth by Love LO Parks—a raised this important issue to the parks in their most natural ele- could not be developed at any of Thursday,Nov.11,we invite you to read a di- grassroots movement led by attention of our community," ment,while the city said the corn- the parks covered by that chapter. verse array of stories from veterans all around Lake Oswego community Scott Handley, LoveLOParks peting measure clarifies some of "The City of Lake Oswego shall the Portland metro area.Our hope is that you'll members to prevent 15 parks grassroots organizer, said in a the wording in the Love LO Parks not cut (or allow any person to come away with a deeper and more nuanced from any future development press release Wednesday,Nov.3. measure that could present fu- cut)any tree in Springbrook Park understanding of what it means to serve this —was approved by voters "This not only is a win for our ture concerns. for the purpose of facilitating the country during times of both war and peace. Tuesday,Nov.2. community, it is a win for the The Love LO Parks Measure construction or development of We thank all veterans for their service and According to the Oregon Secre- abundant wildlife that calls these 3-568 repeals and replaces the any Athletic Facility or any park- sacrifices, and to those within these pages: tary of State's unofficial results, natural habitats home." original Chapter 10 in the char- ing lot, road, or trail for motor- Thank you for sharing your stories. the city's measure turned out After Love LO Parks received ter,which was created in 1978 to —The Review 7,299 votes in favor,or 55%,while enough signatures on an initia- preserve Springbrook Park or See PARKS/Page A3 INSIDE Police Log B2 ; Lakers football survives `-,...'ta Editorial/Opinion A6 Obituaries B6 challenge from Newberg /PI,-,, Neighbors B1 Sports B12 , See B12 1 7 12506 00102 2 I RE.,�co�e. a, local news e.5,:,,,.;:__::,-„:,: --12:-‘„ -------moi ...,t„.:1 ...,...,t, Don't miss out on what matters most to you. Get unlimited access for less than $2 per week corruption you didn't Taquietlyrs • Your local paper mailed to you every week. • Weekly newsletter and breaking news alerts. read about Wastes • Unlimited access to the Business Tribune. • Unlimited access to 26 digital newspapers. • Unlimited access to 26 Pamplin newspaper websites. SIGN UP TODAY — www.savinglocalnews.com Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,November 10,2021/Thursday,November 11,2021 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman A3 Who are the heroesBond said Lake Oswego School Readsg Board member John Wallin. The most substantial ef- forts planned for the 2021 bond are complete remodels From Pa e Al • From Page Al of Lake Oswego Junior High and River Grove Elementary assessed value for Lake Os- school — both of which are members and fostering many wego homeowners. Based on around 60 years old. learning opportunities." Oswego. the median home valued at Every other school in the There will be 800 free cop- of Lake $420,000,households will pay district will see infrastruc- ies of the book given away approximately$385 per year. ture, accessibility and safety during the program's drive- This will be the last school improvements such as secure thru kickoff event at 10 a.m. City seeks ingful impacts in Lake Oswego The application will ask for bond within the plan to in- entrances,and more inclusive Feb.28 in the library parking and nominate them for the the details of the individual dude a tax rate increase,An- playgrounds on a primary lot located at 706 Fourth St. nominations for city's Unsung Heroes Award and a statement of qualifica- thony Vandenberg,executive level. Both high schools will While the LO Reads events by Friday,Nov.12. tions. People are eligible for director of project manage- also receive updated science, typically take place in Febru- volunteerism and "As part of this effort, our the award if they are not a city ment for the Lake Oswego engineering and computer ary,activities will be in April Unsung Heroes Award has ex- employee or elected city offi- School District,said in an ear- laboratories to adapt more ef- of next year. those outstanding panded to include the short- cial, performed their service Her interview with the Re- ficiently with the changing Nancy Niland,the library's term, extraordinary efforts of within the city or surrounding view. curriculum. volunteer and special events during pandemic community members, who area,have largely flown under The bond will tackle both "It's amazing to have this coordinator, told Pamplin stepped up throughout this un- the radar for their services and basic capital repairs and dras- community come together for Media Group there were a By CLARA HOWELL precedented crisis in an ongo- have not been paid for the con- tic overturns of outdated fa- things that matter to them, few reasons for this transi- Pamplin Media Group ing fight against COVID-19," tribution. cilities. and education has always tion. Along with tight press the city's website read. "Nor- For more information and "It's very gratifying that been such a priority. They deadlines during the holi- The deadline to nominate mally we recognize long-term questions, contact Diana our community understands stood up as a community dur- days,Niland wanted to move an Unsung Hero in Lake Os- volunteerism,but as witnessed Smith-Bouwer at 503-635-0257. that education is important. ing the pandemic and said activities to give space for wego is around the corner. around the globe,an enormous To nominate an individual, They know that our buildings 'Yes, this matters.' I'm so increased programming for Community members are number of people became first fill out the online at ci.oswego. are a reflection of that and an proud of everyone,"said Lake Black History Month and Lu- encouraged to spotlight indi- time volunteers in a huge im- or.us/publicaffairs/unsung-he- opportunity to give the best Oswego School District Super- nar New Year, which both viduals who have made mean- pactful way!" roes. education to our students," intendent Jennifer Schiele. happen in February.Another reason for the shift was the pattern of bad weather that's typically seen in February, which Niland said affects programming. Parrs promote a healthy ecosystem. adopt and implement master serve. The City of Lake Os- logue into action, improving She added that novel is The city shall also manage plans for each of these natural wego shall be allowed to im- upon it,and working together "lyrical and poetic while ad- Natural Areas in a way that areas." plement(or allow any person on the multitude of communi- dressing the harsh land- protects their scenic and aes- Citizens behind the Love to implement) a park master ty topics framing our city life scape." • From Page Al thetic qualities and provides LO Parks measure said it plan for a Nature Preserve with unity and a neighborly "These characters and access to nature for the pub- would not prevent restoration that was adopted before(date respect,"Buck said in a press their stories will live inside ized vehicles," the charter lie,consistent with their envi- work or the city from main- initiative is ratified)." release sent by the city."Even the reader long after they read. ronmental values and ecologi- taining the parks. The problem, according to if at times we disagree, we finish the book,"Niland said. The Love LO Parks initia- cal function." "The City of Lake Oswego the city, is the future impact can all find truth in the sin- "Even while reading, I was tive expands those limitations The city's amended charter shall be allowed to maintain this charter amendment could cere love we share for the imagining event program- to cover 14 additional parks would have prohibited sever- (or allow any person to main- have. The citizen's initiative community and our shared ming ideas that will once and natural areas — Bryant al actions at the parks,includ- tain) a Nature Preserve for would prohibit the addition of desire to continue to make the again address history that Woods Park, Canal Acres, ing construction of athletic the purposes of ecological res- paved pathways but would community an exceptional has been missing from our Cooks Butte,Glenmorrie Gre- facilities,commercial logging, toration that provides a safe support crushed gravel sur- place to live,work and play." collective education. I think enway, Cornell Natural Area, the addition of new public and healthy natural area that faces. But there were con- The Love LO Parks mea- April will be a month of pro- Hallinan Woods, Iron Moun- streets or roads and the in- is accessible for public enjoy- trasting views on whether sure also includes a require- found discovery and appre- tain Park, Kerr Open Space, stallation of telecommunica- ment,provides a healthy hab- crushed gravel provided suf- ment of voter approval for ciation for Chinese immi- Lamont Springs Natural Area, tions facilities. Activities al- itat for wildlife, eliminates ficient accessibility. park projects that are outside grants in the U.S." River Run, Southshore Natu- lowed by the city's proposed invasive species,restores na- "Aside from the trail, it's the parameters laid out in the Events will include speak- ral Area, Springbrook Park, charter language included tive species and mitigates fire the notion of providing access amended charter. The city ers, art and online displays, Stevens Meadows, Waluga various maintenance,renova- hazards," the Love LO Parks through parking for the mo- has said this would be costly culminating in an author talk Park-West and Woodmont tion, stewardship and mitiga- charter amendment read. bility-challenged and others and more time-consuming with Zhang at 7 p.m.Apri129 Nature Park — and develop- tion efforts. "The City of Lake Oswego when appropriate given the than the master planning pro- at Lakeridge High School. ment will be limited to only There was back and forth shall be allowed to maintain specific, local conditions," cess that is currently in place. Tickets will be limited and what is necessary for the en- between the two entities as to (or allow any person to main- Lake Oswego Mayor Joe Buck "We're thankful for every will go on sale in March. joyment of the natural spaces. what that language would al- tain) any existing facility or told Pamplin Media Group in volunteer, donor and petition "One of the wonderful The initiative also allows low and would not allow. existing structure, or any ex- a prior interview. "These are signer who made Measure things about Lake Oswego room for the addition of other The city claimed the Love isting parking lot, road or prime examples of the unin- 3-568 a reality,"Handley said. Reads—apart from the ter- natural spaces to be included LO Parks measure could af- trail for motorized vehicles in tended consequences that "Everyone involved with rific and thought-provoking in the charter as they appear. feet restoration activities, a Nature Preserve construct- come from applying blanket Love LO Parks should be programs and events — is The city's Measure 3-575 renovation and replacement ed before (date initiative is rules to a wide variety of proud of their participation in how memorable so many of would have also amended of existing facilities — like ratified)that is above ground parks and conditions." this significant accomplish- these books have been,"said Chapter 10 of the city charter water storage or utility infra- as long as that facility or After viewing the election ment to give our community retired Library Director Bill to state that"the City of Lake structure — in the listed ar- structure,or parking lot,road results,Buck expressed grati- this choice and the protection Baars in the press release. Oswego shall manage the eas. It could also affect the or trail for motorized vehicles tude toward Love LO Parks for of our parks." For more information,visit Natural Areas to preserve city's ability to provide ADA is not altered in any manner raising the issue of protecting The city will eventually the city's website. and enhance the biological, access and address parking that would further impair or the city's natural spaces. share more information on For questions, contact hydrological, ecological and needs for visitors as well as be inconsistent with the natu- "Now, we must commit to the charter amendment pro- Nancy Niland at 503-675-2538 environmental functions and "the ability to develop,revise, ral conditions of a Nature Pre- continuing to put that dia- cess. or NNiland@ci.oswego.or.us. i v -,/ 1 '1 li 9 it, . /--,,: r, A Off A HARN I SH PROPERTIES Justin Hamish Kristi Harnish Errol Bradley Bruce Winkler Tricia Jenkins Principal Broker/ Principal Broker/ Broker/ Broker/Listing Licensed Office Partner Partner Customer Coordinator Coordinator Relations Local Real Estate Expertise LEVERAGE i rn h r i m GLOBAL PARTNERS h a s p open es co on a Global Scale MOUNTAIN AND RIVER VIEWS OPEN HOUSE SAT-SUN 1-3 _y, .. \'' ON.‘' I - V.'-0 \ 9y . y _ .. 0 _ .. t _ I rim— i __\* 21 i.dr" . r ��~ f `` `1_ -`ice • , j'M� _ s 'z r`�.�' yj �.'x+���a :._` `1�,"' 4 V f ter_ i � y $ qrt ' i � t t i gr`� j-;�_ 11 Lem• . :,cN14", \ • ZIP t il ir ' ,.- g}��.- 7- . 1AL r 1 FIBRIN 11 ' l Ifif4 ` ...-/ - ,�- ; ''i`,� - g a. .:r 1`;''� , _ ,.., l'', �—'1 40 Jo"k _ • L �lr,�iLi .II rin .._ a •- "1�-. ,c` - - - - I�� V .i _ {! it A t 1R SKYLAND DRIVE 3,100,000 TUALATIN ST 650,000 Welcome to Lake Oswego's castle in the sky! Stellar views and privacy. First time on Opportunity awaits at this well-loved ranch.Great room floor plan with ideal separa- market.Entertainers dream home with game room,200 bottle wine cellar,pool,multi- tion between living and sleeping spaces.Deeded rights for lake access to 3 easements,& ple wrap around decks,&much more.Sweeping views of Mt.Hood,Mt.St Helens,Mt. the Lake Grove swim park.Feeds into the highly-coveted LO School District!Minutes Adams,&the Willamette River.Living room features vaulted ceilings&gas fireplace. from schools,parks,stores,great restaurants,and all the new establishments at Mercato Spacious primary suite on main. Grove!A Must buy! 4,871 SQFT 14 Bedrooms 13.1 Bathrooms 1,491 SQFT 13 Bedrooms 12.1 Bathrooms HARNISH PROPERTIES Pacific Residential Mortgage, LLC 201 B Avenue, Suite 101, Lake Oswego Blake Rice NMLS-135765 harnish@harnishproperties.com 1503.699.8483 Sr. Mortgage Advisor www.harnishproperties.com PACIFIC 4949 Meadows Road Suite 150 RESIDENTIAL Lake Oswego, OR 97035 kAil.,i MORTGAGE f O (503)699-5626 Office • (503) 260-9564 Cell Licensed in the State of Oregon NMIS-1477EQUALHOUSINGLENDER Opinion Pam diaGplin Meroup A6 • Wednesday, November 10, 2021 /Thursday, November 11, 2021 build b k 0 8 b tt The difficulties of the past egonians united to look out for each investments have all been informed is the most important part of our jobs Committee on Education—state Sen. year and a half are far other,and we continue to.Despite by individuals who know their as legislators. Michael Dembrow—as well as teach reaching.When COVID-19 misinformation and in the face of ad- neighborhoods,the services most With that in mind,I will be hosting ers and school employees will share hit Oregon and versity,we proved that we needed and what will ensure an eq- a series of town halls to provide a how we can support their work and when the first case was diag- are capable of rallying for a uitable recovery as we come out of venue to hear from educators,par- ensure our students thrive. nosed,it was with an em- Acommon goal—to keep each this truly challenging part of modern ents,health care providers,retail I hope you join me in continuing to ployee at the elementary ,e other safe. history. workers and others on the front follow best practices to protect our ~ school my children attended. ,F Additionally,challenges The Legislature also took action to lines.I want to know what worked public health.I look forward to my It felt close to home for all 'j. regularly faced by Oregon's keep Oregonians housed,expand un- and what didn't.What's changed and COVID-19 booster shot and will wear of us,and especially mem- residents as well as weak- employment assistance,support vul- how we address critical needs in our my mask wherever and whenever bers of our community. nesses in our systems were nerable Oregonians and provide re- new reality.Where do we go from prudent. I chaired our local school made bare.Housing insecu- sources to small businesses. here? More to come on the communities board at the time,and like 111 l r �� rity,joblessness,technology We built on our work to prevent, On Nov.9,I was joined by state and industries we'll be hearing from. many institutions we made a gaps and access to support mitigate and respond to wildfires, Sen.Kate Lieber,nurses,firefighters Please visit my website,Oregon series of tough decisions to services were chief among and passed additional environmental and long-term care workers to learn Legislature.Gov/Wagner for details do all we could to protect the Rob Wagner them.So,the Oregon Legis- protections. about the challenges and strains on on how to participate. public health and wellbeing lature took action to make I'm proud of what we've accom- our health care system. We must make certain all commu- of our kids,our households and our progress toward addressing those plished thus far,and I know we have On Dec.1,we'll hear from state nities share in Oregon's recovery entire state. needs. more work to do. Sen.Kayse Jama and workers about and have an equitable shot at getting Early 2020 was marked by fear, Over the course of official meet- As we did before,the Legislature how to best support those who have ahead.I look forward to hearing from and that fear hasn't quite left all of ings and legislative sessions,we put will rally to meet Oregon's greatest been disproportionately impacted by you. us.Impressively,it was also marked the bipartisan CARES Act and the needs.Our previous investments and these incredibly tough months.We by hope,and confidence that we will American Rescue Plan Act dollars policy changes were shaped by indi- must ensure economic justice,wage Rob Wagner,a Lake Oswego resident,is get to the other side. directly into our communities to viduals and families in Oregon,re- protections and job security. the Oregon Senate majority leader repre- I know we will.That's because Or- meet their own unique needs.These minding us of how hearing from you On Dec.13,the chair of the Senate senting District 19. Federalu etREADERS'LETTERS Vote for parks is our LoveLOParks grass- I have always found the teers were portrayed. coucould iiIip act Our historic moment roots citizen-led effort over staff and volunteers to be Springbrook Park, for ex- the last 24 months that very responsive and re- ample, would be an ivy- With the passage of the made this possible! spectful.We all care deeply choked mess if not for the / citizens' Measure 3-568, Nov. 2, 2021 will forever about the health and acces- leadership of the Friends of ci ren S ea Lake Oswego voters have be a historic moment for our sibility of our city parks. Springbrook Park. Iron chosen to leave an everlast- community. I became very concerned Mountain Park would not be A ing legacy of wilderness to Scott Handley when the backers of Ballot as healthy or accessible as it future generations. Lake Oswego Measure 3-568 started mak- is today if not for the hard mericans should not up to five years as part of its pro They have chosen to help ing false accusations about work of the Friends of Iron have to choose between posed Medicaid 1115 waiver.With in the global fight against A reCiation Or the intentions of the Parks Mountain group. their jobs and their 42%of Oregon kids on the Oregon climate change by protect- pp f Department and the city to Have there been prob- health. Health Plan,the state is propos ing nature from develop- parks Staff, allow development in our lems and missteps?Yes.But They shouldn't have to worry ing this expansion because it has ment. natural areas. Staff were they have been worked out whether a few hours of overtime the potential to improve health They have chosen a lega- volunteers made out to have nefarious through public involvement will keep them out of a safety net outcomes for Oregonians for cy that conserves our natu- intentions, just itching to and the collaboration of all program intended to keep them years to come. ral habitats for the abun- To the Parks and Recre- sell off park lands. If you involved. healthy.And that goes double for The benefits of such a program dant wildlife that call them ation Department staff and look at recent history, the Thank you to the Parks the parents of children. have been clearly measured.Chil- home and for future resi- volunteers, department has purchased Department staff and the But a twisted set of dren living in our state and dents to enjoy aJLtheir I have volunteered in the land to save it from develop- hundreds of park volun- bureaucratic rules actu- others with 12-month con- splendor. LO Parks for most of the 24 ers and expand the park teers! We can pass all the ally punishes parents tinuous eligibility are less A heartfelt thank you to years I have lived in LO.I've system.It has also expand- initiatives we want but our for working harder by likely to be uninsured and all Lake Oswego voters who pulled ivy, planted new ed existing natural areas in parks and natural areas taking away health care y' to have a gap in coverage cast their ballots in this No- plants,removed debris after collaboration with park would be nowhere without for their children.Right in the previous year. vember's special election windstorms, and helped friends groups. these people. now,Congress has the Twenty-four states have and every volunteer,donor plan and lead the preschool I'm even more concerned Sara McKean opportunity to fix that '` adopted 12-month continu- and supporter involved in walks in Springbrook Park. about how long-time volun- Lake Oswego problem and create in- ` ous eligibility for children centives and opportuniI�� in Medicaid,plus 26 of 35 ties for working Ameri separate CHIP programs. cans. In the remaining states Medicaid doesn't op- Eric C. without such policies,chil- Solidarity • • erate like other forms of Hunter dren frequently lose cover- wl BIPOC usinesses health insurance.Every age between annual re- year,millions of people newals,for a variety of enroll in Medicaid and are re- reasons. to • mod buse of coll- alth care and stCan ea prospentyOr amerul only to and of MedicaidI can'tll arod a reapplystand by and sectless chil- This bureaucratic merry-go- dren lose coverage when there is round is called Medicaid churn, such an easy fix. eing an entrepreneur as a Na- ty,but we were not going to allow that expensive or most experienced bidders, and it can happen for a multitude Early in the COVID-19 pandem- five American is not only an to happen. which disadvantages BIPOC vendors of reasons.Coverage can be inter- ic,Congress passed the Families investment in myself and my Together,we founded the Communi- and contractors. rupted by minor fluctuations in First Coronavirus Response Act, family.It's an investment in ty Chamber Coalition,formalizing part- We still have more work to do,and income,a move to another area, which requires all states receiv- my community and a form of nerships that had existed be- everyone—individuals,business own- failure to submit periodic reports, ing enhanced Medicaid funding to resistance. s fore the pandemic.But COV- ers and elected leaders alike—can or missing a renewal deadline by provide continuous Medicaid cov- Ownership—whether it's ID-19 gave us a new charge:to playa role in bolstering historically un- a day or two. erage to all enrollees.As a result, of our own narratives,cul- advocate for funding and poli- derserved businesses and in turn,their If a parent works a few extra eligibility churn in Medicaid has tures,land or labor—is a 1 cy frameworks that could help communities. hours of overtime,their children been brought to a temporary halt, powerful way to determine insulate our BIPOC-owned Each of us can examine our family's can lose health coverage.If a par- providing security to tens of mil- our own futures,based on businesses from the economic purchasing power and recognize that 712 ent gets paid irregularly because lions of people. principles that are sacred and impacts of the pandemic and where we spend our dollars represents they work in the"gig economy," One of the 117th Congress's authentic to us. generate the conditions and our values.We can uplift communities their children can lose health cov- first acts this year was to allow Since starting my own con- nyn.IEw resources our businesses and and businesses that have been inten- erage. states to provide continuous Med- suiting business,my goal has 11��'l1��r� communities need to thrive tionally left out of opportunities for Fixing Medicaid churn would icaid and CHIP coverage to all been to support small busi- over the long term. lending,investment and procurement. have positive effects on both our pregnant and postpartum individ- nesses,tribal organizations Lames Parker The Community Chamber By doing so,we uphold our neighbors' public finances and our public uals,under the American Rescue and nonprofits with organiza- Coalition includes the Oregon right to exist and prosper. health.Research shows that con- Plan Act. tional solutions that empower them to Native American Chamber,Philippine Infusing equity into economic devel- tinuous eligibility policies are But more needs to be done.If focus on achieving their own vision for American Chamber of Commerce, opment is not something that can be cost-effective and significantly passed,the House budget recon- the future. Black American Chamber of Com- accomplished in a single legislative ses- improve the continuity of chil- ciliation package would eliminate Through my own experiences and merce and Hispanic Metropolitan sion or funding cycle.We will continue dren's enrollment in Medicaid. churn for kids by requiring 12 conversations with small-business own- Chamber.Together with allies like to engage government leaders in a con- Monthly per-person costs de- months of continuous eligibility ers in my role as executive director of Business for a Better Portland,we have versation about improving procure- crease over time;the longer the for children on Medicaid and the Oregon Native American Chamber, advocated for access to economic re- ment practices,expanding access to coverage,the greater the savings. CHIP. I am acutely aware of the challenges covery resources and a more equitable economic development resources,and Under Medicaid,the average This measure must be included facing BIPOC business owners,includ- approach to economic development in addressing challenges that limit access monthly cost for a child enrolled in the final budget package that is ing limited access to capital,difficulty our region. to economic opportunity such as low for 12 months was$107,compared send to President Biden. accessing technical assistance and ex- In our first two years,we've made wages,unaffordable housing costs and to$163 for a child enrolled for on- The vote on budget reconcilia- clusionary procurement processes. significant progress: growing inequality.None of this chang- ly one month and$147 for a child tion is the most consequential At the onset of the pandemic,my fel- •We helped secure$32 million in es until our approach to economic de- enrolled for only six months. health care vote since the Afford- low small-business owners,entrepre- state and federal funds for emergency velopment shifts to become more equi- States with continuous eligibility able Care Act was saved by a sin- neurs of color,and community leader- assistance that helped Oregon small table and inclusive. policies have fewer administra- gle vote in the Senate in 2017. ship knew we needed to support one businesses survive the pandemic. Widespread economic success relies tive costs—because there is less A child can't have continuous another in solidarity.Not only did we •We won passage of legislation that on cultivating an ecosystem of small need to repeatedly review eligibil- access to health care without con- anticipate the public health crisis expands access to capital for under- businesses that provide our commun- ity,terminate children and then tinuous eligibility for their par- would impact our communities dispro- served businesses. ties with essential services,job oppor- re-enroll them—and increased ents'insurance.Private insurance portionately,we also knew we would •We are building support for the tunities and self-determination.We preventive care,which in turn re- and Medicare don't work this suffer the brunt of the economic fallout, Center for Social Entrepreneurship,a know that if we increase investment in duces expensive acute and emer- way.Medicaid shouldn't either. as well. campus and community grounded in BIPOC-owned,local businesses,the gency care. Congress should fix this discrep- We had lived through the crash of equity and designed to call forward en- economic benefits will reach everyone Our state is fortunate.Thanks ancy once and for all. 2008 and saw how businesses led by trepreneurs of color in all aspects of in our region. to Oregon's good decision-mak- Black,Indigenous and People of Color business development. ing,our state has provided 12 Eric C.Hunter is president and chief could fall through the cracks of the fed- ■And we continue to advocate for James Parker is an entrepreneur,executive months of continuous eligibility executive officer of CareOregon,the eral and state response.The decima- government agencies to approach pro- director of the Oregon Native American for children for years and is con- largest provider of Oregon Health Plan tion of Native American-owned busi- curement with equity at the forefront Chamber and co-chair of the Community sidering expanding eligibility for services. nesses in this state was a real possibili- —rather than favoring only the least Chamber Coalition. ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING - Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 17 • New bill ; Schools Dark , pushesa-_ . ' dealing with ; Horse ' ' • ''`back « �. --7-- --_,, _,...1‘.- tolling = __ substitute Comics r . plans - lett shortage sold ' _ See Page A4 - ; See Page A7 ; See Page A9 2 d, t Owner&Neighbor Dr.Robert B.Pamplin,Jr. Lake0swegoReview Pamplin MedlaGroup Wednesday,January 12, 2022 • Vol 101, Issue 22 • Building a stronger Lake Oswego through great local journalism • lakeoswegoreview.com • $1.00 NEWS IS CHANGING RAPIDLY I For breaking stories, COVID-19 news and the latest headlines, visit pamplinmedia.com man w o i e i• wi a avoi• s rison ime Michael Winchester killing of his wife,who had verdict Friday afternoon. The ing the trial. "A jury of his peers has re- bleeding from self-inflicted been diagnosed with termi- verdict was first reported by "It's a very sad case," Kim viewed the evidence and deter- wounds. found guilty but for nal cancer. The Oregonian/Oregonlive. said."There wasn't going to be mined that to be the case,and When police arrived, they insanity' in 2019 lulling Michael Winchester, an in- Kim told Pamplin Media a happy ending,but this is an we respect their decision,"he found the box cutter lying next to surance adjuster from Lake Os- Group the Oregon State Hospi- appropriate ending to the case." said in an email to The Orego- Annie's body and Michael in the By HOLLY BARTHOLOMEW wego, killed his wife, Hei- tal may need to evaluate Win- Clackamas County Deputy nian/OregonLive that was also garage,in need of medical care. Pamplin Media Group di Anne Winchester,with a box chester. District Attorney Matt Semritc shared with PMG. Winchester reportedly con- cutter knife before turning the The hospital had previously said Winchester's depression at According to Lake Oswego fessed to the crime,telling po- A Clackamas County jury blade on himself in January evaluated Winchester and Kim the time he killed his wife raised Police,Heidi Anne Winchester, lice"I did it,I killed her.She had has found a Lake Oswego 2019. said he believed the hospital questions about whether he who went by Annie,was found cancer.She's dead upstairs." man guilty of manslaughter Winchester's attorney Benja- would determine he would not was able to understand the na- dead by their then 18-year-old except for insanity in the 2019 min Kim confirmed the jury's need to be hospitalized follow- ture of his conduct. son. Michael was discovered See VERDICT/Page A3 { K Lake� - Oswego � F Unin� erg a 4�. - Y� ;gip �aR - h a A . r- schools not haltin j� .fi ,� ,consequences?...z _4,-, - r, ._, . ,. � .. „..,„ . , .--- .,..., . �. ___._ . .,:--„,. . ..,... _4.e.„..____- -- . ,___,.• _ _ _ �_.... ...... - � , �- �, ' i extracurriculars .--.. —r,`eF.s ,••,_. SS . -*g 0. -1- j - r' LOSD will tweak .g .4.,. ...., ,. ,,,,,,...,.., L ., tion and Oregon Health Au- z thority released a school ie- athletic protocols health advisory recommend _ ingdistricts temporarily t- halt extracurricular activi- ��. sl for competitions w. : sr C'�..' - amid omicron surge ties or implement additional a' ,� y s- .);_'_;(i. * qa, a* . ' �t safety measures that are ;� 3� .:y1- `'4' 12 ;1 ,ii� ' its , '� •f - 7- _ By MIA RYDER-MARKS practiced during the school •, )` -- -- At• -'i ' . 1_a" 7 - 1 : P 1 ' $7g.. ,� C Pamplin Media Group day like social distancing ,J � t �y� -� ' . and face coverings. ,�y- - ..�^I �, a" < ;341- f1./. 4 .". ,• '!Pf� �,yt�'7 i� •til t f� f��`�.y�� ,4.i I- g �+� s Arc',.: E `+r z, '� s =: t � �'� r ` ••�+a.s Following new guidance LOSD announced slight "_ ,--. 7-,,,-,?-,:,-.,--_,;,,;:-...-,. ``%x- � i. a'-�-'=: -"? i from the state regarding changes to athletic competi- r ? 1 �� x"^�', ,, '�, :„ `+ '-.Ai -, { ` � � extracurricular activities tion protocols that went into x>.,r , ,, '• ,,, i- - 0., :r •, . ,': ate. : M. � 7. and the spread of COV- effect Jan. 5. Athletes com- ,,'r w"f !, .x ; , .- ', u- r , . 4'_ . . , ID 19,the Lake Oswego peting in games hosted in rr,. ., -- 1 ',,_ r w fix ;- `''sd i.'!�.' r .,---,."---i`w School District updated its school's gymnasiums will be ` s •� °J5 b , R +v�ca 17. 'i y ' a '.a..� rtdaRi�.' ,Y�, � '`" '' �•= �'+r- safety protocols for ongo allotted four tickets for spec , _,,,,,,...,. .,__,..:. , . ,i.,..,1,„s� � .... %,...:€ r4 t 45, * r n* ,t� 1,r fi-, a ing athletic competitions. �� -7- ``: 1 ."s .. s . ' �, ' t....,zek,:s4;,:., �+ On Monday,Jan.3,the Ora : k � �` "�' •N. y * � ' egon Department of Educa See SCHOOLS/Page A3 PMG FILE PHOTO Crews work on a project at Woodmont Natural Park in 2020.A ballot measure passed in November created new restrictions on development at city parks. "" • Claiming voters were 'duped,' City Council considers tweaks to parks ballot measure - -c By COREY BUCHANAN Measure 3-575 in the November to agree that munity. You are hurting our = ,., - - ,.-- , Pamplin Media Group election, prompted the repeal Measure 3-568 ability to protect people and Ir._ s , and replacement of city charter included flawsit our kids," Rapf said at the s u �' ; During a work session on language covering develop- that needed fix- meeting. -- l ,r ; r , )k - -- Jan.4,the Lake Oswego City ment at local parks.While both ing, Lake Os- - , "I'm not politicking here ... er '1. Council considered formulat- measures had similar inten- w e g o City ' • but these are problems.When '. " 1 ' - ` ing a new ballot measure to tions of protecting the city's Councilor Aar- - we were voting most of the vot t ' correct some unintended parks, Love LO Parks claimed on Rapf was ers did not know those these 1 I t, consequences of a charter its measure would protect the p art i c u 1 a r 1 y I - things were going to be prob- ilamendment designed to pre- parks in their most natural ele- empathic in his RAPF lems," Councilor Massene �- m 1 vent development at 15 parks ment, while the city said the denunciation. Mboup added. and natural areas. competing measure clarified "If you voted for this,shame The approved measure disal- % _ Measure 3-568,which was put some of the wording in the Love on you. Do your homework. lows the cutting down of trees forth by the citizen-led group LO Parks measure that could Don't listen to people who are to build athletic facilities,park- Love LO Parks and ultimately present future concerns. loud on the internet and Next- PMG FILE PHOTO defeated the city's competing While all councilors seemed door.You are hurting the corn- Lake Oswego won't halt extracurriculars at its schools,but some See MEASURE/Page A3 protocols were changed amid the omicron surge. A 6 d fen • ng, n • TAIL residents along for a change in policy. Sheriff's Office Marine Unit deafening noise,"Arthur wrote Mike Arthur and his neigh- had gauged it at over 80 deci- in an email to the Bolton Neigh- river say they're fed up bors said the loud revving from bels)is that its driver stays in borhood Association. "Even if om et ski a two-stroke engine jet ski at one spot,revving his engine to two-stroke motor boats were to with noise Meldrum Bar Park (in Glad- flip the jet ski over and over generate a similar amount of stone across the river from the again. noise as the PWC (personal By HOLLY BARTHOLOMEW Bolton neighborhood) can be Other jet skiers and boaters watercraft or jet skis),their en- Pamplin Media Group heard for several hours nearly create noise,but typically don't gines are submerged in water, every day of the week from overburden one area with and most importantly, they Tired of the noise from a spring until late fall. ceaseless noise, according to just pass through creating a ..: competition-grade jet ski on They described the noise as Arthur. nuisance for seconds." -, ".} the Willamette River,and "someone starting a chainsaw" Arthur said the jet skier Two-stroke jet skis are Ilk, met by local law enforce- over and over. stays in the same spot practic- banned from many waterways yx. ` '" - i ment who say they cannot While not opposed to people ing flips due to the need to re- in the United States because of enforce the noise ordinances enjoying the river on paddle- fuel the jet ski at his truck and the excessive pollution they .::. - - of West Linn,Gladstone and boards, kayaks,boats or even trailer every five to 10 minutes. emit.They have not been wide -,, 3 '�'� 4, ,, �,. . Clackamas County,a hand- normal jet skis,Arthur said the "Because he's doing flips,his ly manufactured since 2006, -i _:. : ' :-. 2". --:- ,_ t _ - y ful of Bolton neighborhood problem with this particularly revved engine is above the wa- when the Environmental Pro- PMG FILE PHOTO residents have pushed the loud jet ski(he said the Marine ter, not below it, amplifying A jet skier rides on the Willamette River in 2006. Oregon State Marine Board Board and Clackamas County and sling-shotting an already See NOISE/Page A3 INSIDE Police Log B4 ; Cremona named MVP of Editorial/Opinion As Obituaries 61 state water polo tourney - , a' Neighbors B1 Sports B12 ; •►�° See 612 7 12506 00102 2 ATTENTION LOCAL BUSINESSES! PamplinMediaGroup ONE DAY - Wednesday, January 12th ONLY - GA o Our biggest advertising sale of the year. r, ITa� , If you're looking to grow your business now is the time to take advantage of d our massively discounted rates on print and digital advertising. •: IS BAC mall 503= 54-0360 to tallto your Pamplin sales represen Pamplin Media Group • Wednesday,Janum 12,2022/Thursday,January 13,2022 Clackamas Review • Lake Oswego Review • Oregon City News West Linn Tidings • Wilsonville Spokesman A3 by citizens via a vote. tower used for emergency corn- were to be instances of vandal- easureCity of Lake Oswego Parks "If you voted for this, munications at Cooks Butte ism.Anderholm explained after verdict derholm said that the approved andRecreationDirectorIvanAn Shame on you. DO your "got away from" the city and the meeting that the city can y y that being able to maintain in- install security cameras, but ■ From Page Al charter amendment restricts the homework. Don't listen to frastructure is critical. That only ones that do not have an • From Page Al g replacement of telecommunica- people who are loud on controversy was one of the internet connection(unless the tions infrastructure,and whether the Internet and driving factors that led to the connection had already been es- Winchester reportedly left a inglots,roads or trails for mo- or not the replacement of utilities ballot measure. tablished). note for his sons,in which he said tor vehicles, and ensures that is allowed is open to legal inter- Nextdoor.You are The leader of the Love LO "This has real consequences he could not bear to watch their development is limited only to pretation.He added that remov- ,, Parks group,Scott Handley,al- for our community and I guess mother suffer anymore. what is necessary for the enjoy- ing and replacing a reservoir like hurting the community so led a petition against the in- •(the)big •picture•is,I would like •Winchester was treated at Ore- ment of natural spaces on 235 the one at Cooks Butte would not —Aaron Rapf, stallation of the communica- to be an efficient and safety- gon Health&Sciences University acres worth of land at Bryant be permitted under the measure, Lake Oswego city councilor tions tower at Cooks Butte.Af- oriented city,"Wendland said. hospital before his arrest.He was Woods Park, Canal Acres, but they could fix it if it needed ter the Save Cooks Butte group "And we can correct anything if eventually released from police Cooks Butte, Glenmorrie Gre- repair. gathered about 900 signatures we want to put it on the ballot custody in June 2019 on$250,000 enway, Cornell Natural Area, "We're not able to change it be allowed on these properties. for the petition in November for any of these parks,but the bail,shortly before his son's gradu- Hallinan Woods,Iron Mountain in a way that would further im- Rapf described the telecom- 2019,the Emery family—who citizens need to know that costs ation from Lakeridge High School Park,Kerr Open Space,Lamont pair it or be inconsistent with munications issue as an unin- sold the property to the city in time and effort and education." In May 2019,ahead of his re- Springs Natural Area, River the natural conditions,"Ander- tended consequence, citing the 1975—withdrew its consent for For his part,Councilor Daniel lease,Clackamas County Circuit Run,Southshore Natural Area, holm said. recent security incident at Lake the city to build the tower. Nguyen said having an election Court deemed that Winchester Springbrook Park, Stevens The parks director added Oswego High School and the im- Newly-appointed Council during a pandemic when people was highly likely to prevail Meadows, Waluga Park-West that the measure would mean portance of communication tech- President John Wendland grad- aren't able to engage in person based on a defense of extreme and Woodmont Nature Park. two existing projects—adding nology in such an emergency. ed the failed city measure as an may have led to misunderstand- emotional disturbance due to his The failed city measure includ- parking on Childs Road at the "For those of you who voted "A"and the grassroots measure ings. wife's terminal cancer. ed similar restrictions but used lower portion of Stevens Mead- for this, you were duped and a`B,"and said the city now has Buck indicated that the City The emotional disturbance de- the word"new"instead of"any" ows and the rerouting of a path- lied to about the unintended the opportunity to reflect and Council would discuss the issue fense can lower a murder charge in terms of the disallowed de- way through Hallinan Woods consequences of what this does determine issues that need to further at the council retreat in to first-degree manslaughter, velopment,and the citizen mea- —would have to be tabled. for the city.It puts lives in dan- be corrected. One thing he's February and emphasized that which carries a lesser sentence. sure stated that any projects However,the construction of ger,"Rapf said. concerned about is the difficulty community engagement would A memo prepared by Kim in outside of the ground rules set trails for hiking, picnic tables Mayor Joe Buck said the de- for the city to install security be important in any future mea- defense of his bail release also forth would need to be approved and sanitary facilities will still bate over a telecommunications cameras in the parks if there sure. suggested that both Michael and Annie Winchester had undiag- nosed mental disorders. "The defense anticipates that National Association of State through Jan.5 and is expected the evidence will show that every Noise Boating Law Administrators. to decide on the proposal at its Schools that the state will likely expe- person who spoke to Ms. Win The stricter limits in other meeting Jan.26. rience a significant uptick in chester heard Ms. Winchester states mean that people with "We're aware that a handful positive COVID-19 cases, be- speak of the severity of herphysi- two-stroke jet skis and other of operators are causing these ginning in January and con- cal and emotional pain,her desire • From Page Al noisy watercraft travel to Ore- issues," Mulhollem said. • From Page Al tinning through February. to die and her wish that she could gon where their crafts don't "We've had extensive commu- "As Oregon fully experi- join her loved ones in heaven," tection Agency updated its fuel violate state rules. nication with local law enforce- tators. No other audience ences the impacts of the Omi- Kim wrote in the memo. "The efficiency standard. However, When Arthur and his neigh- ment on ways to address this members, including pep cron variant over the next people who knew Ms.Winchester some manufacturers still offer bors first complained to local and at least at this point, the bands, will be permitted in- several weeks,student access were also aware of undiagnosed two-stroke jet skis,billing them officials about the noise from activities generating all these side the gymnasiums. How- to in-person instruction is un- psychological issues, including "for competition only." the jet ski,they learned the lo- complaints and this animosity ever, games will be live der serious threat,"the agen- the behavior consistent with a Nowadays, Arthur said jet cal jurisdictions were unable to are within the law." streamed. cies said in the advisory. manic-depressive disorder." skis with four-stroke engines enforce their own noise ordi- Mulhollem said he was un- Concessions will be sus- "While early data indicate Kim argued that Michael Win- are much more common be- nances on the river because the sure what actions the board pended. that the Omicron variant may chester was depressed, noting cause they are quieter,cleaner Willamette is a state waterway. would take at the Jan.26 meet- For swim meets in the result in less severe disease that he was hospitalized two and more fuel efficient than the "Because the state rule does ing,but added it was possible LOSD pools, only home team than previous variants, it is months before killing Annie af- two-stroke. not currently have a narrative to accept the petition but not senior athletes will be allotted increasingly clear that the ter experiencing migraines, According to the California standard as it pertains to noise, use the proposed rule changes two tickets for spectators. Omicron variant spreads slurred speech and the inability Division of Boating and Water- the narrative standard of the it outlines.The board could al- The meets will be live much more quickly and easily to sleep or complete tasks he ways, the two-stroke engine city/county cannot be en- so accept the changes as pro- streamed. than all previous variants." used to easily perform. does not burn all its fuel and forced," Arthur wrote in his posed or deny the petition alto- No spectators will be per- In the joint statement, the "Although undiagnosed at the emits 25%to 30%of its fuel into email."The result is,local law gether.Another option for the mitted at the upcoming cheer agencies warned districts time,Mr.Winchester was likely the water and air. enforcement is getting bom- board would be to simply en- and dance competitions host- that extracurricular activities suffering from a major depres- To address the issue,Arthur barded with noise complaints, courage better behavior from ed in LOSD facilities. pose a large risk for the"rap- sive disorder,"Kim wrote. "On and others in the Bolton neigh- and even though the com- recreationists on the water. "LOSD will continue to id transmission of COVID-19 Jan.30,2019,Mr.Winchester not borhood have partnered with plaints are violating local city If the board adopts the monitor and evaluate proto- that will prevent students only caused the death of Heidi local attorney Bert Krages to (and) county laws, police are changes but the problem still cols for its school-sponsored from participating in in-per- Winchester, but also made re- ask the marine board to lower unable to act due to the state persists, Arthur said they extracurricular activities ev- son learning." The use of di- peated and credible attempts to the sound level limit on Oregon rules." would push for an all-out ban ery two weeks. Some events agnostic testing,vaccinations commit suicide." waterways from 84 decibels to In November,Krages sent a on two-stroke jet skis. that can be postponed,such as and boosters was also recom- The judge granted Win- 75 decibels and to add a"narra- petition to the marine board, "Changing state law(with a high school dances and per- mended if group activities chester's release on bail despite tive standard"to the rule. asking the body to consider the two-stroke jet ski ban) could forming arts events,are being continued. objections from District Attorney The narrative standard rule changes.A separate com- take a while,and our communi- rescheduled for later this win- The OHA and ODE urged John Foote,who argued he was a would take into account the munity-based petition Arthur ties need relief soon," the on- ter,"said Superintendent Jen- school districts to partner potential danger to the public. context(location,duration and and his neighbors have circu- line petition read. "This is one nifer Schiele in a letter to the with health care providers to In October 2020 the court or- type of noise) of someone pos- lated online includes a video reason why the current pro- community last week. offer vaccine clinics and en- dered Winchester to report to sibly violating the noise limits. depicting the noise nuisance posal with the Marine Board is The state advisory is intend- courage eligible students to the Oregon State Hospital for an Other states, including created from the jet ski and has an option to take care of many ed to lift after Jan.31,but may get their shots. evaluation in which the hospital Washington, have adopted over 240 signatures. of the public nuisance prob- be updated or extended. Cur- would determine whether he had 75-decibel sound limits based The board accepted public lems,without being too restric- rent data from Oregon Health Courtney Vaughn contributed a qualifying mental disorder at on a recommendation from the comments on the petition tive on responsible operators." and Science University shows reporting to this article. the time of the killing. ell r, A1 , HARN I SH ' s A - .I PROPERTIES Justin Hamish Kristi Harnish Errol Bradley Bruce Winkler Tricia Jenkins Principal Broker/ Principal Broker/ Broker/ Broker/Listing Licensed Office Partner Partner Customer Coordinator Coordinator Relations Local Real Estate Expertise LEVERAGE i rn h r i m GLOBAL PARTNERS h a s p open es co on a Global Scale FIRST ADDITION IN LAKE OSWEGO PRIMARY ON MAIN JO`O�P�Q6 9•GSFq`O pQ��P����� ¢ ; g4 t`0 4'OF Q ' r ' r / - t - K 'fill _ .. L `?i y�rr g Ell \ a ate... /+C• ✓� .„ P sal - • Ik. e s3 1'� fir `Y Y_ 3 • y . i.C I I't l h ;l�".1f , ��l A P' , -- __,------------r. s. .' II1F4 1.11)'' ! V -'-- _ k_1,,‘_,_ A —1 It 1,??.. , n _ ,,,r,''' ,.„..:-„,,, 4TH ST. $1,499,000 IRON MOUNTAIN $1,495,000 Modern Brownstones in Lake Oswego's First Addition.6 luxury townhomes in the Here's your chance to add your personal touches on a classic cottage charmer in heart of downtown Lake Oswego.3 bedrooms,4 full and 1 half bath with detached the heart of the LO Country Club district!Main level offers the primary bedroom, studio/office space over the garages.All 6 units are "elevator ready".Views of the office,two full bathrooms &more. The upper level is home to 4 guest bedrooms, park,Mt Hood and an easterly territorial outlook with a modern vibe.Spectacular 2 full baths, and potential 2nd laundry. Located on a corner lot minutes from construction by an award winning Street of Dreams builder. downtown LO,the OLCC,and the highly coveted Lake Oswego Schools. 3,186 SQFT 13 Bedrooms 14.1 Bathrooms 3,378 SQFT 15 Bedrooms 14 Bathrooms HARNISH PROPERTIES Pacific Residential Mortgage, LLC 201 B Avenue, Suite 101, Lake Oswego N Blake Rice NMLS-135765 �. harnish@harnishproperties.com 1503.699.8483 Sr. Mortgage Advisor www.harnishproperties.com PACIFIC 4949 Meadows Road Suite 150 RESIDENTIAL Lake Oswego, OR 97035 kA,i f O MORTGAGE Licensed in the State of Oregon NMIS.1477EQUALHOUSINGLENDER 503-699-5626 Office• 503-260-9564 Cell Exhibit 18 Opinion Pam dlaGplin Meroup A6 • Wednesday, January 19, 2022/Thursday,January 20, 2022 - _ The face on •emnin council's of war words to voters MYVIEW session on Measure 3-568 where proved it.It's disappointing out and met with several City the Director of Parks&Recre City Council continues with aligned community members LoveLOParks ation,Ivan Anderholm,ex- these disingenuous and decep- who routinely dismissed our ef- plained the City's legal interpre- tive tactics." forts and falsely claimed we ' Steearrived home the other day to find a lone photo- ring Committee tation on allowed and prohibit- Brad Home:"Being a mem- were uncooperative.Not once graph on my kitchen counter.Who's this,I asked ed development activities for 15 ber of this community that has in two years did Mayor Buck, my husband."I don't know,"he replied.I studied oveLOParks Steering natural parks.In an about-turn protected Cooks Butte 3 times City Councilors,or City staff it.The photo was of a young man with a pro Committee issues state- to Mayor Buck's public concilia- from increasingly larger tele- accept our offer to discuss and nounced crew-cut standing almost at attention,even ments condemning tory statements on election communication facilities over work toward common ground. though the background showed a sandy beach and a JLake Oswego City night,Mayor Buck and City nearly 30 years,it's disturbing Their recent actions are yet an- relaxed atmosphere,with children playing and a fish- Council's rebuke of Lake Oswe- Councilors expressed contempt that Lake Oswego City Council other example of them going erman casting his line. go voters for ratifying citizen- toward the Lake Oswego com- fails to respect the wishes of against the will of our commu- It turns out my husband found the picture at the initiated Measure 3-568 and munity and discussed forward- the Emery family who be- nity.Instead of defiance,City bottom of a paper sack that had been brought up from their consideration to under- ing another referendum to vot- stowed Cooks Butte as a nature Council should make this an the basement.Now you have to understand that any- mine voters with another refer- ers—continuing their cam- preserve to Lake Oswego citi- opportunity to finally begin lis- thing found in our basement is a candidate for carbon endum. paign tactics characterized by zens.From the beginning,we tening more closely to all con- dating,so I was stymied.As I studied his face,though, Measure 3-568 was the result opacity,obfuscation,revisionist campaigned on the prohibition stituents." a memory suddenly surfaced. of Lake Oswego residents orga- history,and disinformation. of public and private telecom- Michael Louaillier:"We ex- Many eons ago,and before nizing,informing and commu- In response,the LoveLO- munication facilities as one of pect the Lake Oswego City I was married,I spent some nicating with transparency, Parks Steering Committee has the limitations.It's time for the Council to respect the will of 11. time on my own in Laguna honesty and integrity on devel- issued the following state- City Council to respect the peo- the community and the funda- Beach,California.The Viet- nam— War was being fought, 15 designated natural parks. Kirsten Sommer:"Lake Os- Betsy Wosko:"We orga think they owe our community and there were young men When City Council chose to wego City Council's narrative nized and executed a TWO- a big apology." newly returned from the con compete against the citizens' about`unintended consequent year transparent,fact based LoveLOParks remains com- flict and stationed in nearby measure,LoveLOParks encour- es'is a desperate attempt to re- campaign to inform and edu mitted to overseeing the pro- San Diego.As I walked the aged our community to com- tain control by invoking doubt cate the Lake Oswego commu- tection of our natural parks as &YE R beach one day,I met an off- pare and contrast the legal and fear.Measure 3-568's devel- nity on these development limi- an independent citizens'over- t h& duty marine whose name has since faded into memory.He strength of both measures'full opment limitations are precise, tations.For Councilor Rapf to sight to ensure the City of Lake texts to make an informed vote. deliberate and intentional to say voters were"duped"and Oswego upholds the provisions NCE was a big guy,shy and polite, In the November 2,2021 Spe- ensure the City obtains voter stupid is offensive,grossly in- of Measure 3-568. with a somewhat tense de- cial Election,Measure 3-568 approval before natural habi- accurate,and a Trump-like,an- meanor.We spent the after- was ratified by 8,267 Lake Os- tats are destroyed.The prohibi- ti-democratic and incendiary LoveLOParks is a Lake Oswego Kay Cora Jewett noon walking on the sand and wego voters,or 62%,thereby tion of telecommunications fa- response to a valid election re- grassroots citizen coalition&over- talking about the war.When enacting legal safeguards limit- cilities and parking lots are in- suit.It's time to put politics sight for City Charter Chapter X- the sun went down,we ing development in 15 Lake Os- tended protections and not un- aside and unify our community Park Development Limitation that agreed to meet the next morning. wego natural parks keeping intended consequences.It's the toward the common goal of pre- was enacted by voters to apply legal In the harsh light of the new day,I saw the face of them safe,accessible,healthy strength of these protections serving these natural habitats." safeguards limiting development in what can only be described as an agitated and fright- and vibrant natural habitats. that Sierra Club and Oregon Scott Handley:"Lake Oswe- 15 natural parks to keep them safe, ened young man.The term Post Traumatic Stress Syn- On January 4,2022,Lake Os- Wild endorsed Measure 3-568 go City Council's comments are accessible,healthy,and vibrant nat- drome hadn't come into usage,but that is most likely wego City Council held a study and the majority of voters ap- unequivocally false.We sought ural habitats what he had.As we walked along,it seemed he was al- ways looking back at his shadow,as if it were gaining on him,and he was unable to shake it.As I stood fac- ing him on the beach,I thought of my brother,who at that time was off flying Cobra helicopters in Vietnam. I wondered(feared)that he might have this same ra- zor-edged,haunted personality when he returned.Oo I s. City recognizes lill of voters As mid-day arrived,we decided to fmd a place to eat. We emerged from the beach and discovered we needed to cross a multi-lane roadway to fmd a restaurant.We n November 2021,the elec- ments in the enhancement and Selecting yes or no on a ballot portant we sit with the results were about half way across when there was suddenly a tors of Lake Oswego preservation of natural areas does not properly reflect the of the Charter amendment be- very loud explosion,which felt like it came from right passed Measure 3-568.This and by the passage of Measure spectrum of beliefs and per- fore any potential future con- under our feet!My response was to jump and cry out. Measure amends our City 3-568 itself. spectives we hold as residents. sideration.It is also a distinct My companion's was to scream and hit the ground roll- Charter to provide additional While Measure 3-568 is not Those dynamics only coalesce possibility no future consider- ing.He ended up in a fetal position with his arms protections to without critics,the fact re- through dialogue,understand- ation will prove necessary. crossed over his head.What we had just experienced natural areas mains the voters spoke.Our ing and open care.My hope,as Therefore,given the impor- wasn't a bomb,but a car loudly backfiring just beside throughout the collective ability to have our always,is that we see issues tance of the passage of this us.I have since thought that it might as well have been City.Protect- voices heard through our vote before us through the neigh- measure and the voices of its a bomb,given the damage it did.No,we weren't hurt, ing our natural is of paramount importance to borly lens,thinking of broad supporters,I will not bring for- but my soldier-friend was thoroughly traumatized and area parks and - the functioning of our demo- community benefits over indi- ward to the Council agenda seemed unable to recover.It was clear that he reacted the overall en- cratic system.I value each vidual impacts. any consideration of changes as he did because of his experiences in dodging the real hancement of person who participated in the The City Council recently or modification to the charter thing. the ecosystem a' i process.Many residents gave studied potential impacts from amendment in the year to We never went to the restaurant.Despite my reas- is a top priority their time,energy and talent the Charter change brought come. surances,he was mortified that I had witnessed his re- for our City— min Ew to advocate for what they about by Measure 3-568.Con- Let us move our energies sponse.The last I saw of him,he was walking away as evidenced 11��11�� wholeheartedly felt was in the cerns of our ability to maintain, forward in partnership to con- from me with his head down and his hands in his pock- by our Climate best interest of the communi- repair or replace critical infra- tinue making Lake Oswego ets.He never said goodbye and I never saw him again, Action Plan, Joe Buck ty.We are neighbors,not ene- structure or safety issues are even better tomorrow than it is at least until his picture appeared on my kitchen coun- the number of mies and our community dy- undoubtedly important to ev- today. ter.I didn't know him very well,and as I said,cannot residents engaged in communi- namic is not as polarized or ery resident.Yet,it will take remember his name.But I have never truly forgotten ty-based environmental advo- disparate as the process of time to fully understand what Joe Buck is the mayor of Lake Os- him.He showed me the face of war. cacy groups,our City invest- elections tends to engender. the true impacts are.It is im- wego. Kay Cora Jewett can be reached at k.kayusa@frontier.com. READERS'LETTERS Council should who was duped when casting votes for City ed two-year effort by Lake Oswego residents. To the members Council members who don't understand the It garnered 62%of the vote over the City's respect will of voters basic of how democracy works.It's enough 3-575. of our City Council the national stage is a mess.Let's hold our lo- Please stop using shaming,the negative mo- Unintended Consequences.A rebuttal.As cal representatives accountable for what they tivator of fear,gaslighting and our own tax- I didn't vote yes on the citizen sponsored reported on the front page of the LO Review say and do. payer dollars against us.Another City mea- initiative that protects our nature parks so on January 12,the City Council considers Matthias Beckmann sure on 4%of our land is a further waste of that you,the city council could"tweak"it. tweaks to the ballot measure designed to pre- Lake Oswego taxpayer dollars and an affront to our demo- Letting you tweak is like giving away the vent development at 15 parks and natural ar- cratic institutions.Instead use creative and keys to the tool shed where the chain saws eas.Fact is that a citizen-led initiative was Res pea the vote and collaborative sustainable solutions on the oth- are hanging.Respect the voice of the people. voted in by a majority of LO voters.After p er 96%of land.Council has higher priorities. Your city council referendum was hand- enough signatures were collected,and once it attend to more pressing issues Rosemary DiCandilo somely defeated by citizens who could see it was clear that this initiative would be on the Lake Oswego for what it was—a sham.Take the$10,000 November ballot,the City Council quickly put Lake Oswego City Council must respect the donated to your campaign by Renaissance together their own version in the hope of will of the voters who approved the citizen-ini Homes and use it to help buy up even more eclipsing it that way.The City Council's ini- tiated Measure 3-568 in November 2021.Less Council, citizens land so that we might expand the footprint tiative got defeated by a strong majority. than three months have passed since the elec- Now,the City Council wants to change the tion.Yet Council is already contemplating an- need to work together of our natural areas in this time of irrevers- will of the voters after the fact.However you other ballot measure to subvert voters'will ible and catastrophic climate change. feel about the initiatives,the fact that City and continuing to promote disinformation. I am dismayed by the LO City Council's Instead of trying to subvert the will of the Council members have the audacity to claim Despite the City's lack of transparency(the comments that voters were"duped"and stu people,"tweak"the tree and development "voters were duped,"saying things like"if City's proposed 3-575 City charter language pid to vote for Measure 3-568 which won by a codes instead,so that they clearly state that you voted for this,shame on you"should give was never clearly published on any platform), large measure and required years of citizen ell builders and developers are free to build you serious pause.What kind of democracy City control of both measures'titles and de- fort to bring to a vote a measure to keep our whatever they want.They can just no Ton- do these City Council members favor?Why scriptions in the Clackamas County Voter's parks as natural as possible.It is offensive and ger cut trees down to do it!Period. not just talk about a"rigged election?"Maybe Pamphlet,and the absence of objective report- inaccurate and perpetuates the ongoing politi- Our world now is really on fire.To help City Council could do away with these pesky ing and advertising,voters and objective third cization of local politics which I find very dis- save our planet,you must put an end to democratic antics like elections altogether parties still discerned that Measure 3-568 best tasteful.Can we please come together in a business as usual and act.Lead.We have and install themselves as benevolent des- protects the remaining 4%of natural park fruitful and sensitive way to work on this? such little time! pots?I am sure we'd save some money in the land.Voters were well-informed on Measure Kathy Hanavan Pierre Zubrinsky process.Those statements make me wonder 3-568,a well-researched and strongly support- Lake Oswego Lake Oswego ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING — Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 19 Opinion firedfalGroup A6 • Wednesday, January 26, 2022/Thursday,January 21, 2022 Ittik btF th•li d i t I he time has come to talk used to replace bridges and oth- the existing downtown urban re- The focus in the new district Downtown Lake Oswego and about redevelopment of er infrastructure in our city.An newal district is shut down. should be on building"up"in the Lake Grove did not happen by the north end of the additional approximately$4.9 When a new urban renewal Foothills commercial and light in- accident.They are among the i Foothills area...the land million will go to schools and district is formed,all increases in dustrial area.With Lake Oswego economic engines of our city that - between State Street and the other governments.A success property taxes within the district standards,it comes down to spe- draw locals and visitors alike to =-4- - Willamette River and north of story compared to what might must be used in the new district, cifics-what specific infrastruc- enjoy eating,shopping,working, the Oswego Pointe apartments. have been. i.e.,they cannot be spent on other ture projects are needed.How living and playing.It took sus- Unless we want the city to grow More importantly,the city can government purposes. The in- much will each cost?How many tained,decades long work and out into the Stafford triangle, initiate its next multi-decade crease in tax revenues from the can be done?How will it be paid commitments to make our city �,�Y■I�� then we must grow up in the plan...the redevelopment of the district does not represent a new for?Yes,to community engage- what it is today.We enjoy a l�ll Y north end of the Foothills area. north end of the Foothills area. tax,but rather a reallocation of a ment,design,clear,objective and quality of life because of these By possibly 2027,the East End The Foothills Plan adopted by a portion of existing property tax- specific standards and swift pro- commitments.It is easier,much Jeff Gudman urban renewal district will have previous city council is already es.A new Foothills urban renew- cessing of development projects easier,to visualize the future largely completed its 40 years in place.It needs some tweaking, al district covering a similar area that meet those standards. than to get there.That Foothills journey.The district can be shut but the core projects in the to the current district could gen- Work is proceeding nicely on vision work has been largely do- down having fulfilled its mission North blocks,primarily infra- erate an initial tax increment of the replacement Tryon Creek ne.Let us begin the hard work of revitalizing downtown.It can be structure,have been identified. about$250,000 a year.The wastewater treatment plant in modification,execution and im- easily argued the benefits,fiscal There is no need to reinvent the $250,000 increment,which in- the Foothills light industrial area. plementation.The time is now to and otherwise have outweighed plan.Fifteen infrastructure proj- creases by 3%each year,can be While the treatment plant project continue the multi decade pro- the costs of this multi-decade ef- ects were identified.There is a used to pay for the needed infra- stands on its own,it is integral to cess with Foothills light industri- fort.Shutting down the district need to begin the community structure improvements in the the future success of redevelop- al and commercial area. "frees up"approximately$2.3 work now to tweak the plan and new Foothills district.Schools ment.It is part of providing a million dollars a year which over prepare a new urban renewal and other services lose out on first-rate infrastructure so a first- Jeff Gudman is a former member of the next two decades can be district to go into effect the day their share of the increase. rate quality of life can follow. the Lake Oswego City Council. Voters weren t I UESS PEOPLE DON'T G E LP WANT TO WORK... NO'- 'duped' on ANTED W EXACTLY EX L ... Q WE OFFER= parks measure ---7 - LOW PAY ��►� - NO BENEFITS c---i s a long time resident of Lake Oswego I was ' offended and angry regarding the commentsA �/ 4----; made by Councilor Rapf regarding the pas- Q P I sa ge of Measure 3-568 in the recent election. / 1 1 P U NOW ----__,4,/ He indicated those who low voted for this measure ^!� should be ashamed and MYVIEW they were hurting theN7 P ability to protect people and our kids.In his Virginia Bodent ilijill;" I ( -------- words the people were I P P ',do- duped. U �j� I have been involved (rs in the development of the Rassekh Park along Stafford OMIKE RJ(AS I/2.Q122 Road and I have to say I find that the city has done its fair share of duping. This park was presented as multiple ball fields,six READERS'LETTERS 60-foot lights with artificial turf.The driving force of this park has been those who make a living with orga- nized sports.When the people in the neighborhoods , �� i l ; were finally asked for input overwhelmingly they want- For Congress, elect someone I I' I prI, 1, ,11. �i h`k i, �., _ 7,T it �, W si L ed a natural,family oriented park.I attended many of with our interests at heart ' s ' I i , l , t l ea !o ' the community meetings and every person presented I " *<'� I ,,:it' t 1 ,�;, concerns about the size of the park,the extremely poor Kurt Schrader has a dubious working I ',I ='r �' f t ' r� 'e V` v. and dangerous access off an already overtaxed round relationship with his fellow Democrats ,i _ •- .t, about,the noise and additional traffic in the small ad- on issues related to healthcare. , _ � u F � t t � � joining neighborhoods and the lack of a quality play He has been a co-sponsor on reducing I r . structure and covered picnic tables.We were told the regulatory government involvement on I r _ =.o' - .;!=7,k-'.. ,. ' or covered tables and play structures were very expen- issues related to our health eliminating ' . ';�V `j �"' s= •- 6 ,. ,,. , �� Volunteers sive and probably not in the budget.I attended the safeguards already in place.When the , ,��, Council Meeting proposing the inclusion of the land in- issue is related to health perils such as I r � 5„ = K helped clean to the urban boundary.The city's own planning board lead poisoning or cancer-causing chemi- I �: a _ ' . ' ,,,, and plant -* .' s - - - -b ' seedlings at recommended against indicating more issues needed to cals,Schrader sides with industry and ,'. , > be studied.Several residents spoke against and yet the not with the health and well-being of his ,,y `� N�_ �-tr ;.. •Springbrook council voted to include the property,paving the way constituents in Oregon's District 5. I - r `� .-, ' , Park this for the park.The design has now been submitted to the As a senior and cancer survivor I am I - `j .' A' . .:'` f• s : past City's Planning Department for land use review. angry that he did not support negotiat- ' r� � `4 - : , ; - weekend. And just as an additional bonus to the residents the ing lower drug prices for Medicare. z+ 'tA _ * -� " COURTESY @, ,„- ' PHOTO:PAUL funds have been found to design and add a 10,000 sq ft We have an alternative in Jamie I , t' 0, LYONS skate park to the"natural park."I understand com- McLeod-Skinner who is one of us.As our I pletely why the Love LO Parks was forced to do what representative she will make sure our ' First volunteer work partyin Springbrook Park they did by getting a vote of the people.The City has voices are heard and not the ones from completely ignored the residents concerns of safety and Corporate PACS,such as big pharma. , Saturday morning was a successful work party.A group from Riverwest keeping the area natural.And now the City Council is Jamie is a bridge-builder and she is a I Church moved lots of gravel to repair trails.Other volunteers and our board going to try and override the vote of the people to longtime advocate of healthcare for all. I members planted 200 cedar and fir seedlings to restore an area.So grateful for change the charter amendment. Let's elect someone who actually has ' the dedication of Lake Oswego residents.Thanks to Laura Tanz for organizing So much for community involvement. our interests at heart. ; the work party and buying the trees.A great way to start our new year. Pamela Berg I Paul Lyons Virginia Boden is a Lake Oswego resident. Lake Oswego I Springbrook Park Board member Nick Krcan't have it both ways practiced election law required by the Oregon sufficient and superior to the concerns resident for the three-year period. that New York was his permanent in Oregon for 25 years. MYVIEW Constitution—that is,to raised by Fagan. Kristof voted in the November 2020 home to which he always intended to In my view,Nick have been an Oregon resi The former columnist has now filed election in New York.He voted there return,not his Yamhill farm. Kristof is not qualified Richard Botteri dent since November 2019. a petition in the Oregon Supreme as a registered New York voter.He To rule in Kristofs favor,the Ore to run for Oregon gover- During the critical peri- Court asking it to order Fagan to in- was not registered in Oregon. gon Supreme Court must hold he nor. od,Kristof has lived and elude his name on the 2022 Democratic New York's election statute defines could maintain two mutually contra- Kristof,former national worked in New York and Party primary ballot. residence for voting purposes:"The dictory intentions as to his principal columnist for the New York Times, voted there.He did not vote in Ore- There is no controlling law in Ore- term`residence'shall be deemed to home in 2020. owns a family farm in Yamhill County, gon. gon specifically defining when a per- mean'that place where a person Kristof could only have one princi- Oregon,where he now resides.He has Yet,he claims he has been an Ore- son is deemed to be an Oregon resi- maintains a fixed,permanent and pal home in 2020.If he maintained his filed to run for the Democratic Party's gon resident for the required period dent to meet a residency requirement principal home and to which,wherev- Yamhill farm to have been his perma- nomination for governor on the 2022 because he has owned the Yamhill for election to a public office.There er temporarily located,always intends nent and principal home in 2020,he primary ballot. property for more than three years, was an Oregon trial court ruling in a to return."' should have voted in Oregon and not Secretary of State Shemia Fagan, improved it,has returned there to re- candidate residency case that"the How could Kristof validly vote in in New York.Though he has now Oregon's chief elections officer,had side several times,paid taxes on it, question of domicile is largely one of New York unless he felt his residence made Oregon his permanent home, rejected Kristofs filing,asserting he and has always considered the proper- intent."This case will not save Kristof, in New York was his permanent and his residence change has come too can not qualify to be elected governor ty to be his residence to which he because New York's law defining resi- principal home and where he always late. in the 2022 general election,for his would return.He claims that his inten- dency for voting purposes raises an intended to return,at least in 2020? failure to be a resident of Oregon for tion always to return to the Yamhill insurmountable obstacle to his validly Regardless of what he is saying Richard Botteri is a Raleigh Hills resident three years prior to such election as farm as his permanent residence is declaring his intent to be an Oregon now,he expressed his intent in 2020 and retired attorney. ClackamasReview OregonCityNews Pamplin MediaGroup LakeOswegoReview WilsonvilleSpokesman WestLinn[idingc CIRCULATION 503-620-9797 CLASSIFIEDS 503-620-SELL (7355) LEGAL/PUBLIC NOTICE 503-799-3274 NEWS OR ADVERTISING — Visit our Contact Us page online at www.pamplinmedia.com This is the combined newspaper of the Clackamas Review,Estacada News, POSTMASTER:Please send address changes to:Pamplin Media Group,P.O. Estacada News-Publication No.UPS 080-790 ISSN 0889-2369 Lake Oswego Review,Oregon City News,West Linn Tidings and Wilson- Box 22109,Portland,OR,97269.503-620-9797. Lake Oswego Review-Publication No.UPS 302-540 ISSN 0889-2369 ville Spokesman. The paper is published weekly by the Pamplin Media West Linn Tidings-Publication No.UPS 302-540ISSN 0889-2369 Group,400 Second Street,Lake Oswego,OR 97034.Periodical postage paid SUBSCRIBE:Rates vary by newspaper.For subscription information and Wilsonville Spokesman-Publication No.UPS 021-752 ISSN 0889-2369 at Lake Oswego,OR 97034 and additional mailing offices. service call 503-620-9797 or go online to www.savinglocalnews.com. Exhibit 20 EXHIBIT E-4 /� Name of Document For Recording:Covenant to (For County Recording Use Only) j� Construct and Connect to City Sewer Line Clackamas County Official Records *ZQ22_Q11231 Grantor:Hail Capital LLC.,i/o David Nelsen,3115 Sherry Hall, County Clerk Wembley Park Road Lake Oswego OR 97034 Grantee:City of k Oswego,OR 970La e Oswego, P.O. Box 369, Lake I HIM I IIIIIII liii I I IIIII III IIIII II I I I $1 28.00 Consideration:$0.00. 02543743202200112310080089 Tax Statement to be mailed to: No Change 02/23/2022 02:20:40 PM Recordation Authority:ORS 205.130(2)(a). D-OD Cnt=1 Stn=9 COUNTERI After Recording,Return To:City of Lake Oswego, $40.00$16.00$62.00$10.00 Attn:City Recorder, P.O. Box 369, Lake Oswego,OR 97034 Covenant to Construct and Connect to City Sewer Line WHEREAS,the undersigned Hail Capital LLC("Owner")warrant(s)to the City of Lake Oswego (City)that Owner is the fee title or contract purchaser of real property in Clackamas County, Oregon, outside the corporate limits of the City of Lake Oswego, but inside the City's Urban Service Boundary, described as follows("Subject Property" or"Subject Properties"): Legal Description: A tract of land located within the southwest quarter of Section 7,Township 2 South, Range 1 East of the Willamette Meridian,City of Lake Oswego, County of Clackamas, Oregon,said tract of land being all of that property conveyed to Hail Capital LLC, an Oregon limited liability company, by Statutory Warranty Deed recorded July 7, 2021 in the Official Records of Clackamas County as Recording No. 2021-065158;said tract of land more particularly described as follows: Lots 1, 2, 69, and 70 of Block 1, Plat of Lake Forest(Plat No. 509), plat records of Clackamas County. Together with a tract of land located within the southwest quarter of Section 7,Township 2 South, Range 1 East of the Willamette Meridian, City of Lake Oswego, County of Clackamas, Oregon, said tract of land being all of that property conveyed to Hail Capital LLC, an Oregon limited liability company, by Statutory Warranty Deed recorded June 30, 2021 in the Official Records of Clackamas County as Recording No. 2021-063293; said tract of land more particularly described as follows: Parcel 2, Partition Plat No. 2007-142, plat records of Clackamas County. Street Address: No Situs address, Lake Oswego Assessor Map/Lot References: Tax Lots 0100, 3000 and 02902, Map 21E07CA WHEREAS,the undersigned Owner applied for annexation of the subject property to the City of Lake Oswego(Planning Dept. Case No. AN 21-0003). WHEREAS,the City's Public Facilities Plan, which is consistent with Statewide Planning Goal 11 (Public Facilities)and the Community Health and Public Safety Chapter of the Comprehensive Plan, requires the development of master plans for the orderly development of streets,sanitary sewer,water, and stormwater facilities, and the basis for long-range planning for both the incorporated and unincorporated lands within Lake Oswego's Urban Services Boundary. WHEREAS,the Lake Oswego Comprehensive Plan Urbanization Policy C-4: "requires that urban services commensurate with the scale of the proposed development are available and are adequate to serve the property or can be made available in a timely manner prior to the annexation of non-island properties." WHEREAS,to comply with the above Policy and with other related polices that are criteria for annexation of the Subject Properties,the Owner represented to the City that it would proceed with construction of public sanitary sewer lines to serve future development on the Subject Properties consistent with the City's Sewer Master Plan and guarantee sewer availability. WHEREAS,following a public hearing,the City Council tentatively approved Ordinance 2874 ("Annexation Ordinance") and directed City staff to return with findings and ordinance for enactment upon recordation of this Covenant to Construct and Connect to City Sewer Line (Exhibit E-3) in the official records of Clackamas County, Oregon. NOW THEREFORE, Owner does hereby covenant to City as follows: 1. Owner shall construct a sewer main, in conformance with the City Engineering Dept.'s standards and specifications from the Point of Connection of the existing City Sewer Main to the upstream boundary of each property for one connection or one home, or in the case of a partition of the Subject Property,then to the upstream boundary of that Subject Property(parent parcel of the partition),to serve each of the respective Subject Properties, as shown on the attached map, Attachment 1.The sewer main shall be installed to the respective Subject Property and accepted by the City prior to issuance of a development permit(including a building permit)for the respective Subject Property. (This obligation to construct does not preclude Owner from seeking a Zone of Benefit under LOC Art. 40.04.) 2. Owner acknowledges that neither the City's condition upon the annexation nor the City's acceptance of this covenant constitutes consent for Owner to install the sewer main in any property owned by or under the jurisdiction of the City. The Owner will need to obtain such City consent in the manner required for such, and the annexation does not obligate the City to so consent. The Owner's obligations under this Covenant shall arise only after the Subject Property has been fully annexed into the City.The completion of the annexation process shall be an express condition precedent to Owner's obligations under this Covenant. 3. Owner acknowledges the risk that events, circumstances, or unknown conditions could arise that would make it more difficult or preclude the extension of the sewer main as intended. Nevertheless,the Owner waives any and all claims or causes of action, legal or equitable,for the issuance of a development permit(including a building permit) absent compliance with the requirement that any development on the respective Subject Property be served by connection to a City sewer main. Specifically,the Owner waives any right to seek approval of an alternative sewage disposal system, including the right to seek exemption from the requirement to connect to the City sewer system. 4. This Covenant may be enforced by the City of Lake Oswego by a proceeding in the Clackamas County Circuit Court under any applicable legal or equity basis, including specific performance and injunction. The City shall be entitled to its reasonable attorney fees if it is the prevailing party, at trial or on appeal. If the City is represented by"in-house" counsel,the City shall nevertheless be entitled to recover reasonable attorney fees based upon the reasonable time incurred and the attorney fee rates and charges reasonably and generally accepted in the metropolitan Portland, Oregon area for the type of legal services performed. 5. Following construction of the sewer main to the upstream boundary of the property a respective Subject Property(as provided in Paragraph 1, above), at the Owner's request and expense,the City shall execute a Notice of Termination of Covenant suitable for recording with the County Clerk,so that upon recordation,the obligation to construct the sewer main to the respective Subject Property, and the agreement that no development permit(including building permit) be issued for the respective Subject Property will be shown as an obligation against the respective Subject Property. 6. This Covenant shall run with the land and shall be recorded in the deed records of the County of Clackamas,to give notice to all successors-in-interest in the Subject Properties and shall be binding on all successors in interest. // [Signature on Next Page] 3 IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the undersigned Owner has hereunto executed this Covenant on the date stated below. GRANTOR Hail Capital LLC,an Oregon limited liability company By. / An •C rti . Da en, .tManager / mot / � z2 Date Signed STATE OF OREGON ss. County of Clackamas ) On this �� S day of , 2022, before me the undersigned Notary Public, personally appeared DAVID NELSEN ❑ personally known to me fg proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence To be the person who executed the within instrument as manager of on b If of Hail Capital, LLC, pursuant to authority,and acknowledged to me the execution her of. OFFICIAL STAMP ) KEVINRY WALTPUBLI C OREGONER LUBY (�I) ary Pu c for Oregon _Z}� N - 1 =P COMMISSIO OTAN NO.1009870 t` y Commission Expires: MY COMMISSION EXPIRES MARCH 07,2025 Exhibit 21 January 11, 2023 APPLICANT ' S STATEMENT APPLICANT: John Gliebe New Look Development 7685 SW Cirrus Drive, #32F Beaverton, OR 97008 OWNER: Hail Capital, LLC 501 4th Street, #974 Lake Oswego, OR 97034 APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE: Danelle Isenhart, AICP Emerio Design 6445 SW Fallbrook Place, Suite 100 Beaverton, Oregon 97008 REQUEST: Minor Development - 2 lot confirmations, 4 serial lot line adjustments and an unavoidable RP crossing for the new sanitary main extension SITE LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Tax Lots 100, 2902, 3000; Tax Map 21E 07CA Waluga Park - West, Baleine Street and Inverurie Road rights-of-way Lake Oswego, Oregon SIZE: —104,099 sq. ft. (TLs 100, 2902, and 3000 only) LAND-USE DISTRICT: R-7.5 (TLs 100, 2902, and 3000) PNA (Waluga Park - West) LOCATION: Vacant lots north & east of 15868 Kimball Street, Waluga Park- West, and Baleine Stree and Inverurie Road rights- of-way Kimball Street Development Page 1 of 38 APPLICABLE REGULATIONS A. Lake Oswego Comprehensive Plan B. Lake Oswego Community Development Code: Chapter 42: Streets and Sidewalks Section 42.03 Street Design Standards Section 42.08 Sidewalks Chapter 50: Community Development Code Section 50.02 Base Zoning Districts Section 50.03 Use Regulations and Conditions Section 50.04 Dimensional Standards Section 50.05 Sensitive Lands Overlay District Section 50.06 Development Standards Section 50.07.007 Flag Lot Requirements Chapter 55: Trees Section 55.02.035 Tree Removal in Conjunction with Major or Minor Development Permit Section 55.02.080 Criteria for Issuance of Type II Tree Cutting Permits Section 55.02.084 Mitigation Required Section 55.08 Tree Protection II. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting approval for 2 lot confirmations, 4 serial lot line adjustments and an unavoidable RP crossing for the new sanitary main extension to serve the development. The parcels are approximately 104,099 sq. ft and are in the R-7.5 zone. Waluga Park - West is part of the project for the sanitary sewer extension and is in the PNA zone. Portions of Baleine Street and Inverurie Road rights-of-way are part of the project for the sanitary main extension. The subject property is identified by the Clackamas County assessor as Tax Lots 100, 2902, and 3000 of Tax Map 21E-07CA. The site is currently vacant. There is a delineated wetland on a portion of the property. This delineation was approved in LU22-0019 (See Exhibit 6). The proposed new single-family detached dwellings will take access from 2 new and adjacent access lanes onto Kimball Street. The abutting properties are all within the R-7.5 zone. Dedication and improvements are not required along the site's Baleine Street or Inverurie Road frontages per the engineering pre-application notes (See Exhibit 3). Kimball Street is a County road. Per Clackamas County a there are no required improvements or dedication along the site's Kimball Street frontage (See Exhibit 11). All necessary utilities (i.e., power, water, etc.) are presently available to the site, except for sanitary sewer, as illustrated on the existing conditions map (Exhibit 4). There are existing water mains in Baleine Street and Kimball Street. All 5 lots are Kimball Street Development Page 2 of 38 proposed to have water meters from the water main in Kimball Street (See Exhibit 4 - Preliminary Site Plan). A sanitary sewer main extension along the site's Kimball Street, Baleine Street and Inverurie Road frontages and through a portion of Waluga Park- West is proposed (See Exhibit 8). This sanitary main extension will provide sewer service to all 5 proposed lots. Sewer laterals for all 5 parcels will be provided. Lots 1-3 will each have a private storm planter for treatment of stormwater for the new dwelling on the respective lot. Lots 4 and 5 will each have private drywells for treatment of stormwater for the new dwelling on the respective lot. A drywell is also proposed on Lot 4 for the stormwater for the access lanes. III. FINDINGS A. LAKE OSWEGO COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMMENT: Except where required by the Lake Oswego Community Development Code, this application is not required to address the city's goals and policies related to the development of land, since the Lake Oswego Comprehensive Plan is implemented by the code. B. LAKE OSWEGO COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE CHAPTER 42: STREETS AND SIDEWALKS 42.03 STREET DESIGN STANDARDS 42.08 SIDEWALKS COMMENT: Dedication and improvements are not required along the site's Baleine Street or Inverurie Road frontages per the engineering pre-application notes (See Exhibit 3). Kimball Street is a County road. Per Clackamas County a there are no required improvements or dedication along the site's Kimball Street frontage (See Exhibit 11). Sidewalk is not proposed along any of the abutting street frontages as there are no existing sidewalks or pathways near this site. Baleine and Inverurie Road are both local level streets under the jurisdiction of the City of Lake Oswego. Baleine Street is not improved at all along the site frontage and is not proposed or required to be constructed for this development. Kimball Street is under the jurisdiction of Clackamas County. The County is not requiring sidewalk or any improvements along this frontage. CHAPTER 50: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE 50.02 BASE ZONING DISTRICTS 50.02.001 Residential Districts 1. Residential - Low Density Zones Kimball Street Development Page 3 of 38 a. Districts The residential-low density zone districts are R-15, R-10, and R-7.5. b. Purpose To provide lands for single-family residential development with densities ranging from two to five dwelling units per gross acre. COMMENT: The site (Tax Lots 100, 2902 and 3000) is located in the R-7.5 District. The applicant is proposing 5 lots through a series of lot confirmations and lot line adjustments for single- family residential development. 50.02.003 Special Purpose Districts 3. Park and Natural Area Zone a. Purpose The purposes of the Park and Natural Area (PNA) zone are to: i. Protect, preserve, conserve and enhance natural areas, greenways and parks; ii. Permit a wide range of passive and active recreational uses, and accessory uses, on property for the future use and enjoyment of the City and its residents; iii. Implement Statewide Planning Goal 8, Recreational Needs; and iv. Establish a master plan process for park planning and development. COMMENT: Waluga Park - West is located in the PNA District. The proposed sanitary sewer main extension is going through a portion of the park to connect to an existing main. 50.03 USE REGULATIONS AND CONDITIONS 50.03.002 Use Table COMMENT: The proposed single-family detached dwellings are an allowed use in the R-7.5 District. Public utilities (minor) are an allowed use in the PNA District. 50.04 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS 50.04.001 Dimension Table 1. Residential Low Density Zones a. Dimensional Standards Development in the R-7.5, R-10, and R-15 zones shall conform to the dimensional standards in Table 50.04.001-1 except as modified below. Kimball Street Development Page 4 of 38 Standard Required Proposed Density Minimum 80% of max Not applicable - lot line Maximum (2) adjustments Minimum Lot Dimensions Each lot line adjustment with Area (sq. ft.) 7,500 sf dimensions are noted below. Width (ft.) 50 ft Final lot area and width for Depth (ft.) -- each lot are: Lot 1: 9,607 sq. ft., 83.81 ft. Lot 2: 9,570 sq. ft., 83.26 ft. Lot 3: 44,059 sq. ft., 373.68 ft. Lot 4: 13,592 sq. ft., 97.23 ft. Lot 5: 13,592 sq. ft., 97.22 ft. Max. Floor Area Additional floor area Allowed: allowance per Lot 1: 4,323 sq. ft. Base calc.: 3,000 sq.ft. residential unit Lot 2: 4,316 sq. ft. +[(actual lot size - 5,800 providing a garage (sq. Lot 3: 10,869 sq. ft. sq.ft.)* 0.19] ft.) Lot 4: 4,694 sq. ft. 600 Lot 5: 5,080 sq. ft. Proposed: Specific house plans have not been selected for this development. Yard Setbacks All lots: Front 25 ft. Each lot will meet setbacks Street Side during building permit review. Arterial/collector 20 ft. Lot 4 is a new flag lot and will Local 15 ft. meet flag lot setbacks. Interior Side Total 15', 5 ft. min. Rear 30 ft. Maximum Lot Coverage Based on height of All lots: 50.O4.O01.1.f structure Building plans and height unknown at this time. Lots 4 and 5 are flag lots and will meet flag lot standards. Maximum Base Height All lots: Flat Lot 30 ft. Building plans and height Lot with Sloping 34 ft. (5) unknown at this time. Lots 4 Topography and 5 are flag lots and will Sloped Lot 35 ft. meet flag lot standards. The development includes 4 successive lot line adjustments. Below is an explanation on how each lot confirmation and lot line adjustment step (4) meets required R7.5 lot dimensions. Lot Confirmation 1 and Lot Line Adjustment 1 The lot line confirmed is the property line between Lots 69 and 70 of Lake Forest. This line is then moved (adjusted) to the west. Tract 1 (Lot 1 - final dimensions) is 9,607 sq. ft. in area and is 83.81 feet in width. Tract 1 retains frontage on the Baleine Street ROW and Kimball Street Development Page 5 of 38 Kimball Street. Tract 2 (portions of future Lots 2 and 3) is 22,592 sq. ft. and is 196.57 feet in width. Lot Line Adjustment 2 Lot line adjustment 2 is between Tract 2 of LLA 1 (above) and Tax Lot 2902. This lot line adjustment also creates access and utility easements for the future lots. Tract 1 includes future Lot 2, Lot 4 and a portion of Lot 3 and is 36,217 sq. ft. and is 140.17 feet in width. Tract 2 (Lot 5 - final dimensions) is 13,592 sq. ft. in area and is 97.22 feet in width. This tract is considered an existing flag lot and will have access from an access lane within the shown 20' access and utility easement to the north and within the existing 15' access and utility easement on the property to west and a new 10-foot easement north of the existing easement. Lot Line Adjustment 3 Lot line adjustment 3 is between Tract 1 of lot line adjustment 2 and Tax Lot 100 (Lots 1 and 2 of Lake Forest). Tract 1 includes future Lots 2 and 3 and is 53,629 sq. ft. in area and is 466.78 feet in width. Tract 2 (Lot 4 - final dimensions) is 13,626 sq. ft. and is 97.23 feet in width. Tract 2 is a new flag lot. A parking easement is created with this lot line adjustment for Tract 2, the new flag lot, to meet the required parking standard for flag lots with an access lane. Lot Confirmation 2 and Lot Line Adjustment 4 The line confirmed is the line between Lots 1 and 2 of Lake Forest. This line is then moved (adjusted) to the west to create Lots 2 and 3 in their final dimensions. Tract 1 (Lot 2 - final dimensions) is 9,570 sq. ft. in area and is 83.26 in width. Tract 2 (Lot 3 - final dimensions) is 44,059 sq. ft. in area and is 373.68' in width. g. Height - Additional Standards A greater height than otherwise permitted is allowed for: i. Single-Family Dwellings Base building height may be increased by one ft. for every five additional ft. in yard setback on all sides, beyond the minimum code standards provided in Table 50.04.001-1 above. COMMENT: Specific house plans are unknown at this time. Therefore, the dwellings on Lots 1-3 will be required to meet height standards at the time of building permit. Lots 4 and 5 are flag lots and will meet height standards in the flag lot standards. 50.04.002 Special Street Setbacks COMMENT: Inverurie Road has a special street setback of 20 feet. The only lot that abuts Inverurie Road is proposed Lot 3. Due to the location of the existing wetland, there will be no structure near Inverurie Road and the special street setback will be more than met on this frontage. Kimball Street Development Page 6 of 38 50.05 OVERLAY AND DESIGN DISTRICTS 50.05.010 Sensitive Lands Overlay Districts 2. Applicability This section applies to all lands designated RP or RC on the Sensitive Lands Map, and lands designated HBA where an HBA protection area is established pursuant to LOC 50.05.010(7). a. Sensitive Lands Development Review Required i. Except as provided by subsections 2.b through 2.d of this section, development within: (1)The RP district, as defined in LOC 50.05.010.6.b; COMMENT: The RP district on Tax Lots 100, 2902, and 3000 has been delineated (LU22-0019 - See Exhibit 6). The area of the sewer main extension through Waluga Park - West and in the rights-of-way of Baleine Street and Inverurie Road have not been delineated and fully encumber the subject area. The applicant is not providing a resource delineation and accepts that the subject areas are fully within the RP District overlay. Therefore, the sewer main extension must comply with the RP District development and mitigation standards for the entire disturbance area within Waluga Park - West and the rights-of-way. This is addressed below. 3. Development Review The development review procedures for sensitive lands overlay districts are found in LOC 50.07.004.8. COMMENT: This application follows the review procedures in 50.07.004.8. 4. Generally Applicable Standards for Lands with RP Districts, RC Districts, and HBA Protection Areas d. Construction Standards An owner shall submit a construction plan and narrative to the City Manager prior to any grading, clearing, or construction on a development site which contains an RP or RC district, or where the owner received development review approval under subsection (7) of this section, Habitat Benefit Areas (HBA) Incentives. The construction plan and narrative shall demonstrate that the following standards will be met: i. RC protection areas or RC districts where no protection areas have been approved, RP districts, and protection areas within an approved HBA development shall be protected during construction with either: (1)A minimum four-ft. tall chain link fencing secured with a minimum of four-ft. tall steel posts. The fencing shall be in place and Kimball Street Development Page 7 of 38 maintained for the duration of construction. In addition, temporary signage shall be placed on the fencing which shall clearly identify the resource district and shall state the penalty for violations of this section; or (2)Such alternative method to subsection (4)(d)(i)(1) of this section that is approved by the City Manager to demarcate and protect the RCPA or RC/RP district from the adverse effects of construction activity upon the resources. ii. RC protection boundaries and RP district boundaries, as applicable, shall be located and staked by a qualified professional prior to placement of fencing and other protective measures. iii. Hazardous Materials. The site shall be inventoried for hazardous materials, debris and noxious materials, and these materials shall be removed prior to the development of the site. iv. No construction, demolition, grading, or site clearing shall begin until after protective measures, signs, and erosion control measures are in place and have been inspected and approved by the City Manager and all applicable permits have been issued. Fencing and other protective measures shall not be removed, even temporarily, without the permission of the City Manager. v. No stockpiling of fill materials, or parking or storage of construction equipment shall be allowed within a resource district. vi. When transportation facilities, pathways, utilities, or structures are approved within a delineated RP district, they shall be constructed in such a way that a minimum of excavation is required and so that no permanent draining or filling of a stream corridor or wetland will occur. vii.Surface runoff and other water sources supplying hydrology to an RP district shall be designed and maintained so as not to adversely impact the functions and values of the resource. viii. Any additional construction requirements imposed as conditions of approval or which may be required by the Development Standards, the Lake Oswego Building Code (LOC Chapter 45) or the Erosion Control Code (LOC Chapter 52). COMMENT: The applicant has provided the construction plans for the sewer main extension (See Exhibit 8). The RP District will primarily be protected by tree protection fencing, which is generally 6 feet in height. Additional fencing will be provided as needed to protect the RP District outside of the construction area. Erosion control will be provided along the construction area. The applicant understands that construction, grading, or site clearing cannot begin until after protective measures, signs, and erosion control measures are in place and have been inspected and approved. The proposed sewer main extension is proposed to be constructed by boring within the RP district to minimize excavation so that no permanent draining or filling of the wetland will occur. Spoils from the boring of the sewer main will be taken out of the RP district (off-site). e. Mitigation; Purpose Mitigation is a way of repairing or compensating for adverse impacts to the functions and values of a natural resource caused by a development. Kimball Street Development Page 8 of 38 Exhibit 22 June 22, 2023 APPLICANT ' S STATEMENT APPLICANT: John Gliebe New Look Development 7685 SW Cirrus Drive, #32F Beaverton, OR 97008 OWNER: Hail Capital, LLC 501 4th Street, #974 Lake Oswego, OR 97034 APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE: Danelle Isenhart, AICP Emerio Design 6445 SW Fallbrook Place, Suite 100 Beaverton, Oregon 97008 REQUEST: Minor Development - 2 lot confirmations, 4 serial lot line adjustments and an unavoidable RP crossing for the new sanitary main extension SITE LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Tax Lots 100, 2902, 3000; Tax Map 21E 07CA Waluga Park - West, Baleine Street and Inverurie Road rights-of-way Lake Oswego, Oregon SIZE: —104,099 sq. ft. (TLs 100, 2902, and 3000 only) LAND-USE DISTRICT: R-7.5 (TLs 100, 2902, and 3000) PNA (Waluga Park - West) LOCATION: Vacant lots north & east of 15868 Kimball Street, Waluga Park- West, and Baleine Stree and Inverurie Road rights- of-way Kimball Street Development Page 1 of 38 APPLICABLE REGULATIONS A. Lake Oswego Comprehensive Plan B. Lake Oswego Community Development Code: Chapter 42: Streets and Sidewalks Section 42.03 Street Design Standards Section 42.08 Sidewalks Chapter 50: Community Development Code Section 50.02 Base Zoning Districts Section 50.03 Use Regulations and Conditions Section 50.04 Dimensional Standards Section 50.05 Sensitive Lands Overlay District Section 50.06 Development Standards Section 50.07.007 Flag Lot Requirements Chapter 55: Trees Section 55.02.035 Tree Removal in Conjunction with Major or Minor Development Permit Section 55.02.080 Criteria for Issuance of Type II Tree Cutting Permits Section 55.02.084 Mitigation Required Section 55.08 Tree Protection II. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting approval for 2 lot confirmations, 4 serial lot line adjustments and an unavoidable RP crossing for the new sanitary main extension to serve the development. The parcels are approximately 104,099 sq. ft and are in the R-7.5 zone. Waluga Park - West is part of the project for the sanitary sewer extension and is in the PNA zone. Portions of Baleine Street and Inverurie Road rights-of-way are part of the project for the sanitary main extension. The subject property is identified by the Clackamas County assessor as Tax Lots 100, 2902, and 3000 of Tax Map 21E-07CA. The site is currently vacant. There is a delineated wetland on a portion of the property. This delineation was approved in LU22-0019 (See Exhibit 6). The proposed new single-family detached dwellings will take access from 2 new and adjacent access lanes onto Kimball Street. The abutting properties are all within the R-7.5 zone. Dedication and improvements are not required along the site's Baleine Street or Inverurie Road frontages per the engineering pre-application notes (See Exhibit 3). Kimball Street is a County road. Per Clackamas County a there are no required improvements or dedication along the site's Kimball Street frontage (See Exhibit 11). All necessary utilities (i.e., power, water, etc.) are presently available to the site, except for sanitary sewer, as illustrated on the existing conditions map (Exhibit 4). There are existing water mains in Baleine Street and Kimball Street. All 5 lots are Kimball Street Development Page 2 of 38 proposed to have water meters from the water main in Kimball Street (See Exhibit 4 - Preliminary Site Plan). A sanitary sewer main extension along the site's Kimball Street, Baleine Street and Inverurie Road frontages and through a portion of Waluga Park- West is proposed (See Exhibit 8). This sanitary main extension will provide sewer service to all 5 proposed lots. Sewer laterals for all 5 parcels will be provided. Lots 1-3 will each have a private storm planter for treatment of stormwater for the new dwelling on the respective lot. Lots 4 and 5 will each have private drywells for treatment of stormwater for the new dwelling on the respective lot. A drywell is also proposed on Lot 4 for the stormwater for the access lanes. III. FINDINGS A. LAKE OSWEGO COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMMENT: Except where required by the Lake Oswego Community Development Code, this application is not required to address the city's goals and policies related to the development of land, since the Lake Oswego Comprehensive Plan is implemented by the code. B. LAKE OSWEGO COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE CHAPTER 42: STREETS AND SIDEWALKS 42.03 STREET DESIGN STANDARDS 42.08 SIDEWALKS COMMENT: Dedication and improvements are not required along the site's Baleine Street or Inverurie Road frontages per the engineering pre-application notes (See Exhibit 3). Kimball Street is a County road. Per Clackamas County a there are no required improvements or dedication along the site's Kimball Street frontage (See Exhibit 11). Sidewalk is not proposed along any of the abutting street frontages as there are no existing sidewalks or pathways near this site. Baleine and Inverurie Road are both local level streets under the jurisdiction of the City of Lake Oswego. Baleine Street is not improved at all along the site frontage and is not proposed or required to be constructed for this development. Kimball Street is under the jurisdiction of Clackamas County. The County is not requiring sidewalk or any improvements along this frontage. CHAPTER 50: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE 50.02 BASE ZONING DISTRICTS 50.02.001 Residential Districts 1. Residential - Low Density Zones Kimball Street Development Page 3 of 38 a. Districts The residential-low density zone districts are R-15, R-10, and R-7.5. b. Purpose To provide lands for single-family residential development with densities ranging from two to five dwelling units per gross acre. COMMENT: The site (Tax Lots 100, 2902 and 3000) is located in the R-7.5 District. The applicant is proposing 5 lots through a series of lot confirmations and lot line adjustments for single- family residential development. 50.02.003 Special Purpose Districts 3. Park and Natural Area Zone a. Purpose The purposes of the Park and Natural Area (PNA) zone are to: i. Protect, preserve, conserve and enhance natural areas, greenways and parks; ii. Permit a wide range of passive and active recreational uses, and accessory uses, on property for the future use and enjoyment of the City and its residents; iii. Implement Statewide Planning Goal 8, Recreational Needs; and iv. Establish a master plan process for park planning and development. COMMENT: Waluga Park - West is located in the PNA District. The proposed sanitary sewer main extension is going through a portion of the park to connect to an existing main. 50.03 USE REGULATIONS AND CONDITIONS 50.03.002 Use Table COMMENT: The proposed single-family detached dwellings are an allowed use in the R-7.5 District. Public utilities (minor) are an allowed use in the PNA District. 50.04 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS 50.04.001 Dimension Table 1. Residential Low Density Zones a. Dimensional Standards Development in the R-7.5, R-10, and R-15 zones shall conform to the dimensional standards in Table 50.04.001-1 except as modified below. Kimball Street Development Page 4 of 38 Standard Required Proposed Density Minimum 80% of max Not applicable - lot line Maximum (2) adjustments Minimum Lot Dimensions Each lot line adjustment with Area (sq. ft.) 7,500 sf dimensions are noted below. Width (ft.) 50 ft Final lot area and width for Depth (ft.) -- each lot are: Lot 1: 9,607 sq. ft., 83.81 ft. Lot 2: 9,570 sq. ft., 83.26 ft. Lot 3: 44,059 sq. ft., 373.68 ft. Lot 4: 13,626 sq. ft., 97.23 ft. Lot 5: 13,594 sq. ft., 97 ft. Max. Floor Area Additional floor area Allowed: allowance per Lot 1: 4,323 sq. ft. Base calc.: 3,000 sq.ft. residential unit Lot 2: 4,316 sq. ft. +[(actual lot size - 5,800 providing a garage (sq. Lot 3: 10,869 sq. ft. sq.ft.)* 0.19] ft.) Lot 4: 5,086 sq. ft. 600 Lot 5: 5,080 sq. ft. Proposed: Specific house plans have not been selected for this development. Yard Setbacks All lots: Front 25 ft. Each lot will meet setbacks Street Side during building permit review. Arterial/collector 20 ft. Lot 4 is a new flag lot and will Local 15 ft. meet flag lot setbacks. Interior Side Total 15', 5 ft. min. Rear 30 ft. Maximum Lot Coverage Based on height of All lots: 50.O4.001.1.f structure Building plans and height unknown at this time. Lots 4 and 5 are flag lots and will meet flag lot standards. Maximum Base Height All lots: Flat Lot 30 ft. Building plans and height Lot with Sloping 34 ft. (5) unknown at this time. Lots 4 Topography and 5 are flag lots and will Sloped Lot 35 ft. meet flag lot standards. The development includes 4 successive lot line adjustments. Below is an explanation on how each lot confirmation and lot line adjustment step (4) meets required R7.5 lot dimensions. Lot Confirmation 1 and Lot Line Adjustment 1 The lot line confirmed is the property line between Lots 69 and 70 of Lake Forest. This line is then moved (adjusted) to the west. Tract 1 (Lot 1 - final dimensions) is 9,607 sq. ft. in area and is 83.81 feet in width. Tract 1 retains frontage on the Baleine Street ROW and Kimball Street Development Page 5 of 38 Kimball Street. Tract 2 (portions of future Lots 2 and 3) is 22,592 sq. ft. and is 196.57 feet in width. Lot Line Adjustment 2 Lot line adjustment 2 is between Tract 2 of LLA 1 (above) and Tax Lot 2902. This lot line adjustment also creates access and utility easements for the future lots. Tract 1 includes future Lot 2, Lot 4 and a portion of Lot 3 and is 36,217 sq. ft. and is 140.17 feet in width. Tract 2 (Lot 5 - final dimensions) is 13,594 sq. ft. in area and is 97 feet in width. This tract is considered an existing flag lot and will have access from an access lane within the shown 20' access and utility easement to the north and within the existing 15' access and utility easement on the property to west and a new 10-foot easement north of the existing easement. Lot Line Adjustment 3 Lot line adjustment 3 is between Tract 1 of lot line adjustment 2 and Tax Lot 100 (Lots 1 and 2 of Lake Forest). Tract 1 includes future Lots 2 and 3 and is 53,629 sq. ft. in area and is 466.78 feet in width. Tract 2 (Lot 4 - final dimensions) is 13,626 sq. ft. and is 97.23 feet in width. Tract 2 is a new flag lot. A parking easement is created with this lot line adjustment for Tract 2, the new flag lot, to meet the required parking standard for flag lots with an access lane. Lot Confirmation 2 and Lot Line Adjustment 4 The line confirmed is the line between Lots 1 and 2 of Lake Forest. This line is then moved (adjusted) to the west to create Lots 2 and 3 in their final dimensions. Tract 1 (Lot 2 - final dimensions) is 9,570 sq. ft. in area and is 83.26 in width. Tract 2 (Lot 3 - final dimensions) is 44,059 sq. ft. in area and is 373.68' in width. g. Height - Additional Standards A greater height than otherwise permitted is allowed for: i. Single-Family Dwellings Base building height may be increased by one ft. for every five additional ft. in yard setback on all sides, beyond the minimum code standards provided in Table 50.04.001-1 above. COMMENT: Specific house plans are unknown at this time. Therefore, the dwellings on Lots 1-3 will be required to meet height standards at the time of building permit. Lots 4 and 5 are flag lots and will meet height standards in the flag lot standards. 50.04.002 Special Street Setbacks COMMENT: Inverurie Road has a special street setback of 20 feet. The only lot that abuts Inverurie Road is proposed Lot 3. Due to the location of the existing wetland, there will be no structure near Inverurie Road and the special street setback will be more than met on this frontage. Kimball Street Development Page 6 of 38 50.05 OVERLAY AND DESIGN DISTRICTS 50.05.010 Sensitive Lands Overlay Districts 2. Applicability This section applies to all lands designated RP or RC on the Sensitive Lands Map, and lands designated HBA where an HBA protection area is established pursuant to LOC 50.05.010(7). a. Sensitive Lands Development Review Required i. Except as provided by subsections 2.b through 2.d of this section, development within: (1)The RP district, as defined in LOC 50.05.010.6.b; COMMENT: The RP district on Tax Lots 100, 2902, and 3000 has been delineated (LU22-0019 - See Exhibit 6). The area of the sewer main extension through Waluga Park - West and in the rights-of-way of Baleine Street and Inverurie Road have not been delineated and fully encumber the subject area. The applicant is not providing a resource delineation and accepts that the subject areas are fully within the RP District overlay. Therefore, the sewer main extension must comply with the RP District development and mitigation standards for the entire disturbance area within Waluga Park - West and the rights-of-way. This is addressed below. 3. Development Review The development review procedures for sensitive lands overlay districts are found in LOC 50.07.004.8. COMMENT: This application follows the review procedures in 50.07.004.8. 4. Generally Applicable Standards for Lands with RP Districts, RC Districts, and HBA Protection Areas d. Construction Standards An owner shall submit a construction plan and narrative to the City Manager prior to any grading, clearing, or construction on a development site which contains an RP or RC district, or where the owner received development review approval under subsection (7) of this section, Habitat Benefit Areas (HBA) Incentives. The construction plan and narrative shall demonstrate that the following standards will be met: i. RC protection areas or RC districts where no protection areas have been approved, RP districts, and protection areas within an approved HBA development shall be protected during construction with either: (1)A minimum four-ft. tall chain link fencing secured with a minimum of four-ft. tall steel posts. The fencing shall be in place and Kimball Street Development Page 7 of 38 maintained for the duration of construction. In addition, temporary signage shall be placed on the fencing which shall clearly identify the resource district and shall state the penalty for violations of this section; or (2)Such alternative method to subsection (4)(d)(i)(1) of this section that is approved by the City Manager to demarcate and protect the RCPA or RC/RP district from the adverse effects of construction activity upon the resources. ii. RC protection boundaries and RP district boundaries, as applicable, shall be located and staked by a qualified professional prior to placement of fencing and other protective measures. iii. Hazardous Materials. The site shall be inventoried for hazardous materials, debris and noxious materials, and these materials shall be removed prior to the development of the site. iv. No construction, demolition, grading, or site clearing shall begin until after protective measures, signs, and erosion control measures are in place and have been inspected and approved by the City Manager and all applicable permits have been issued. Fencing and other protective measures shall not be removed, even temporarily, without the permission of the City Manager. v. No stockpiling of fill materials, or parking or storage of construction equipment shall be allowed within a resource district. vi. When transportation facilities, pathways, utilities, or structures are approved within a delineated RP district, they shall be constructed in such a way that a minimum of excavation is required and so that no permanent draining or filling of a stream corridor or wetland will occur. vii.Surface runoff and other water sources supplying hydrology to an RP district shall be designed and maintained so as not to adversely impact the functions and values of the resource. viii. Any additional construction requirements imposed as conditions of approval or which may be required by the Development Standards, the Lake Oswego Building Code (LOC Chapter 45) or the Erosion Control Code (LOC Chapter 52). COMMENT: The applicant has provided the construction plans for the sewer main extension (See Exhibit 8). The RP District will primarily be protected by tree protection fencing, which is generally 6 feet in height. Additional fencing will be provided as needed to protect the RP District outside of the construction area. Erosion control will be provided along the construction area. The applicant understands that construction, grading, or site clearing cannot begin until after protective measures, signs, and erosion control measures are in place and have been inspected and approved. The proposed sewer main extension is proposed to be constructed by trenching within the RP district. The construction limits have been designed to 17 feet in width to minimize disturbance area and tree removal. The trench will be backfilled with the site soil and considered a temporary impact. The 3 proposed manholes along the alignment will have spoils that will be taken out of the RP district (off-site). Per DSL this is a permanent impact that requires mitigation. Kimball Street Development Page 8 of 38 Exhibit 23 LoveLOParks Customize 17 * 1 -I New Edit Page Insights © SEO 6 Howdy, Love LO Parks LOVELOPARKS ABOUT US OUR CAUSES LATEST NEWS RESOURCES C=10 atA 1. & TIMELINE HOME » CAUSES » SAVE WALUGA PARK » TIMELINE • V l Last updated: December 10, 2023 at 8:02am CONTENTS Timeline of events Since November 2, 2021, Mayor Joe Buck and City Council have failed their constituents by not asking one single question of City Manager Martha Bennett and City staff about any impacts Measure 3-568 or Measure 3-575 (both being Save Waluga Park voted upon that day) would have on LU 23-0002's proposed sewer line through Waluga Park - West; And again on March Timeline 17, 2022, when they approved LU 23-0002 in the consent agenda without any comment about Chapter X. Sometime between January 11, 2023 and one 22, 2023, the communicated construction method, boring, was changed to trenching, News thereby resulting in proposing to clear a 17' x 525' construction corridor removing 14 trees and all the natural habitat to install the sewer line - an unlawful action per Chapter X. The City Manager and City Attorney are willfully choosing NOT Post Card to recognize Chapter X - Park Development Limitation in the City Charter; a willful violation for this protected Nature Preserve. Poster Fundraising Did The Mayor and City Council know about this construction methodology change that is unlawful? And When? Submit Testimony As facts are discovered, this timeline will continue filling in and bring clarity to who knew what and when: What People are Saying! Jump to: 2021 2022 2023 Taking Action 2021 Yard Sign Oct 13, 2021 • Email from Todd Knepper (Engineering Program Supervisor, City of LO): • "...maybe it would be better to have a midpoint manhole within the park..." Protect Our Natural Parks • "...we can start talking about access to the overall sewer system and manholes, and if there could be access pathways that would also serve as Expand Hallinan Woods a maintenance access..." Save Cooks Butte • Email from Ivan Anderholm (Director of Parks & Rec, City of LO): • "The issues we have from the park perspective is that the original alignment would have required significant tree removal and would have placed a manhole in the wetland. There is really no vehicular access to the manholes, wetland unless there was a road built, not ideal for the natural resource." Oct 14, 2021 • Email from Phil Lawrence (Wastewater Superintendent, City of LO): • "Whatever we build we will really need some sort of access. We will not need a road but will need a access walking path wide enough for our equipment to the manholes. Nov 2, 2021 • Measure 3-568 ratified by 62% of Lake Oswego voters • Chapter X - Park Development Limitation becomes legally binding in the City Charter • LoveLOParks issues press release on Measure 3-568 passing • City issues press release on Measure 3-568 passing • "During the November 2, 2021 Special Election, Lake Oswego voters passed the Citizen's Initiative 3-568. Through voter approval, the City will amend Chapter X of the Lake Oswego Charter to include additional protections of our natural areas. Any future property-specific changes will include voter approval." • "I would like to give special thanks to all the community members engaged in the parks measure campaigns," Mayor Joe Buck said. "Love LO Parks elevated the issue of natural area protections for a broad set of acreage within the city. The City will continue to work together with the Friends Groups, Oswego Watershed Council and the community on the comprehensive approach needed to enhance ecological conditions throughout the City." • "The City will share more information about the charter amendment process in the coming weeks." No process was communicated. • City Council "tentatively" approves applicant annexation (AN 21-0003) in Ordinance 2874* (YouTube, Presentation*, Approved Minutes*) • Not one discussion about Chapter X, Measure 3-568, nor Measure 3-575 from Mayor Joe Buck, City Councilors, nor City Manager Martha Bennett • Erica Rooney, Public Works Director / City Engineer and Daniel Nguyen discussed impact to natural area (YouTube @ 1:40:20): • Erica Rooney_: "We do sometimes have to go through parks. And actually As long as they're accessible um it's actually a pretty good place for us because it works out well for" • Daniel Nguyen: "and we're able to do it without...with kinda preserving the natural areas in the area" • Erica Rooney_: "and in this case correct they want to start with the attempt to bore as opposed to open cut." Nov 3, 2021 • Email from Ed Brockman (Landowner's Representative) to Scot Siegel (Community Development Director, City of LO) • "This option makes sense to appease the concerns by the council and the public. We would develop 3 houses on septic instead of 5 on sewer...This plan avoids the path down Baleine and protects the wetlands. We might even donate the remainder of the property to Waluga Park." Nov 12, 2021 • Email from Scot Siegel (Community Development Director, City of LO) responding to Ed Brockman (Landowner's Representative) Nov 17, 2021 • Measure 3-568 Impact Report to Parks, Recreation and Natural Resources Board by Ivan Anderholm (Director of Parks & Rec, City of LO) Nov 22, 2021 • Email from Ed Brockman to Jason Loos (City Attorney) and Scott Siegel (Community Development Director, City of LO) • "... My client is willing to deed the 1.4 acres bordering Baleine to the city in exchange for being able to build two homes on the .62 acre Kimball lot. We already have a septic approval and we just did some more test holes and appears we could get another approval there. We have other ideas as well. We need to annex into the city to be able to have enough space to do anything. The county encumbered the property recently with an overlay that is extremely restrictive that would go away if we were in the city." 2022 Jan 4, 2022 • City Council considers tweaking voter-approved Chapter X Jan 15, 2022 • LoveLOParks issues press release condemning City Councils' plans to subvert the will of voters Jan 19, 2022 • Mayor Joe Buck issues statement that City will recognize will of voters • "Protecting our natural area parks and the overall enhancement of the ecosystem is a top priority for our City - as evidenced by our Climate Action Plan, the number of residents engaged in community-based environmental advocacy groups, our City investments in the enhancement and preservation of natural areas and by the passage of Measure 3-568 itself." Feb 23, 2022 • Hail Capital LLC (property owner) executes the deed covenant on property to be annexed that requires a sewer line through Waluga Park - West at the direction of the City. • City was not authorized per Chapter X to compel the property owner to execute an invalid deed covenant. Mar 17, 2022 • City Council approves applicant annexation (AN 21-0003) in Ordinance 2874* as part of the consent agenda (Approved Minutes*) • No discussion. Aug 15, 2022 • Email from Ivan Anderholm (Director of Parks & Rec, City of LO): • "I've visited the site in the past and walked it and have no issues with the sewer extension through West Waluga Park." 2023 Jan 11, 2023 • Pre-application Conference Applicant Statement* • Page 8: "The proposed sewer main extension is proposed to be constructed by boring within the RP district to minimize excavation so that no permanent draining or filling of the wetland will occur. Spoils from the boring of the sewer main will be taken out of the RP district (off-site)." *** Sewer construction method changed from boring to trench between these dates. While boring may or may not be allowed by Chapter X, trenching is prohibited by Chapter X *** Jun 22, 2023 • Applicant development narrative* • Page 8: "The proposed sewer main extension is proposed to be constructed by trenching within the RP district. The construction limits have been designed to 17 feet in width to minimize disturbance area and tree removal. The trench will be backfilled with the site soil and considered a temporary impact. The 3 proposed manholes along the alignment will have spoils that will be taken out of the RP district ( off- site). Per DSL this is a permanent impact that requires mitigation." Jul 19, 2023 • City publishes Notice of Application* for LU 23-0002 (website) Aug 2, 2023 • Lake Forest NA submits Positions of Opposition Sep 22, 2023 • City publishes Re-Notice of Application* Oct 25, 2023 • City publishes Notice of Decision* and Staff Report granting tentative approval Oct 31, 2023 • City publishes Anticipatory Notice of Public Hearing* Nov 6, 2023 • Lake Forest NA files Notice to Appeal Nov 10, 2023 • LoveLOParks Steering Committee & Lake Forest NA issue a joint press release condemning the City for violating Chapter X Nov 17, 2023 • City staff issue DRC Memo in response to written submitted testimony received • Charter Primacy.. City stands firm with their flawed opinion that the City Charter and Chapter X don't apply and specifically are not "...'applicable standards and criteria' upon which the Commission is to base an approval or denial upon" • Chapter X Limitation. • City fails to accept first mandatory requirement "all development within a Nature Preserve is consistent with the preservation of a Nature Preserve as a natural area" • City misinterprets Chapter X's allowing park sanitary facilities 'for public access and use' as allowing the installation of a major sewer line for a private landowner • City contends that the 17' x 525' habitat destruction and tree removal to create a construction corridor for trenching and installing a sewer line is not a 'road' Nov 20, 2023 • DRC Meeting 7:53pm - 10:48pm • 61 Written Statements in Opposition • 0 Written Statements of Approval / Neutral • Statement from Evan Boone (Deputy City Attorney) about Chapter X • Oral Testimony from Lake Forest NA (written testimony G-580, G-581) • Oral Testimony from Jim Bolland • Oral Testimony from Brad Home (LoveLOParks G-570) • Oral Testimony from Mike Louaillier (LoveLOParks G-571) • Written Testimony from LoveLOParks G-572 • DRC meeting continuance granted: Dec 18, 2023 @ 7pm • Continuance requested by Lake Forest NA due to "missing" pages and inappropriately redacted documents in the public record • Public testimony may be submit until Dec 18, 2023 @ 12:00pm Dec 4, 2023 • Written Testimony from Michael Kohlhoff G-587 • A thorough and compelling argument on Oregon's home rule city charter authority in the voters' and the clear intent of Chapter X's final authority for Nature Preserves Dec 8, 2023 • Supplemental Written Testimony from Michael Kohlhoff G-588 • Another substantive research based in case law • "...municipal charter provisions supersede and preempt contrary ordinances that can not be read as being consistent." Dec 9, 2023 • Written Testimony from Sierra Club (G-589) • "The plain text language of Measure 3-568, now Lake Oswego's City Charter Chapter X, is clear and concise that all development must be consistent with preserving a Nature Preserve." • "It is clear to us that this proposed development is contradictory to the act of preservation..." • "...we encourage the City of Lake Oswego to do the right thing...insure preserving this Nature Preserve." *Applicable Regulations sections in City documents and public meetings held by the Mayor, City Council, City Manager, and City staff fail to acknowledge city charter Chapter X land use limitations for Nature Reserves LU 23-0002 should never have reached this stage in the City's development process. Mayor Joe Buck and City Council should have rejected Ordinance 2874, annexing the aforementioned properties (An 21-0003), at the city council meeting on March 17, 2022, on the grounds the City directing the applicant to execute a covenant for a sewer line through Waluga Park - West was not compliant with Chapter X, effective November 2, 2021 . In fact, Mayor Joe Buck, City Council, and the City Manager should have inquired specifically about whether the two natural park measures (citizen-initiated Measure 3-568 and City's Measure 3-575) voters where considering on November 2, 2021, could have any impact on a sewer line through Waluga Park-West and advised staff accordingly in the temporary approval of Ordinance 2874. But, they didn't. Ultimately, the City Manager and Deputy City Attorney's failure to acknowledge Chapter X and direct City Staff shows their apathy toward the will of Lake Oswego constituents and the city's governing system - once again, demonstrating Lake Oswego voters were justified in ratifying Measure 3-568. It is now incumbent on the Development Review Commission to reject LU 23-0002 to comply with the City Charter, the City's governing authority. Edit STAY INFORMED. GET INVOLVED. SUBSCRIBE s LoveLOParks.org is managed by Lake Oswego residents who architected and supported the voter-ratified Chapter X - Park Development Limitation in Lake Oswego's City Charter. LoveLOParks remains as the steward providing oversight to hold the City accountable to Lake Oswego residents. Chapter X provides legal safeguards to insure all development in a Nature Preserve is consistent with the preservation of a Nature Preserve as a natural area. Copyright 2019-23 LoveLOParks, All Right Reserved info@loveloparks.org Mit 0 w u